Gaming & Gambling
19-S in Murcia: Agreement and Decree of the Governing Council of Murcia
Carlos Lalanda ·
19 September 2018 will go down in the annals of the gambling sector in Murcia. As “19-S”, being the day on which the Governing Council adopted several measures of varying significance in this sector subject to administrative intervention, which should nevertheless be distinguished: an Agreement, a Decree, and the commencement of the procedure for another.
We shall analyse the Agreement, but at the same time a Decree amending the Betting Regulations, which had already been going through the procedure for some time, was approved; and, in addition, another regulatory amendment is being initiated through a Public Consultation announced on the Murcia Government's Transparency Portal, for which the current deadline is 10 October.
The Agreement suspending the acceptance of applications for authorisation of gambling premises.
This is the most striking measure. Although the announcement was made on the 19th itself, it was necessary to wait for the Official Gazette of Murcia of 20 September, in which the Agreement was published with the following operative provisions:
“First. – No authorisations for the opening and operation of bingo halls, gaming halls and dedicated betting premises shall be granted, nor shall prior feasibility consultation reports be issued, in respect of applications submitted from the date of this Agreement.
Second. – This Agreement shall take effect from the date of its publication in the Official Gazette of the Region of Murcia and shall remain effective until an express agreement to the contrary is issued.
Such is the terse text. No more and no less. For some, a great deal; for others, little.
For there is a climate in which some exaggerate matters, and an alarmist, fearful or merely concerned perception of what public policies may be imposed today on gambling and gaming halls in the Autonomous Communities.
Content and limits of the Agreement
The Agreement is an act of the Government equivalent to an order or instruction that no new application files be processed, covering the 3 classes of premises, although gaming halls constitute the bulk. For various reasons set out therein, which boil down to our being in a phase of uncontrolled expansion. Not one more, for now.
But this Agreement is not a Regulation, and the Governing Council of the Region of Murcia cannot regulate or plan secretly and overnight the future and configuration of gaming halls or betting premises as authorised and extensively regulated activities under the provisions of the Law and the Regulations in force.
Government Agreements are one of the possible forms taken by the decisions of this administrative body and differ, both in nature and in effect, from administrative Regulations as such.
The Agreement approved certainly instructs civil servants to refuse to admit new applications or even to reject them, but not to suspend files already opened, which will continue their ordinary course. This is appropriate and consistent with the legal certainty that characterises the Spanish administrative legal system. The long-standing general principle that remains unshaken is that files must proceed and be processed in accordance with “the Law in force at the time the file is opened”.
The reference to the “feasibility consultation” procedure may seem strange, since in these cases favourable reports grant those making the consultation a right to the subsequent processing of the file, and a right to compensation even arises if action is taken contrary to the report. It therefore seems logical, within this exceptional situation, that the prior feasibility consultation procedure should also be mentioned and refused admission, just in case.
A separate matter is that we are facing a clear exception. And we wonder whether the Government can adopt such a measure contrary to the individual right of those subject to the administration to apply for authorisation when the Law and the Regulations allow them to do so. Without first having amended the Regulations. Some will consider, and may well be right, that this improperly disapplies the Regulations and infringes one of the basic Principles of Administrative Law: the prohibition on derogating from Regulations in individual cases.
The Government of Murcia may issue all the instructions it sees fit to its civil servants,,,,, but it cannot remove rights belonging to those subject to the administration (or their expectations, which is what properly exists before an application, according to case law). In short, this is an argument that will have to be advanced by those who intended on 19-S to apply for authorisation, and for their benefit the Secretary of the Governing Council recalls that they have a period of 2 months in which to challenge the Agreement before the administrative courts. Although, for now, we have some precedents that cast considerable doubt on their prospects of success; Agreements of this nature have previously been adopted by the Government of Murcia, such as the Agreement of 19 January 2001 suspending the granting of operating permits for gaming machines, which lasted a long time.
And no Court annulled that Agreement, if indeed it was ever challenged.
The Decree amending the Betting Regulations.
