Gaming & Gambling

Anti-gambling judges

Carlos Lalanda ·

We are sometimes asked whether the outcome of proceedings or an appeal can vary according to the values and subjectivity of the judges delivering judgment.

A recent judgment of the Toledo Administrative Court allows us to approach this subject, the matter at issue coincidentally being gambling. It also serves to highlight the crisis in media coverage and public opinion currently besetting gambling establishments, and gambling in general. And to gauge its influence on judicial decision-making.

Subject matter of the appeal

The appeal giving rise to the judgment concerned the validity of a fine of 11,500 euros imposed on the entity operating a gaming hall for having launched, “without authorisation”, a draw of the kind known as “random prize draws”, in which customers were offered a prize (the value of which is not recorded). Tickets were given free of charge to anyone who had spent more than 10 euros on certain products in the gaming hall’s catering facilities. However, the judgment presumes that there is evidence that the tickets were actually obtained by those who had gambled 10 euros or more on the machines on the premises.

The authority imposing the penalty considered such conduct to constitute a very serious infringement of the Castilla La Mancha Gambling Law, and the judgment itself confirms this. The operative part states this very clearly: “commission of the very serious infringement defined in Art. 26 a) of Law  2/2013-,… consisting of holding random prize draws without authorisation”.

But … what authorisation?

 Random prize draws do not require authorisation from the State or the Autonomous Communities.

A simple analysis of the modern and advanced Gambling Law in Castilla La Mancha, cited in many forums as an example of originality and technical rigour, confirms that that Law does not make random prize draws subject to administrative authorisation, but only to a “declaration of compliance”, which the gambling operator had indeed submitted.

The aforementioned Law states this clearly in its Explanatory Memorandum: the previous Law 4/1999, of 31 March, on Gambling in Castilla-La Mancha, had already removed the authorisation requirement following the transposition of the Bolkenstein Community Directive 2006/123/EC on the liberalisation of business services. This occurred in the First Additional Provision of Autonomous Community Law 7/2009 of 17 December:

“The organisation and holding of random prize draws for advertising purposes, type A or amusement machines with prizes and amusement arcades, within the scope established in Law 4/1999, of 31 March, on Gambling in Castilla La Mancha do not require administrative authorisation”

How, then, can the absence of administrative authorisation be classified as an infringement and penalised when such authorisation is not required? Since it is clear that something must have been confused or misinterpreted, we must examine in a little more depth the reasons why the Judge has chosen to uphold a legal impossibility in the case under consideration.

Random prize draws are not games of chance involving money, but merely advertising tools.

As a precaution, we consider it appropriate first to review the body of legislation underpinning random prize draws, which indicates that these are genuine “free draws”, awarding a prize to the winner, financed by those wishing to promote their businesses. In certain judgments, such as that of the Supreme Court (TS) of 5/10/1995, they were indeed classified as a “game”, precisely to establish the competence of the Autonomous Community, rather than the State, to regulate them where their territorial scope is confined to one such Community.

By the Royal Decree-Law of 21/11/1929, the Government of the time authorised draws held by Savings Banks to encourage deposits and investments in these institutions. In more recent times, since the State and its Lotteries Monopoly controlled all forms of draws, these were subject to its authorisation (although there were never any Regulations governing them as such).

Consumer Law took an interest in these practices from the perspective of commercial promotions, and under Law 7/1996 on the Regulation of Retail Trade they are addressed under the heading “Sales with gifts”; and also in Law 29/2009 on Unfair Competition. All of these seek to prevent misleading conduct towards consumers or third parties. The same applies to the Law on Information Society Services (LSSI).

However, the aforementioned Community Directive and its transposition into Spanish law dispense with administrative intervention precisely because participating users are not required to stake money.

The revenue-raising aspect of this practice has always appeared to be of greater interest to the public authorities, and has always been the ultimate reason for their intervention; generally, a levy is imposed consisting of a small portion of the prize, originally a tithe, 10%.

Law 25/2009 had already expressly repealed the authorisation regime at State level, while retaining the tax; and Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling excludes its application to random prize draws, which require neither authorisation nor anything whatsoever … but retains the taxable event under which the prizes in these draws are taxed.

Thus, we find no legal reason to penalise the absence of an authorisation which the business operator cannot apply for and the Administration cannot grant.

Random prize draws as a means of encouraging gambling.

To exhaust the analysis, there is another way of looking at the issue. It has been debated in some cases whether, when dealing with a promotional technique, or, in consumer terminology, the promotion of certain products or services, it is possible to organise random prize draws specifically to promote or encourage gambling, a question which has received different answers over time. For example, in Aragón, the recently published Regulations on Raffles, Tombolas and Random Prize Draws 56/2019 establish the conditions and prize values applicable to these draws as a means of promoting gambling premises. Failure to give prior notification or to comply with the detailed conditions, they state, constitutes a serious infringement. And this applies to Aragón.

Administrative intervention of this kind requires the legislation to specify whether an authorisation for the “promotion of gambling” is required and, clearly, what the consequences of the absence of such authorisation are (for promotion, not for “gambling”), which the Castilla Mancha Law certainly neither states nor specifies.

Accordingly, I do not see how the charge can be sustained on this basis either.

What, then, was the reason that led the judge to act so unjustly?

Contributing and decisive grounds for the ruling

The descriptions employed in the judgment to justify the unjustifiable are true “legal gems”, which would be merely anecdotal were they not a misfortune for the person penalised, who will always be able to say that” he ended up with an anti-gambling judge”.

I shall transcribe verbatim one of the arguments used in the judgment which tipped the balance of the decision:

“……it being particularly reprehensible that it was carried out (the random prize draw) with the aim of attracting customers who gamble rather than consume, insofar as this may contribute to encouraging addictive gambling in a sensitive location frequented by very young people. Since these premises are located in a busy shopping centre, alongside other premises offering healthy leisure activities, such as Cinemas and restaurants”.

Quite a statement of reasons (personal and subjective, but not legal)

Gambling business operators penalised for any reason in Toledo who wish to appeal may well assume that a wise course of action would be to wait for the allocation of cases and, as soon as they discover that theirs has been assigned to this Court, withdraw and run away.

Madrid, 24 July 2019

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez

More publications