Gaming & Gambling

The Basque Mega-Regulation

Carlos Lalanda ·

Analysis of the Draft General Gambling Regulation of the Basque Country

We must state at the outset that this is not merely a General Regulation on games of chance, but a compilation of all the Regulations developed to date for the various business subsectors operating the different games, betting and lotteries in the Basque Country.

Its first part contains rules common to many of the games, but these are then followed by the specific Regulations for each of them, amended to a greater or lesser extent from those currently in force, one after another in a long chain.

Rather than a General Regulation, it could be described as a “Total” Regulation, a kind of regulatory “Code” of gambling and games, in which to search for and find any provision applicable to games of chance in the Basque Country. Upon its entry into force, virtually all the other sectoral Regulations currently in existence will be repealed. However, this is not exactly how it should be viewed, since we must recall the existence, “above” it, of the Basque Country Gambling Law and the need to assess the regulatory provisions against it, as in the case of the sanctions regime, whose raison d’être is to “complement” the statutory regime.

Nor is this the case “below” it, since several provisions announce subsequent, specific regulatory development in the form of a Departmental Order (including in the First Final Provision), thereby disregarding its principal purpose of being the sole and exclusive regulatory instrument. We shall have to await, for example, an Order developing certain technical conditions relating to the type approval of gambling systems or machines, another on  players’ accounts, and another on preliminary laboratory tests; in particular, gaming machines will require an Order determining the prices of games, prizes and playing times; bingo halls will require another to determine many of the characteristics of the game, or of its various forms, or the characteristics of special cards; gaming halls will require one to determine their characteristics; and another will be required to regulate certain characteristics of betting premises. This is in addition to those regulating the standard forms to be submitted, or the obligation to process applications electronically, etc.

It is not a Regulation consisting solely of “general” rules, in the manner of the antiquated yet still current Madrid Regulation of 1995, which survived the subsequent Gambling Law; nor is it in the manner of the General Decree of Castilla La Mancha of 2013, adopted to implement the new Castilian Gambling Law, which laid down general rules on the legal framework and authorisations for undertakings and establishments, subsequently requiring a further Order for each specific subsector. In short, this is a  “Regulation of Substance”: what we have before us is a true “Mega-Regulation”.

An overwhelming list of provisions

The task of analysing the Draft appears, to anyone attempting it, gigantic and overwhelming. 253 Articles (an all-time record in the history of gambling rules in Spain, and probably in those of the rest of the world).

8 Additional Provisions and 6 Transitional Provisions.

4 Annexes.

A considerable challenge and narrative, currently comprising 257 pages, without a single table of contents with page numbers to facilitate navigation through this monumental work.

How long will the passage of a Draft such as this take before its final approval? How many will dare to examine in depth and report on each and every provision proposed for approval? Let us recall that, in addition to the private parties to whom it is now being made available for representations, numerous administrative bodies and entities will have to report on its Articles.

Two examples. The Civil Code of 1889, with 1976 Articles, albeit much more succinct than those of this Regulation, was approved after almost 8 years of discussions and debates on the initial Draft. The Commercial Code of 1885, after 3.

It is frankly curious that, given such extensive and complex regulation, the Second Final Provision of the Draft stipulates that it will enter into force on the very day following its publication in the Official Gazette of the Basque Country (BOPV)!

New developments

With such a profusion of provisions, it is difficult to provide a complete list of the new developments introduced, although on this point the Explanatory Memorandum assists understanding on its first page, where  some of them are listed: the creation of the Technical Advisory Commission on Gambling; the possibility of conducting all procedures in person and electronically, and their simplification; the regulation of a “statute” for Basque men and women who gamble; the regulation of gambling advertising and promotion; the abolition of security deposits for the qualification of undertakings to operate, and the regulation of the Central Gambling Register. A change (increase) is introduced in the minimum distances between gambling establishments. Reference is also made to extending the range of establishments in which a player admission service must be introduced. Some of those mentioned are “new developments” in that they correct or amend the law currently in force. Others, however, are mentioned specifically as a “reminder” of the application of the Common Procedure: for example, applications will be processed in the order in which they are submitted where there are limitations or restrictions on authorisation. This is merely a transposition of this general principle of administrative law.