Another measure taken on 19-S was the approval of Decree 190/2018 amending the Betting Regulations of 2012, published in the Official Gazette of the Region of Murcia (BORM) of 21 September . This Decree has undergone a lengthy prior procedure and concerns principally the amendment of Article 19, on the authorisation regime for dedicated betting premises:
- The processing of applications, which must be submitted by betting operators, is divided into two stages, as under the Gaming Hall Regulations: the first concludes with the Report (favourable or unfavourable), which determines whether the application meets the regulatory requirements in the abstract; the second, once the adaptation works have been carried out, involves checking the legal compliance required for opening.
- A prior feasibility consultation regime is included which, if the outcome is positive, may serve to enable the immediate processing of the subsequent application; but it is not equivalent to an application and does not take priority if another is submitted first.
- The distance requirement in relation to other gambling premises remains 200 metres, but now extends even to those whose applications are being processed.
- The renewal regime is slightly amended, with the same periods as those for the general authorisation to operate betting, and with reference to the requirements of “these Regulations” (previously it referred to “the requirements applicable at the time of applying for renewal”).
- The type “B” gaming machines now installed on these premises may be multi-position machines, with a limit of 3 positions (it does not specify whether these are “3 positions per machine”).
- The circumstances in which alterations to premises require an application for prior authorisation, or in which prior notification is sufficient, are included.
Otherwise, the requirement for operators to have an address located in the Region of Murcia is removed (Art. 9); and, in betting operations, the requirement for exact multiples of the minimum stakes is also removed, those minimum stakes remaining €1 for single bets and €0.20 for combination bets.
In addition, this Decree adopts certain measures affecting both dedicated premises and gaming halls or bingo halls where betting machines are also present. Whereas until now there were virtually no physical restrictions on placement and control, two measures are now approved relating to access control and unlawful gambling by minors or prohibited persons:
- Betting machines must have a locking device, operated by the employees or persons in charge of the premises, which is deactivated when it has been verified that the player is not a minor or is not listed in the Register of Prohibited Persons.
- These machines shall be located in separate areas so that players must first pass through the reception service, and therefore identify themselves. In the same way as “special” machines are now separated in gaming halls, and access to the separate area is only permitted after identification.
This Decree and amendment enter into force after 20 calendar days, meaning that these measures must be adopted before 11 October.
The Proposal for a Regulatory amendment concerning gaming halls and other premises in Murcia.
Lastly, there is the Public Consultation procedure to amend other Regulations. This is a separate matter from the Agreement and Decree approved.
A Regulatory amendment is subject to time limits, safeguards and a procedure also fully regulated by the Law of 2004 on the Governing Council of Murcia, and the exercise of regulatory powers now begins, under Law 39/2015, with a public consultation addressed to all citizens and entities, inviting them to express their views on this amendment, which, for now, has only been outlined in broad terms. And this public consultation is the one the Government has made available to everyone, until this coming 10 October (see this link to the Transparency Portal page) .
From now until 10 October, companies, citizens, political parties, local councils, etc., may submit their opinions to the Government on the proposed regulatory amendment. In the accompanying Explanatory Memorandum, with a reminder of the large number of gaming halls and betting premises authorised in recent years, the proposal is summarised in the following paragraph:
\»This initiative responds to the need to rationalise this situation quantitatively, insofar as the growing increase in the supply of gaming halls and dedicated betting premises would cause imbalances and dysfunctions in the current economic equilibrium of this sector, focusing in this case on those particularly sensitive groups of users who require special safeguards or protection.\»
Thus, with this description, which allows us to discern forthcoming planning in space and time, the field of play is open, and now is the time to submit proposals and opinions on the matter to the Administration.
It is foreseeable, of course, that a Draft Decree will then be prepared, which must undergo the procedures and safeguards governing the preparation of general provisions, and that one or more rules will ultimately be approved, which must also comply with the legal system. We shall see how this match, which has only just begun, ends.
Madrid, 21 September 2018.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández