Gaming & Gambling
Castilla-La Mancha. Planning Back and Forth.
Carlos Lalanda ·
The Lord gave me… and the Lord took away from me, blessed be the Lord (Job, 1:1)
The Official Gazette of Castilla-La Mancha (D.O.C.M.) of 29 May publishes the Agreement of the Governing Council of Castilla La Mancha of 21 May, amending the “planning” for gambling establishments for 2019, approved in the Agreement of 19 December 2017, while retaining that for type B gaming machines.
This Agreement provided for a quota of 100 gaming machine authorisations each year for 2018 and 20190, which has been processed in the normal manner. As regards gambling establishments, the matter was deferred to a tender in each of those years, to award 10 licences each year; in 2018, this tender was launched and concluded without major controversy, and the tender for 2019, which had not yet been launched, is cancelled.
Background in Castilla La Mancha
In a Commentary we wrote on the aforementioned Agreement of 2017, we stated that the “planning” of gambling licences in Castilla La Mancha was a regulatory power conferred on the Governing Council of Castilla La Mancha by the Gambling Law of that Autonomous Community.
The planning of all or part of a business sector is a legal mechanism which limits the exercise of freedom to conduct a business, and is legitimate within the applicable structural legal framework, since, although freedom to conduct a business is enshrined in Article 38.1 of the Spanish Constitution (CE), and freedom to provide services and freedom of establishment in the EU legal order, they may correspondingly be restricted through planning on the basis of Article 131 of the CE and EU case law.
In gambling matters, the planning power relating to gambling establishments is usually laid down (for formal reasons) in sector-specific Gambling Laws, and is understood as a limitation included within the powers to intervene in business, a restriction on the granting of authorisations which are normally subject to non-discretionary rules; and it is established by conferring the powers to exercise it on the executive bodies of the respective Autonomous Community.
In Castilla la Mancha, the authorisation of gambling establishments is regulated and subject to non-discretionary rules under Title IV of Decree 85/2013, of 23 October, and the application and granting procedure refers, in Article 69 et seq., to Title VI of the Law on the Legal Regime of Public Administrations and Common Administrative Procedure (LPAC), now Title IV of the Law on the Common Administrative Procedure of Public Administrations (LPACAP); that is, applications may be made freely if nothing constrains or limits them.
In planning matters, Article 7(a) of Law 2/2013 on Gambling and Betting in Castilla La Mancha grants the Governing Council the power to plan gambling activities, understood as the power to limit them.
“a) To plan gambling and betting by setting objective criteria regarding the number, duration and social impact of each form of gambling.”
Agreement, but not Decree
There has always been doubt as to whether this “limitation” must be incorporated into the legal order through a regulatory provision or not. That is, whether it must be processed as a General Provision or whether this is unnecessary, which in Castilla La Mancha means that it is adopted by a “Decree” or an “Agreement” of the Governing Council, as prescribed by its Law on Government in each respective case. The difference is important, because in the first case the procedural safeguards are much broader and require a succession of procedural steps and formal requirements which are unnecessary for acts of an individual nature, even where they have multiple addressees.
The Second Additional Provision of the Gambling Law establishes that the powers specified in Articles 7 and 8 (Governing Council or Regional Ministers) must be implemented “by regulation”. This is a question which has not so far been the subject of judicial interpretation, since in most cases in which this planning restriction has been imposed in relation to games of chance, it has operated through regulatory provisions (except, coincidentally, in Castilla la Mancha, and in the Community of Madrid in relation to casinos, although this is how it has recently been characterised in an Agreement of the Consello de Galicia concerning gaming machine halls and betting premises).
This power is therefore a “regulatory” power, and the Plan must be drawn up as such: normally by means of a Decree allowing all kinds of rights to be safeguarded and, above all, allowing scrutiny of the reasons and grounds for a limitation which, we reiterate, is imposed on an individual right consisting of the pursuit of a lawful business activity that is initially free and extensively regulated.
“Planning” cannot be understood as a more or less elaborate whim within the “will” of the Government of the day, or as something adopted urgently for other reasons. A different matter, which is not planning but urgent intervention, is the suspension or prohibition of the granting of new licences, which also exists. And this normally requires a legislative formality, not merely an administrative Resolution or Agreement. This is what happened very recently, citing urgent circumstances, for example in Extremadura, through a Decree-Law of the Junta.
That being so, we had already stated that the Plan approved in Castilla La Mancha for 2018 and 2019, as in other cases in which limitations on the granting of gambling authorisations have been adopted by Agreement or Resolution in any other Autonomous Community, cannot be upheld on formal grounds.
Amendment by another Agreement
And now its provisions relating to 2019 are “amended” by another Agreement. But only as regards gambling establishments, “abolishing the quota”, that is, preventing any new authorisation, and again without any express statement of reasons.
It is true that Article 2 of the 2017 Agreement provided for a possible amendment:
“During the specified period, the planning may be reviewed if substantial changes occur in the socioeconomic circumstances taken into account for its adoption. In such a case, a study shall be prepared setting out the new circumstances, on which the Gambling and Betting Commission of Castilla-La Mancha shall issue an opinion.”
Some voices clarify that this had already been addressed at the Gambling Commission meeting of 30 April, but nothing is made explicit in the Resolution published in today's gazette.
The award procedure by tender had not yet been initiated in 2019. This means that, in practice, there are no “directly injured parties”, and consequently no applicants who would have had to be compensated either (under the principle of the Administration's liability for damages).
In short, in 2017 it was agreed to impose “planning”, which was nothing other than a restriction of rights, allowing the possibility of granting only 10 new authorisations, a possibility which is now eliminated.
For reasons of “faith”, as in the parable of Saint Job. What the Government of Castilla La Mancha gave in 2017, it took away in 2019.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Madrid, 29 May 2019