Regulatory & Compliance

Blockchain and data protection legislation: a tense relationship

Patricia Lalanda ·

Since Satoshi Nakamoto released his famous paper “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” in 2009, informing the public of the creation of Bitcoin, Blockchain technology has been a phenomenon spreading across numerous fields. Its “recent” emergence and exponential development pose a genuine challenge.

  • WHAT IS BLOCKCHAIN?

Blockchain consists of a system that combines existing peer-to-peer networks (peer to peer or P2P) with advanced encryption techniques that ensure its transparency and privacy. In this way, this type of software enables any type of transaction to be carried out without the need for any intermediary, that is, on the basis of absolute decentralisation, with participants having complete control over those transactions. It should be noted that transactions do not necessarily have to be financial, but that would be a subject for another article.

  • HOW DOES IT WORK?

The main characteristic of Blockchain is that a “block” of data is created for each transaction carried out. Each block generated is connected to the preceding and subsequent blocks, thereby generating a chain of linked blocks, which is why it is given this name. An essential feature of its operation is that, for the blocks to be valid, the users (or, more precisely, the nodes) participating in each transaction must validate each of those transactions. This makes the chain irreversible, as each block added reinforces the verification of the preceding one. In this way, it remains free from manipulation, providing greater security, privacy and immutability.

  • WHAT PROBLEMS DOES IT POSE?

The conflict in relation to data protection arises from the clash between the nature of this type of technology and our current data protection legislation. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data (hereinafter, RGPD) has been in force since 2016. The RGPD was transposed into our legal system through Organic Law 3/2018, of 5 December, on the Protection of Personal Data and the guarantee of digital rights in 2018 (hereinafter, LOPDGDD).

This legislation presents itself as a genuine declaration of fundamental data protection rights in the digital sphere. The problem, of course, is that this new technology does not appear to be entirely compatible with all its provisions.

Below, we will examine some of the problems arising in this area.

  1. The IP address as personal data

The IP (Internet Protocol) address is a numerical identifier through which the Internet service provider can be identified, which, in turn, enables the equipment that has accessed the Internet to be identified.

Under the RPGD and the LOPDGDD, personal data means any information relating to an identified or identifiable living natural person. Although this definition does not make it entirely clear whether the IP address falls within it, both the Spanish Data Protection Agency and the Supreme Court have made their position clear, since the IP address ultimately enables a link to be made to a specific person and, consequently, constitutes personal data.

Although Blockchain does not use first names, surnames or other personal data each time the chain is accessed, entries and exits are recorded for each transaction carried out. It would therefore be possible to identify the owner of the connection.

This demonstrates how the blockchain, in addition to the data used for each transaction, requires the use of personal data that are recorded upon entry and exit following each transaction, and thus provides a further reason demonstrating the need for it to comply with data protection legislation.

  1. Absence of a data controller

Data protection legislation revolves around the existence of a data controller against whom the user may exercise their rights. The existence of a data controller is fundamental, as the controller is entrusted with responsibility for ensuring the effectiveness of data protection legislation and is liable in the event of non-compliance.

The nature of Blockchain, by contrast, as a peer-to-peer network, is characterised by absolute decentralisation. There is no party responsible for its creation; instead, all participants have control over each transaction. This makes it impossible for data subjects whose data are being processed to know who is using them and for what purposes, or to exercise the rights conferred upon them to safeguard this fundamental right.

  • A possible solution

One of the options being considered is the possibility of authorising or appointing one or more of the nodes to assume this role. However, this could be incompatible with the concept per se of decentralisation and the absence of an “authority”.

  1. On the rights conferred upon users under the legislation

Both the RGPD and the LOPDGDD provide in their texts for a series of rights conferred upon users whose data are being processed. These rights give data subjects the assurance that their data are being used correctly and for the lawful and legitimate purposes for which they were provided.

These rights are the right of access, the right to rectification, the right to object, the right to erasure (or the “right to be forgotten”), restriction of processing, portability and the right not to be subject to individualised decisions.

The use of Blockchain has a direct impact on the rights to erasure and restriction of processing. Below, we will examine how:

  • Right to erasure (or “right to be forgotten)

Article 17 of the RGPD provides that data subjects may request that the controller erase their data in a series of situations envisaged in the text.

