Gaming & Gambling
Ada has “slipped up”
·
Allow me this play on words and the light-hearted opening remark, in a colloquial tone and with no intention to offend. “To slip up” commonly means “to make a mistake”.
It is not that I seek to claim any moral authority or power to censure the decisions taken by the Mayor of Barcelona.
The expression arises in connection with numerous enquiries we have received over the past two days concerning the validity of a decision taken by that Municipal Council (we no longer know whether it is a written resolution, a draft, or one that has been definitively approved), which has been reported in various media outlets.
These state, without documentary support, for example, that “Colau prohibits the opening of new betting shops in Barcelona” (El País).
We have had to provide legal advice on the matter to those who have requested it, reaching the conclusion that numerous individuals and entities connected to a greater or lesser extent with the matter have also publicly stated: the complete lack of competence on the part of that City Council, like any other, to limit the number of authorisations for the opening of gambling establishments in a city or territory within a particular Autonomous Community. Still less to prohibit or expropriate them.
This is a power reserved by the Constitution and the Laws governing Municipal Autonomy, which is also recognised in the Constitution, to the State and, through successive devolution over time, to each and every Autonomous Community.
In some cases (not Catalonia), the Autonomous Community has gone so far as to transfer a very specific part of this power to municipal councils. By means of a Law.
Thus, under the legal framework currently in force in Catalonia, any measure restricting these establishments falls within the remit of the Government of Catalonia, whose officials, as we also understand from other sources, must be hastily preparing another “report” on the disputed decision to set matters straight.
Furthermore, in Catalonia there are no “betting shops” in technical parlance (that is, premises devoted exclusively to this form of gambling), and this decision therefore appears to refer to gaming halls, bingo halls or casinos, the specific limitation of which has already been addressed by the Government of Catalonia in numerous Decrees and resolutions, and even by the Courts of Justice of Catalonia. For example, they have had to deal with the limitation adopted and in force for gaming halls throughout Catalonia: as a result of successive annulments, the Autonomous Community legislation currently in force only permits the authorisation of exactly 126 such premises, with a minimum distance of 1,000 metres between them. All these authorisations were granted a long time ago, and the last was granted by a court judgment, and they remain in force.
Against this background, unless we are mistaken, it seems impossible that any ill-informed person would seek to apply to Barcelona City Council for a new authorisation for premises of this kind, and it would suffice to refer that person, through the “single point of contact for Public Administrations” procedure, to the Government of Catalonia, which would immediately refuse it.
In short, we do not know what the legal basis for this initiative may be. Perhaps we are dealing with another piece of “fake news” of the kind circulating on social media, on which we increasingly find ourselves obliged to comment.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Madrid, 24 October 2019