Gaming & Gambling
THE CANARY ISLANDS: AN EXAMPLE TO FOLLOW …. but not in everything.
Carlos Lalanda ·
Today we turn our attention to two extraordinary provisions adopted by the Government of the Canary Islands and published in the Gazette of 3 April in response to the Covid 19 coronavirus crisis, concerning games of chance, which, from the perspective of gambling businesses, bring both good and bad news.
On taxation, an example to follow. Decree-Law 4/2020, of 2 April
Following some initial tentative steps in the Order of the Department of Finance of 20 March, and that of 30 March correcting the former, the deadline for submitting the self-assessment for the first quarter of the Gambling Tax applicable to gaming machines in their various forms was extended until 1 June.
But the main issue remained: the establishments in which they are authorised and had been installed had closed from 14 March pursuant to the first Decree declaring the state of alarm, meaning that, if the taxable event did not occur for approximately 1/6 of the entire quarter, tax fairness required a reduction in the tax liability. This is what is approved in Decree-Law 4/2020, by reducing the tax liability proportionately, for example from 900 to 722 euros in the first quarter in the case of ordinary type “B” gaming machines. And with retrospective effect, because the tax had already accrued on 1 January. Without any other condition.
The Government of the Canary Islands is even empowered to set retrospectively the tax liability for the second quarter, which had also already accrued on 1 April, in an amount proportionate to the length of time for which the state of alarm remains in force. We do not consider this to be an improper delegation (tax liabilities may only be set by Law), but rather an instruction to perform a calculation that is fully predetermined by this Decree-Law.
It must be acknowledged that, in doing so, the Government of the Canary Islands complies with the constitutional principle of ability to pay, which very few Autonomous Communities have so far incorporated into their measures on this particular matter, and it is to be hoped that it will serve as an example.
On authorisations, the perception is different. Decree-Law 5/2020, of the same date.
A second Canary Islands Decree-Law of the same date reiterates the earlier Decree-Law 3/2020, of 5 March, which suspended (prohibited) the granting of authorisations for new gambling and betting premises. It also introduces other supplementary measures concerning gambling and betting, amending the Canary Islands Gambling Law in no fewer than 9 paragraphs. The question a layperson might ask is ……. what is the reason for reiterating the same measure in less than a month? Are the new supplementary measures related to the coronavirus crisis?
Well, spare yourselves the task of reading 6 pages of the Explanatory Memorandum and turn to the third page, which states the real reason that prompted it: the decision to suspend activities adopted by the Parliament of the Canary Islands owing to the unexpected effect of the Covid 19 coronavirus, which prevents parliamentary ratification of the aforementioned earlier Royal Decree-Law within the period of 1 month required by the Statute of Autonomy of the Canary Islands. The only solution arrived at has been to approve it again.
The Decision adopted by the Bureau of that Parliament on 16 March (Official Gazette of the Parliament of the Canary Islands of the same date) interprets the implementation of the state of alarm by the Central Government and the suspension of administrative time limits as extending to the legislative activities of the Parliament of the Canary Islands, whereas Article 116.5 of the Spanish Constitution states that “Its functioning (that of the Congress of Deputies), as well as that of the other constitutional powers of the State, may not be interrupted while these states remain in force (such as the state of alarm)”, which could readily be extrapolated to the functioning of the Parliaments of the Autonomous Communities. As it could to that of the Governments of the Autonomous Communities, which continue to function in essence, although some of their activities have been curtailed and taken over by the State.
This Decision of the sovereign body of the Canary Islands appears rather to be an abdication of its functions, thereby equating parliamentary activities with guided tours, conferences and extraordinary events held at its official seat.
We are therefore faced with a curious technique used by the Government of the Canary Islands in response to Parliament's legislative abdication: the reiteration of unratified Decree-Laws, in practice replacing the traditional separation of powers and nullifying the legislature, which is tantamount to legislating by Decree. A Decree-Law is an exceptional “Law in the formal sense” and requires parliamentary ratification, without which it becomes null and void. If Parliament does not ratify the Decree-Law within a month, for whatever reasons…… well, we shall approve another one, to serve for another month!
In this case, moreover, it would have been more appropriate, in my view, not to reiterate the prohibition. The profound economic repercussions that will result from the abrupt closure of all kinds of establishments and activities ordered because of the health crisis in which we find ourselves would probably have called for a measure in the opposite direction to the one reiterated. Rather than the suspension/prohibition of the granting of new authorisations and, ultimately, of the opening of new businesses, incentives will be needed to launch any activity, and without the customary bureaucratic restrictions.
The economic crisis looming over the services sector is so severe that the most logical course, given the impossibility of parliamentary ratification, would have been simply to declare Decree-Law 3/2020 to have lapsed, and to begin adopting economic recovery measures radically different from a prohibition on new activities, which the hospitality and entertainment sector of the Canary Islands, a territory almost entirely dependent on tourism, is going to need.
Specific amendments under Decree-Law 5/2020
Examining the provisions of the new Decree-Law, the only new element compared with the earlier prohibitive suspension is the replacement of the 18-month prohibition period with another fixed deadline, 31 December 2021, which is therefore further away in time. The granting of new authorisations for gaming machines in hospitality establishments, and in betting “corners” in bingo halls and casinos, remains excluded from the prohibition.
However, the measures additional to the original suspension are of a very different significance, and it is surprising that so much effort and urgency have been devoted to introducing them at this time, if we examine them closely:
- All references to the regulation of type “A” amusement machines (purely amusement machines or amusement machines without prizes) are removed from the Gambling Law, while regulatory control over type “A special” machines (amusement machines with prizes in kind) is retained. This is a matter that is not urgent but has, by its very nature, long been a foregone conclusion: this measure is a requirement dating back to the Bolkenstein Directive 2006/123/EC of the Parliament and of the Council, which regards the principles of freedom to provide services as applicable to all activities not classified as gambling activities involving wagering a stake. This Directive was transposed into Spanish law at the end of 2009 by State Law 25/2009, of 22 December, and any application of the Canary Islands Gambling Law to this activity could be considered null and void, with judicial protection available by virtue of the direct application of the Directive. We refer to our now longstanding comments on this issue, from almost 10 years ago: See <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">“The Bolkenstein Directive: application to games of chance in Spain” July 2010.
- The removal of regulatory control does not extend to promotional prize draws either, which should also be excluded from administrative intervention for the same liberalising reasons of European origin. As the State and many other Autonomous Communities have already acknowledged within their respective spheres of competence.
- The possibility is introduced for the Technical Gambling Commission to meet remotely rather than in person, a new feature undoubtedly prompted by the growing use of modern working practices reinforced by the health crisis. This measure could have been approved by an ordinary Decree (not with such urgency, of course). Although it is to be hoped that the travel prohibitions arising from the pandemic will be resolved shortly, and that it will not be necessary to use this way of working even once.
- Lastly, the Decree-Law concludes with the same Transitional Provision already included in the original Decree-Law, fortunately preserving applications submitted before the measure was adopted, which, according to the Explanatory Memorandum, comprise 10 for gaming halls and a further 3 for betting premises. This is logical and consistent with the general principles of law, since otherwise it would have been necessary to compensate the applicants. And, to some extent, it undermines the prohibition (because it will introduce new establishments when the intention was to reduce their number); but ultimately it will help meet the necessary demand for new business activities in the coming months for the economic recovery required in the face of the crisis that has broken out. It cannot be ruled out that, for this latter reason, another Decree-Law may be approved repealing the one now being approved.
Madrid, 4 April 2020
Carlos Lalanda Fernández
Loyra Abogados
www.loyra.com