Gaming & Gambling

AWAITING SIGNATURE (article on the “Agreement” of the Council for Gambling Policy)

Carlos Lalanda ·

We have just learned the content of the “Agreement” of the Council for Gambling Policy drawn up at its meeting on 17 December. On the application of the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity and other aspects of regulatory rationalisation in the gambling sector.

In the Document we find repeated invitations to take and develop action, to simplify, align and unify concepts, to remove barriers. But ……  is this an “Agreement”?

Let us recall that this entire working process arose at the initiative of the Directorate General for the Regulation of Gambling, as a consequence of the obligations which the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity, enacted more than a year ago, in December 2013, created for all those involved in governance affecting economic activities.

This governmental action is amply justified in the Preliminary Conclusions of the Technical Secretariat of the Council for Gambling Policy, which are a true monument to the efforts made in this area. Issues have even been addressed which go far beyond the Law on Market Unity itself, and which have their origin and reference point in the Spanish Constitution, in the European legal order, and even in common sense ….but…. all this to arrive at an “unsigned Agreement”?

For my part, I have already mentioned in an opinion article and to those who have asked me that the Council for Gambling Policy, established under Law 13/2011 in an advisory capacity for specific purposes, was not the appropriate forum for achieving a truly practical outcome, which is what the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity seeks. The Council can produce “advice”, recommendations, well-founded opinions, and even “declarations”, as  in the case of 17 December.

But not “agreements” with legal significance, which is what the 2013 Law seeks, so that its wording and its mandates may have some effect. Agreements to be adopted, where possible, by the Sectoral Conferences (that is, within the framework of the interterritorial administrative cooperation bodies constituted around each economic sector), within very specific time limits laid down by the law, to record, and incorporate into the legal order, the commitments of the Autonomous Communities in matters concerning them.

The Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity does not seek to recognise, delimit or interpret  the specific powers vested in the Autonomous Communities in respect of each economic sector, including those revolving around games of chance, but rather to try to avoid the distortions arising  in practice from the differing ways in which those powers are exercised. The classic example of the Tower of Babel. The aim is not for everyone to speak the same language, but for it to be possible one day to build the great Pyramid.

The statutory time limits have been exceeded and, apart from a few isolated exceptions, no Autonomous Community has stepped forward to adopt measures to resolve the distortions about which many businesspeople complain (and which others applaud at the same time).

Declarations of intent, Appeals, Recommendations and even Warnings are welcome, indeed essential. Psychologically, they help a great deal. It is not even clear whether the Declaration of 17 December is  “signed”, that is, approved by the President of the Council, by all Council members, or only by those present, or whether any of them has expressed disagreement or a dissenting opinion.

The Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity, as a legislative instrument, not only establishes principles and courses of action but also introduces the requisite tools necessary to apply to the Courts for the fulfilment of its purposes. Before a judge or Court, however, we can only plead compliance or non-compliance with Laws, regulations, in short, legal rules, which are what we impose upon ourselves in the respective forums so as not to come to blows.

A real Agreement, a signed Convention, by many or by few, with more or fewer points of consensus, would have served this purpose.

This “Agreement-declaration” of 17 December does not even bear a signature.

ElRecreativo.com  and SectordelJuego

More publications