Gaming & Gambling

Castilla La Mancha. Resolution of 20/12/2016 of the General Secretariat for Finance and Public Administration

·


The Resolution of 20 December 2016
of the General Secretariat for Finance and Public Administration (D.O.C.M. No. 248, of 23 December) publishes the Decision of the Governing Council approving the planning of authorisations for the operation of type B gaming machines and gambling establishments during 2017. In summary, it establishes a maximum number of authorisations for machines to be installed, and a maximum number of gambling establishments open to the public.

Prior legislative context. A one-year plan.
Whilst the constitutional principle of freedom of enterprise is recognised in respect of business initiatives and activities in the gambling sector, it is also common knowledge that administrative intervention has been exercised, sometimes intensively, during this period, the beginning of which roughly coincides with the adoption of the Constitution. It is accepted and undisputed that the State initially, and subsequently the Autonomous Communities, have imposed restrictions on this freedom by making it subject to various types of prior authorisation, or by limiting the number of gaming machines, the opening of new establishments, etc. In this context, it also appears to be undisputed that any restriction must be supported by a provision having the force of law, which is then implemented through secondary legislation. This follows from Article 38.1 of the Spanish Constitution (CE), and also from the principles of freedom to provide services and freedom of establishment governing the European Union.
This is the case in Castilla La Mancha, which, first through its Statute of Autonomy and then through the Gambling Law of 2013, establishes these bases for intervention, imposing a system of prior administrative authorisation or, as in the case under consideration, limiting or restricting the grant of such authorisations or, more specifically, the “planning” of authorisations, understood as making them subject to a “plan” which, by its very definition, refers to objectives of a temporal nature.
In this case, the Decision relates to a period of one year, 2017, and to authorisations for the operation of gaming machines on the one hand, and to gambling establishments on the other.
Let us examine the measures adopted, some of their consequences and some of the legal uncertainties arising.

The case of gaming machines
For these authorisations for type “B” machines in Castilla La Mancha, the planning establishes “a fixed quota” of 150 new authorisations in addition to those already in existence. If the known number at the end of 2015 amounted to 8,574, the scope for obtaining new authorisations is approximately 1.7% of the total stock of machines in Castilla La Mancha. Applications must be submitted from 1 January to 15 February 2017; although, should part of the quota remain unallocated, a further period would be established from 1 July to 15 August.
There are essentially four requirements for companies wishing to submit an application: to be registered in the General Gambling Register; to have provided the applicable security deposits; to be up to date with the payment of gambling-related tax obligations; and not to have any type B gaming machines with temporarily deregistered status.
However, no company may apply for more than 10% of the total quota, meaning that it could apply for up to 15 new authorisations.

The case of gambling establishments
In this case, the so-called “fixed quota” amounts to a maximum number equivalent to 10% of the establishments authorised and active as at 1 January 2017, the total number of which is now estimated to be approximately 140, since it has increased substantially in recent years: 44 in 2013, 84 in 2014 and 105 in 2015. This momentum had been triggered by the new Gambling Law of 2013, which provided for a unified regime for gambling establishments that now includes both so-called gaming machine halls and establishments that previously offered only bingo, but which also expanded the range of gambling that could be offered in these establishments, even to games previously played only in casinos.
The definitive number of authorisations determined by the planning will depend on rounding the decimal figures to the nearest whole number. For example, starting from 143 existing authorisations, it will be 14; from 146, 15; from 139, 14.
Furthermore, in this case it is provided that, in order to achieve a wider geographical distribution, there may be only one gambling establishment in towns with 15,000 inhabitants or fewer; or, in other words, no further authorisation may be applied for in such towns where an authorised establishment already exists.
As regards the essential requirements for applicants, they must be up to date with the payment of gambling-related tax obligations in Castilla La Mancha.
Furthermore, to prevent the monopolisation of applications, it is provided that each company may apply for a maximum of 3 authorisations, a restriction which extends to related entities, as defined under the Corporation Tax rules. Lastly, additional conditions prohibit the transfer of those granted during this year, and provide for the possibility of converting other gambling premises (casinos, betting premises) into this category of establishment.

