Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Chamber, Third Section) of 7 September 2017

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Chamber, Third Section) of 7 September 2017 dismisses the application for judicial review brought by the State against two provisions of Basque Country Decree 120/2016, approving the General Gambling Regulations of that Autonomous Community, the first concerning competence to authorise physical online gambling terminals, particularly the terminals of lottery operators SELAE and ONCE; and the second concerning horse race betting with certain elements extending beyond races in the Basque Country.

In both cases, either the issue was not properly presented, or the Basque Court has not adequately understood the grounds of the challenge, because its response seems to us manifestly confused.

As regards the first issue, concerning gambling terminals, there are in fact two distinct levels of analysis, since the perspective of the terminals that SELAE or ONCE may use for their respective lottery operations is one thing, and that of the terminals of other operators authorised by the State to operate online gambling as such is another. The Court confines itself to the perspective of SELAE and ONCE lotteries, which it considers to be expressly excluded from the application of the Decree under Article 2, such that the competence of the Autonomous Community does not extend to the terminals of these lotteries. There is no reasoning revealing the solution in respect of the others, leaving intact the Seventh Additional Provision of the Decree, which permits restrictions on the existence of terminals for other online gambling (whether falling within State or Autonomous Community competence), in accordance with the planning criteria of the Basque Government.

As regards the second issue, concerning horse race betting, the Court likewise does not uphold the application for a declaration of nullity of the Sixth Additional Provision, concerning betting on events where the betting pool is shared with an entity outside the Autonomous Community of the Basque Country, which is what has been happening “in practice”, prior to the approval of the Decree. The Court’s inconsistency here is glaring, since it confuses the subject matter of the bets (which may indeed be, and nothing prohibits this, races within and outside the Autonomous Community) with the transfer of the betting “pool” such that the totalisation of bets takes place outside the Basque Country and is carried out by other undertakings not authorised in the Basque Country, with a common betting pool originating from many different territories.

According to the judgment on this last point, this matter “had been regulated in this way in the Basque Autonomous Community since Decree 68/2005, of 5 April” and State competence is not infringed on the grounds that “…It is not sufficient that the gambling activity extends beyond the territory of a particular Autonomous Community without being national in scope…”. The fact is that, in cases of “transfer of a common pool” (where the betting operator is outside the Basque Country and even outside Spain), the Regulations are in fact giving carte blanche to a form of cross-border organisation and offering which, since Law 13/2011 on gambling, has clearly been subject to State law, and which, even before that, fell within the scope of criminal law and was defined as a criminal offence.

The two challenged provisions are consequently dismissed, and the State Counsel has not subsequently lodged an appeal in cassation against the judgment.

More publications