Finance & Fintech

Bitcoin and blockchain technology are here to stay

Patricia Lalanda ·

On 23 February, the European Parliament published the Draft Report on virtual currencies (2016/2007(INI)) the content of which indicates that, for this EU institution, Bitcoin and distributed ledger technology (DLT), or blockchain, are no longer at an embryonic stage, as most institutions and authorities have maintained until now, but are a global reality.

As is apparent from that document, the European Parliament's opinion is based on numerous earlier documents issued by the European Banking Authority, by the central banks of certain countries, by the European Police Office (Europol), by the Financial Action Task Force (GAFI), by the Commission and by the Council of the EU on strengthening the prevention of terrorist financing, among others. It is also based on studies on VAT and judgments of the Court of Justice of the EU examining the tax nature of virtual currencies; the consultation on investment by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), etc.

The European Parliament takes into account the following key facts:

  • There are more than 600 virtual currencies based on Blockchain(I understand that this includes the numerous projects that may be in incubation, since the number of which I was aware until now was considerably lower);
  • of these, the “parent project”, Bitcoin, accounts for 90% of the market, with a capitalisation of EUR 5 billion;
  • Blockchain has the capacity to process numerous transactions at high speed, meaning that the fintech sector can harness it for many uses; and
  • current investment in Blockchain exceeds EUR 1 billion in venture capital and corporate investment.

It sets out a list of advantages and risks arising from the use of Blockchain technology which may be summarised as follows:

Advantages

Risks

  • Contribution to economic development and consumer welfare by reducing payment transaction costs compared with traditional systems (total costs could be reduced by up to EUR 20 billion), as well as the costs of access to finance without a traditional bank account
  • Increased speed and resilience of payment systems owing to the decentralised system (even in the event of network problems or computer intrusion).
  • Low transaction costs and a high degree of privacy (without complete anonymity, with the possibility of tracing in the event of an infringement).
  • Bringing together systems that facilitate their use and/or combine the development of online micropayment systems, as a possible replacement for current systems (which require excessive data), and other payment mechanisms in a secure and user-friendly application.
  • Potential to accelerate, decentralise, automate and standardise data-driven processes, which could change the methods of asset transfer and record-keeping (implications for the private sector and for the public sector: as a service provider, supervisor and legislator).
  • Potential to deliver greater efficiency, speed and resilience in clearing and settlement processes and other post-trade management processes (which currently cost the global financial sector more than EUR 50 billion annually).
  • Potential of smart contracts.
  • Potential reduction of the significant VAT gap in the EU (currently EUR 168 billion).
  • Potential criminal use: money laundering, terrorist financing[1] and tax fraud.
  • Absence of flexible and reliable governance structures (particularly in Bitcoin), which could give rise to uncertainty and consumer protection problems. [2]
  • Sometimes limited capacity of regulators in the field of new technologies, making it difficult to define appropriate safeguards to ensure the proper and reliable functioning of Blockchain applications in view of their potential growth.
  • Legal uncertainty which may sometimes be subject to existing legislation, or there may even be a lack of appropriate regulation. (For this reason, Parliament once again stresses the need to increase regulatory capacity in view of its potential systemic relevance).

For all these reasons, Parliament recommends smart regulation with a view to fostering innovation and safeguarding integrity.

It emphasises the importance of not stifling innovation and of adapting the relevant Directives to Blockchain technology and virtual currencies.To manage all of this, it calls on the Commission to establish a task force to provide the technical expertise to support the efforts of the relevant public actors, at Union and Member State level, to offer a timely and well-founded response to the new opportunities and challenges arising from the introduction of Blockchain applications.
As regards the nature of this Draft Report, we must recall that such reports are neither binding nor directly applicable to Member States, but are an important working and policy tool for Parliament in the early stages of drafting legislation.
The impact of this document on the Council and the Commission will have to be monitored very closely, since there is no doubt that the days when Blockchain and virtual currencies were not on the agendas of Member State governments have come to an end.
Patricia Lalanda, 10 March 2016

[1]  Although Europol stated on 18.1.2016 that terrorist financing had not been confirmed by law enforcement authorities.

[2]  Particularly in relation to problems not anticipated by the designers of the original software.

Access to the text of the Draft Report:

More publications