The consequences of applications exceeding or falling short of the established quotas. Direct award or competitive procedure.
As a principle common to both matters concerned, it seems clear that applications will be processed strictly in the order in which they are received in the Single Register. And that, if fewer authorisations are applied for than are offered, all of them will be awarded. Incidentally, there is an obvious typographical error in the text of the Decision published in the DOCM, which should refer to the situation where “……the number of applications does not exceed the maximum number…”. However, the consequences of this “undersubscription” would differ in the two cases indicated. In the case of machines, there are fixed application periods or “windows”, the first in January and February and the second in July and August; but in the case of establishments, there is no closing date, meaning that all authorisations applied for at any time will in fact be awarded provided that they do not exceed the number offered, whereas applications submitted at any time once all authorisations have been awarded will be refused.
On the other hand, if there is “oversubscription”, the Department of Finance and Public Administration has the discretion to decide to award additional quotas which could amount, respectively, to 3% of the number of machines existing as at 1 January 2017 and 5% of the number of premises authorised and active as at 1 January 2017.
As we have seen, these additional quotas would cover a maximum of 250 further machines in round figures, and 7 or 8 gambling establishments.
In the event that these additional quotas are awarded, the Decision provides that one or more public competitive procedures would be opened, with the Decision establishing in advance the rules governing the call for applications and the capacity requirements, the assessment criteria and the award criteria, both for the procedure relating to gaming machines and for the establishments offered in that procedure.

Effectiveness and/or entry into force.
An initial uncertainty appears to concern the date on which this Decision takes effect, since this depends on whether it is a “regulatory provision” or an “administrative act addressed to multiple parties”, which we shall examine in greater depth below.
If it is a General Provision, there is no departure from the general principle of law and administrative law concerning the entry into force of legal rules: entry into force occurs 20 days after publication, that is, on Thursday 12 January. In that case, it would be very difficult to reconcile this date with the application dates established by the Decision itself. If we add to this the need to rectify the typographical error referred to above, its entry into force may be delayed still further.
However, it might perhaps be argued that it is not such a provision, but rather an “Act” of the Governing Council and is therefore subject to the rules governing administrative acts. This is what appears to be suggested by its publication in the “Other Provisions and Acts” section of the DOCM, with a notice of appeal rights as though it were an administrative act. In that case, it would take effect immediately upon publication in the DOCM.
We shall attempt to resolve this uncertainty below.

Provisions, alternatives and compatibility with the legislative framework.
In the case of gambling establishments, it will be essential to publish the number of gambling establishments authorised and active as at 1 January, and this will probably be done by means of a simple Notice in the DOCM; but also the number of gaming machines as at that date, in case it is decided to open the subsidiary competitive procedure.
The decision to call one or more competitive procedures in either case is framed as a discretionary power available to the Regional Minister, although reasons must necessarily be given for it. This power is broadly framed, although limited by the criteria for its exercise set out in advance in the Decision itself.
Thus far, everything appears to fall within a logic inherent in the basis for the restriction, and within a solution adopted from a range of possible alternatives; nevertheless, there are certain difficulties in affirming the complete lawfulness of this decision, which is complex in its nature and grounds. I refer to the requirements that this planning power ought to meet.
As an initial point, it should be noted that a competitive procedure as a means of granting authorisations is not provided for in the Gambling Law of Castilla; and Decree 85/2013, which regulates the general regime for enabling authorisations, provides for it only in certain subsidiary cases involving gambling casinos. But there is more.

The requirements for gambling planning in Castilla La Mancha.
As we have already seen, and as the Decision expressly reminds us, it is possible to adopt measures restricting or planning the supply of games of chance, and in this case Article 7(a) of Law 2/2013 on Gambling and Betting in Castilla La Mancha grants the Governing Council the power to plan gambling activities, that is, the power to restrict them.
“a) To plan gambling and betting by setting objective criteria in respect of the number, duration and social impact of each type of gambling.”
However, there has always been uncertainty as to whether this “restriction” must be incorporated into the legal system by means of a regulatory provision. That is, whether it must be processed as a General Provision or whether this is unnecessary, which in Castilla La Mancha translates into its adoption by means of a “Decree” or a “Decision” of the Governing Council, as prescribed by its Government Law in each respective case. The difference is important, because in the first case the procedural safeguards are much broader and require a succession of procedural steps and formal requirements which are unnecessary for acts of an individual nature, even where they are addressed to multiple parties.
The Second Additional Provision of the Gambling Law establishes that the powers set out in Articles 7 and 8 (Governing Council or Regional Ministers) must be developed “by regulation”. This is an issue which has not hitherto been the subject of judicial interpretation, since in all cases in which this planning restriction in gambling matters has been imposed, it has been implemented through regulatory provisions (except, as it happens, in Castilla La Mancha and, in relation to casinos, in the Community of Madrid). It is also clear that, where this power is conferred by the various Autonomous Community Gambling Laws on the Governing Council or an equivalent body, it may not be delegated to subordinate bodies.
Lastly, the planning provision or decision must be duly reasoned, whether it is an act or a Provision; and the Decision discussed here omits any reference to this substantive requirement.
All the foregoing reservations will be of no consequence if business initiatives do not exceed the numerical limits agreed, and we hope that the measure will serve the aims and objectives which it appears to pursue in relation to “supply”.
The entry into force of this Resolution is subject to alternatives: if it is a General Provision, 12 January 2017; if it is an administrative act, 23 December 2016.

More publications