On the one hand, as indicated above, the use of Blockchain technology entails, among other things, the absence of a data controller. The active participation of all users involved in each transaction means that there is no party authorised for these purposes.

On the other hand, one of the fundamental purposes of using Blockchain is to make it impossible for data to be altered unilaterally. This is known as data immutability, and it provides effective security for the transactions carried out.

The complexity of complying with Article 17 of the RGPD is not solely attributable to technical or design factors, since the information is encrypted and modifying it can be highly complex; there are also organisational difficulties. To achieve the purpose of this right, all participants would have to erase the data from their copies of the database. It is therefore the nature of this technology that makes the right to erasure or the right to be forgotten impossible to exercise, which constitutes a direct clash with data protection legislation.

  • Possible solutions

One of the solutions being considered to mitigate this problem is to allow one or more participants to modify the information. However, this could undermine its transparency. Another proposed solution is the destruction of private keys, so that the encrypted data would be inaccessible using a public key.

Nevertheless, it appears that a definitive solution has yet to emerge.

  • Right to restriction of processing

Finally, a series of problems arise in relation to the right to restriction of processing. This right enables the data subject to request that the controller apply measures to their data to prevent their modification, deletion or erasure.

In line with the problems arising in relation to the right to erasure, the immutability of data within Blockchain makes it impossible to give effect to this right. We must not forget that the blockchain entails the creation of an indelible database, meaning that the nature for which it was conceived and the rights that data protection legislation confers upon data subjects are not entirely compatible.

Although the solutions proposed to mitigate the clash between Blockchain and the right to erasure might to some extent be compatible with this right, at present we do not appear to have a clear solution in this regard.

  1. And now… a Metaverse?

The metaverse is a term that has been much discussed and written about in recent months. The company's change of name from “Facebook” to “Meta” and its aim of developing its own metaverse have driven and popularised this phenomenon.

What is the metaverse?

This concept comes from a novel, “Snow Crash” (1992) by Neal Stephenson, and is composed of the terms meta, meaning beyond, and verse, meaning universe.

Although the presentation of Facebook's own metaverse has accelerated the process and user participation in these spaces, there are already some platforms offering this service, such as Decentraland and The Sandbox.

The legal issues arising from the existence of the metaverse are numerous, and one of them concerns data protection. The complexity of the relationship between the metaverse and data protection legislation is reflected in the following two issues:

On the one hand, there is the close relationship between the metaverse and Blockchain technology. One of the premises underlying the existence of the metaverse is its realisation independently of an authority, that is, in a decentralised manner, meaning that Blockchain technology appears to be the most suitable means of achieving its objective. This raises the possibility of users being able to carry out financial transactions of all kinds without having to resort to conventional electronic purchasing methods. This is already a reality in the aforementioned Decentraland, where users can buy plots of land, build on them and sell them. The use of Blockchain technology in the Metaverse would bring with it the problems mentioned above.

On the other hand, users, by creating an avatar, can gain access and carry out any type of activity, not only financial activities but any action forming part of everyday life. In absolute terms, we could understand the metaverse as a datum in itself, a metadatum composed of millions of other data originating from participating users. The data that may come to be provided are inconceivable in comparison with the data envisaged by our current legislation, as they constitute constant information on the decisions, actions and transactions that a person undertakes in their daily life. These issues encompass potential problems of intrusion, as well as data traceability (i.e., each movement a person makes in the metaverse is a datum in itself, a datum that will be recorded and may become known).

The scale of the data that will be exposed in the very near future within the creation of this new universe, which goes beyond the one we know, is no small matter. As regards Blockchain, certain matters remain to be resolved in order to achieve effective protection of personal data, as some legal uncertainty continues to exist at present.

As regards a possible “second life” in the metaverse, ensuring the effective application of this fundamental right will be a genuine challenge and, in our opinion, will require a new approach to the concept and understanding of personal data.

Elvira Sebastià Puig (lead author)

Patricia Lalanda Ordóñez

LOYRA ABOGADOS

More publications