Rules concerning business operators, officials, players, prohibitions, rights and obligations; rules on sanctions, procedural rules, general principles, definitions, etc. To describe all the actual new developments entailed by this Draft, it will be necessary to “dive” into each and every one of the proposed Articles, which is not the purpose of this brief note.

Quick Guide

Some issues are particularly striking and concern the powers of the Government of the Basque Country, on which I cannot resist commenting:

1. The proposed “planning” of games is introduced as part of the General Regulation on gambling and games, although this subject is radically different in nature and subject to different parameters of scrutiny and rule-making. Several judgments have drawn attention to its distinctive nature and have annulled certain “planning” provisions for lack of justification. A “plan” has a temporal connotation and, given that it restricts business activity, must necessarily be justified from a protective standpoint, that is, not so much in terms of protecting business interests as those of consumers (in this case, Basque men and women). Everyone has in mind the recent statements by the National Markets and Competition Commission (CNMC) in favour of the freedom to provide business services, even in the field of games of chance, and its opposition to restrictions on authorisation.

2. The insistence on regulating the activities of Basque men and women on the Internet. This is somewhat difficult to understand in the light of the current position and nature of Autonomous Communities such as the Basque Country, within a constitutional system that is neither federal nor federated, for now. Seeking to prohibit someone from accessing websites, or to regulate how a web portal must prevent their access (Art. 17 or 21), or the advertising to be placed on websites (Art. 88), does not appear to be a  “territorial” matter within the competence of an Autonomous Community; the same may be said  of other formulations appearing here and there in the Draft in relation to  communication channels such as the Internet. It appears to be forgotten that the “personal status” of Basques, Catalans or Andalusians (their rights, obligations and duties in the context of the “civil freedom to gamble”) is not a matter that the Autonomous Communities may regulate, but rather the State. The Basque Country’s competence in relation to games of chance concerns establishments open to the public situated in the Basque Country. Not the private homes of Basque men and women, nor their personal computers or mobile phones.

I also offer some further general observations of interest:

3. Reading and analysing this vast text may be made easier by following this simple advice: leave the reading of Annexes II to IV until later, as these actually reproduce the particular rules of casino games and the particular types of events on which bets may be placed (102 fewer pages). Analysts should first focus on the rules for their own specialist field of activity (casinos, bingo halls,  betting, etc.),  and then turn to the general part, since in this way they will discard many of the general provisions that do not actually affect them.

4. Gambling in hospitality establishments. If analysts wish to investigate gambling in hospitality establishments, they should refrain from reading Articles 29 to 38. “Gambling premises” do not include hospitality establishments, which are referred to in other Articles. For the time being, they may continue to offer pintxos and tapas without any restriction.

5. Security deposits. Security deposits for the registration or qualification of undertakings to operate are indeed abolished. Do not look for them, as you will not find them. A “notification” will suffice for this purpose, although security deposits for “operation” will subsequently be required. A welcome transposition of the principles of the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM) to gambling business operators, even though the Basque Government has challenged the LGUM before the Constitutional Court (TC).

6. Taxation. Not a single Article refers to this subject, apart from Art. 253. It is obvious to say that its regulation is to be found in another “body of legislation”, although it would indeed have been useful to “consolidate” it (with 3 separate Basque tax authorities with separate rule-making powers, plus the entire body of legislation governing the Economic Agreement). In any event, and as an initial approach to the Draft, the effort made by the Basque Administration has been enormous, although it is only fair to include here an indispensable quotation from Baltasar Gracián:  “What is good, if brief, is twice as good”.

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.

www.loyra.com

Madrid, 4 March 2016

Article also published by AzarPlus

More publications