Gaming & Gambling

An accounting device in the Draft State Budget.

Carlos Lalanda ·

We heard the Minister of Finance say in a recent debate and subsequent interview that the General State Budget approved on her predecessor’s initiative was riddled with “accounting devices” that diluted the understanding and comprehension of certain ratios, with various undisclosed purposes aimed not so much at diverting funds as at concealing shortcomings or false promises.  She then qualified and clarified the expression “device”, replacing it with “artifices”, “fireworks”, accounting tricks in general.

In short, Spanish budgetary trickery, from which, as we shall see below, the Draft presented is not exempt, even as regards the Minister’s own Department.

 The revenue and expenditure of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling

From a financial and tax perspective, a Directorate-General within a Ministry does not generate “revenue” because it is not a revenue-collecting body, but it does incur expenditure, and it is this expenditure that is budgeted for each year in its programme.

In the Draft Budget for 2019, the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) appears under Expenditure Programme 496M, with an allocation of €6,567,200 (which includes staff costs, current expenditure and investments). And that is what it can “spend”.

The amount of this expenditure allocated to the DGOJ has nothing to do with the resources to be collected from the activities over which the DGOJ exercises its functions, which are vastly greater, but is the amount corresponding to the quantification of its own needs. This is the case with all expenditure centres.

Revenue collected from gambling activity.

 The gambling activities in respect of which the Directorate-General acts and has powers of action or intervention generate various resources for the Treasury, whether tax-related or otherwise, from companies or players which, being collected by the State, are included under various revenue headings in the Budget. In broad terms, they fall into several distinct groups:

  • The revenue generated, as income from assets, by SELAE’s profits (approximately €1,800 million is forecast for 2019) .
  • That generated by the Gambling Tax under Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling. This amounted to approximately €107 million in 2017.
  • That generated by administrative fees for services provided by the DGOJ itself. According to the DGOJ’s own report, these amounted to €15.4 million in 2017.
  • That arising from fines imposed in gambling matters (€9.9 million in 2017).
  • Lastly, that generated by players’ personal income tax (IRPF); and, on the part of companies, the Tax on Economic Activities (IAE), Corporation Tax, VAT, etc., which are the ordinary taxes applicable to any activity. These cannot be quantified in advance.
  • We do not include here the Gambling Levies on land-based gambling collected by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), Royal Decree-Law 16/1977, which add to their respective Budgets and together amounted to €1,094 million in 2017.

Under Spanish budgetary law, revenue is not assigned a specific purpose or destination unless a Law so provides (Article 27.3 of the General Budgetary Law), so that the resources mentioned above are mostly allocated to the general needs of the Budget (payment of pensions, civil servants, debt payments, transfers for education, healthcare, justice, and other general headings such as defence, the bureaucratic machinery in general, etc….).

In the economic activities of the Gambling Sector, only some of the above revenue headings are earmarked (they are used to finance specific expenditure), because a statutory provision so provides:

  1. – The Tax on Gambling Activities (excluding SELAE) , which is “provisionally” allocated to the Autonomous Communities where the players reside, a distribution that still contains certain technical inaccuracies which we shall not address here. (€58 million in 2017).
  2. The Gambling Tax generated and collected from SELAE in respect of its “pool betting on sports” licence is allocated to various statutory purposes (Third Additional Provision of the Gambling Law: to the Provincial Councils, the Professional Football League, the Football Federation, or this year to the Higher Sports Council, in percentages that vary each year (€49 million in 2017)

All other resources are allocated to the general expenditure account.

However, we shall see that, for the 2019 financial year, there is a new “earmarked” item in favour of the DGOJ.

The DGOJ’s administrative fees, a “multifaceted” concept

We shall address “administrative fees” in particular, which under Spanish tax law are clearly defined as levies in Article 2.2 of the General Tax Law (LGT)

“a) Fees are levies whose chargeable event consists of the private use or special enjoyment of public property, the provision of services or the performance of activities under public law which relate to, affect or benefit the person liable for the levy in a particular manner, where the services or activities are not voluntarily requested or received by the persons liable for the levy or are not provided or performed by the private sector.”

The concept is also clearly defined in the Law on Fees and Public Charges, and in detailed case law and legal commentary, leaving no room for misleading confusion. Let us recall the case of the “Gambling Levy” itself: everyone knows, and the Courts have reiterated, that it is clearly a Tax, not a Fee.

In Law 13/2011 on Gambling, when Article 49 set out the concept and the various categories of fees chargeable for services provided by the National Gambling Commission (subsequently by the DGOJ), several fell within that category (subparagraphs a) to e), corresponding to the tasks of granting general and specific licences, approving gambling platforms and technical systems, entry in Registers, inspections; but there is another, that in subparagraph f), which clearly describes a Tax as defined in tax legislation:

Article 2.2. c) of the LGT:

  • c) Taxes are levies imposed without consideration whose chargeable event consists of transactions, acts or events demonstrating the taxpayer’s economic capacity.

The “fee” set out in subparagraph f) is, moreover, very similar to the so-called “Telecommunications Levy”, which was declared “void” and, like that levy, it accrues as a percentage of gross revenue from gambling operations, irrespective of whether or not services are provided to the companies licensed by the DGOJ from which it is collected.

The amount of this item cannot be quantified precisely, since administrative fees as a whole amounted to €15.4 million in 2017, as we have said. We do know that, in respect of SELAE alone, this item amounted to €6.6 million in 2017 (according to its annual accounts)..

The Device

 A new “earmarked” item appears in the Draft Budget under examination, through the amendment of the wording of Article 49.5. f) in the Twenty-first Final Provision:

“  f) 0.75 per thousand of gross operating revenue, of which 25% shall be earmarked to strengthen the material resources, instruments and investments necessary to undertake prevention, communication, awareness-raising, intervention and remediation initiatives which facilitate responsible gambling practices and mitigate the undesirable effects caused by unhealthy gambling activity, as well as the preparation of studies, reports and research work on the subject”.

This is accompanied by a further Sixteenth Additional Provision which determines how to authorise this item, in addition to those ordinarily allocated to the DGOJ.

We may therefore congratulate the Minister on having managed, through this “accounting device”, to increase the funds available to the DGOJ by almost 50% (or even more) compared with the previous financial year. And we assume that they will result in an improvement for everyone.

That is, if the Budget for 2019 is ultimately approved with the proposed text.

Moreover, should someone decide to challenge this “fee” and a Court declare that this fee is a tax (and consequently annul it), ….. the allocations will, with complete certainty .. already have been spent!

Madrid, 20 January 2018.

Carlos Lalanda

More publications