Gaming & Gambling
Caretaker Government and Gambling
Carlos Lalanda ·
The start of the new term invites an overview of the paralysing political situation, to see whether anything can be extrapolated to the field in which we constantly operate: games of chance.
A radio panellist recently analysed the challenges and consequences of the Government remaining in a caretaker capacity, or becoming a fully empowered Government, albeit in a precarious position; and he identified 4 or 5 major issues on which to focus the differences for short-term decision-making. I shall follow his classification to apply the same approach to gambling:
- Brexit. As regards gambling, the principal consequence has already been stated, particularly in relation to online gambling: licensed companies domiciled in Gibraltar must relocate to a Member State, unless they have already relocated to Malta, Ceuta or Melilla. I would add that, in the event of “Brexit “the hard way”, those domiciled in the United Kingdom would also automatically be left without a legal basis. Another curious collateral effect: a major Trade Fair or Conference will move from London to Barcelona in 2020.
- The Supreme Court judgment concerning the “procés” in Catalonia. Obviously, this judgment has nothing to do with the gambling sector; other articles have already analysed the repercussions of hypothetical Catalan independence, which would be limited, given that extensive autonomy already exists and is fully exercised, in both administrative and tax matters. It is worth recalling only the exception: independence would affect online gambling, SELAE and ONCE.
- The distortions arising from the poor state of the world economy that is anticipated, and possible further deterioration in Trade and the global economy. Mr Trump's tweets or the crisis in Hong Kong do not affect Spanish gambling companies as they do American companies operating in Macao, for example, and only some of the most internationalised companies may be affected by a deterioration. Whether or not Spain has a caretaker Government makes little difference in this regard. But beware: contrary to the myth, when the Spanish economy performs poorly, the gambling sector also declines. And according to the panellist, under this heading, the best course is to clear the way for Government action.
- The Government's social agenda, which may gather pace or slow down depending on whether or not it is acting in a caretaker capacity. Differences between one situation and the other can be discerned here, since the adoption of measures on various issues that clearly attract media attention may be triggered in a more or less drastic or restrained manner: (ill-informed) measures on gambling advertising, on obligations relating to “responsible gambling”, and other similar matters are in the air, and may develop into storms or mere showers. In this respect, a caretaker Government is not the same as a single-party Government or a coalition Government.
- The approval, or otherwise, of a General State Budget, which may revive various aspects relating to games of chance that have been shelved owing to the lack of agreements or the quorums required for approval.
There are opinions to suit every taste, and many even argue that the economy, and the country in general, function better with a caretaker Government; and, as far as we are concerned, with the Directorate-General for Gambling itself also acting in a caretaker capacity.
Be that as it may, the concerns of those operating in this economic sector must also encompass a watchful eye on the new Autonomous Community Governments that are gradually being formed and arousing expectations.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Madrid, 12 September 2019