Firm News

Attendance at members’ meetings by exclusively electronic means

·

Commercial Law Department
Loyra Abogados y Asesores, S.C.

The new economic and social reality arising from the COVID-19 pandemic has brought with it the need to hold and attend members’ meetings by electronic means, even exclusively, without any of the members being physically present at the registered office, a need which, as the pandemic has progressed, has acquired a permanent character in our legislation.

This possibility is not entirely unfamiliar, since the original wording of the consolidated text of the Capital Companies Law (hereinafter “LSC”), approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2010, of 2 July, and in force from 1 September 2010, already provided for the possibility of attending meetings by electronic means in Article 182, which apparently applied exclusively to public limited companies whose articles of association provided for it, although the Directorate-General for Registries and Notaries (hereinafter “DGRN”) recognised, in its Resolution of 19 December 2012, that private limited companies could also be permitted to provide in their articles of association for the possibility of attending meetings by electronic means, including videoconferencing. In such cases, the directors were required to describe in the notice convening the meeting the time limits, forms and methods for exercising shareholders’ rights, and could stipulate that the contributions and proposed resolutions which, in accordance with the LSC, those attending by electronic means duly guaranteeing their identity intended to put forward should be sent to the company before the meeting was constituted. However, at that time this provision did not apply to private limited companies, nor was provision made for the entire shareholders’ meeting to be conducted exclusively by electronic means.

It was not until the WHO declared an international pandemic and the public health emergency caused by COVID-19 arose in our country in March 2020 that the Spanish Government began to enact royal decree-laws containing urgent measures intended to contain the spread of the disease; these measures included temporary restrictions on the free movement of persons which also had a direct impact on commercial companies and, in particular, made it impossible to hold members’ meetings in person.

In this context, it is worth pausing to recall that a royal decree-law is a legal instrument emanating from the Government (and not from the Congress of Deputies, although it must subsequently be validated or ratified by the legislature within a maximum period of thirty days from its enactment), which has its basis in Article 86 of the Spanish Constitution and may be issued only in cases of extraordinary and urgent need, such as those we have experienced since March 2020.

Accordingly, the Spanish Government enacted the following royal decree-laws, which we briefly review below:

  • Royal Decree-Law 8/2020, of 17 March: Article 40.1 established, on a transitional basis, that “even where the articles of association have not so provided, during the state of alarm, meetings of the governing and management bodies of […] civil and commercial companies […] may be held by videoconference ensuring authenticity and a bilateral or multilateral connection in real time with images and sound of those attending remotely […]”. Although this legislation permitted meetings of companies’ management bodies to be held by exclusively electronic means, even where the company’s articles of association did not so provide, it did not clarify whether members’ or shareholders’ meetings could be held on the same terms.

  • Royal Decree-Law 11/2020, of 31 March: the worsening health crisis prompted an extension of the duration of the measures adopted in the preceding royal decree-law. This instrument strengthened the requirements for holding meetings of governing and management bodies by videoconference: “provided that all members of the body have the necessary means, the secretary recognises their identity and records this in the minutes, which the secretary shall send immediately to the email addresses of each of those attending […]. It also resolved the uncertainty surrounding members’ meetings, allowing these also to be held by electronic means where the same requirements as those applicable to governing and management bodies were met.
  • Royal Decree-Law 21/2020, of 9 June: this instrument extended the measures adopted by the preceding royal decree-laws until 31 December 2020, all with a view to avoiding meetings and gatherings of numerous people in confined spaces.
  • Royal Decree-Law 34/2020, of 17 November: it considered it essential that all capital companies which had been unable to amend their articles of association to allow meetings to be held by electronic means should be able to continue using these means throughout the 2021 financial year, safeguarding the rights of members who could not travel in person to the venue of the meeting, while retaining the requirements that the secretary recognise the members’ identities and record this in the minutes, which the secretary shall send immediately to the email addresses.

And so we come to Law 5/2021, of 12 April, amending the consolidated text of the LSC, in force since 3 May 2021. This Law, whose principal purpose was to transpose into our legal system Directive (EU) 2017/828 of the European Parliament and of the Council, of 17 May 2017, concerning listed companies, has been used to amend Article 182 of the LSC on a stable and permanent basis and to insert immediately thereafter a new Article 182 bis providing, for the first time in that legislation, for the possibility of holding members’ and shareholders’ meetings, as applicable, by exclusively electronic means, in anticipation of the royal decree-laws enacted on a transitional basis during the pandemic ceasing to produce the aforementioned effects from 31 December 2021.

In accordance with the foregoing, Article 3 of Law 5/2021 has amended the consolidated text of the LSC, in addition to certain aspects concerning listed companies, in the following terms:

  1. The wording of Article 182 has been updated (electronic attendance) by removing the express reference to public limited companies and thereby recognising the right of the other capital companies, namely, in addition to public limited companies, private limited companies and partnerships limited by shares (Article 1.1 of the LSC), to benefit from this possibility, which, as noted above, had already been accepted by the DGRN Resolution of 19 December 2012.
  2.  Provision has been made, through the inclusion of a new Article 182 bis, for members’ or shareholders’ meetings to be held by exclusively electronic means without members attending in person, provided that the following requirements are met:

a. This must be provided for in the articles of association. The amendment to the articles of association authorising the convening of exclusively electronic meetings must be approved by members representing at least two-thirds of the capital present or represented at the meeting.

b. The holding of exclusively electronic meetings shall be conditional upon the identity and entitlement of members and representatives being duly guaranteed and upon all members being able to participate in the meeting through appropriate means of communication enabling them to exercise their rights as members at such meetings, namely the right to attend and vote at general meetings (Article 93.c) of the LSC) and the right to information (Article 93.d) of the LSC). The directors must implement the measures necessary to ensure that these requirements can be met.

c. The notice convening the meeting shall set out the formalities and procedures to be followed for registration and compilation of the list of attendees, for the exercise of their rights and for the proceedings of the meeting to be duly recorded in the minutes. Attendance may not be made conditional upon registration more than one hour before the start of the meeting.

d. Responses to members or their representatives exercising their right to information during the meeting shall be governed by Article 182 of the LSC, that is, they must be provided during the meeting itself or in writing within seven days following the end of the meeting.

In view of all the foregoing and by way of conclusion, once the transitional period during which the royal decree-laws enacted during the pandemic produced their effects has elapsed, for capital companies to be able to hold meetings by exclusively electronic means, their articles of association must so provide and the requirements and conditions set out above must be met. Companies whose articles of association have not already been adapted accordingly must make the corresponding amendment to their articles of association in compliance with Articles 285 et seq. of the LSC, and must also observe the majority rule laid down in Article 182 bis.3 of the LSC.

 Read the article published in PDF

More publications