Finance & Fintech

Ceuta and Melilla: what the law says

Patricia Lalanda, Cristina Romero, Fernando Martín ·

A strictly legal reading of the status of the Autonomous Cities and its effects on legal certainty for investment.

In recent weeks, public statements have once again been made that call into question whether Ceuta and Melilla form part of Spanish territory. The political debate is not new, and it is not for a law firm to intervene in it. It is, however, appropriate to clarify a separate and strictly technical question, which some investors and international operators have put to us: what is the legal status of the two cities, and what consequences does it have for the legal certainty of those who decide to establish themselves there?

From the perspective of positive law, the answer is unequivocal.

1. The constitutional framework

The Spanish Constitution of 1978 vests national sovereignty in the Spanish people as a whole and proclaims the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation (Article 2), entrusting the Armed Forces with guaranteeing territorial integrity (Article 8.1). Ceuta and Melilla are integrated into that framework through the route provided for in the Fifth Transitional Provision of the Constitution itself, implemented by Organic Law 1/1995, of 13 March, on the Statute of Autonomy of Ceuta, and Organic Law 2/1995, of the same date, on the Statute of Autonomy of Melilla.

It is worth highlighting a rarely discussed consequence of this placement within the constitutional structure: Article 2 is contained in the Preliminary Title, meaning that any alteration to the territory of the State would require the special amendment procedure under Article 168 of the Constitution—approval by two thirds of both Houses, dissolution of the Cortes, ratification by the newly elected Houses and a referendum of Spanish citizens. There is therefore no bilateral, diplomatic or treaty-based route permitting the disposal of sovereignty over these territories. No Government, acting alone, has the legal competence to do so.

2. A system of administrative autonomy, not sovereignty

The Statutes of Autonomy of 1995 confer administrative autonomy on both cities within the Spanish legal system, with more limited powers than those of the Autonomous Communities and without legislative powers of their own. Their institutional activities are governed by the same rules that structure the Spanish public administration: Law 39/2015, on the Common Administrative Procedure; Law 40/2015, on the Legal Regime of the Public Sector; Law 19/2013, on Transparency; and, in the field of gambling, Law 13/2011, of 27 May, on the regulation of gambling, together with Royal Decree 329/1996, of 23 February, on the transfer of State functions in relation to casinos, gambling and betting.

In short, this is administrative decentralisation within the unity of the State, not a cession of sovereignty or a distinct international status. For that reason, the comparison occasionally drawn with Gibraltar or other territories has no basis: their constitutional and historical circumstances are different in nature.

3. The international dimension

Ceuta and Melilla do not appear on the list of Non-Self-Governing Territories maintained by the United Nations pursuant to Article 73 of the Charter. The request made in 1975 for their inclusion was unsuccessful, and since then no international body has opened any proceedings concerning their status. Gibraltar, by contrast, does appear on that list: the difference is not rhetorical, but a matter of record.

Added to this is the prior existence of the titles. Melilla was incorporated into the Crown of Castile in 1497, and Ceuta, taken by Portugal in 1415, passed to Spain under the Treaty of Lisbon of 1668; both situations predate the formation of the present Moroccan State and were recognised in successive treaties concluded with the Sultanate, including the Treaty of Wad-Ras of 1860. A political claim, however often repeated, does not in itself constitute legal title or open a procedural avenue under international law.

4. Territory of the European Union

Pursuant to Article 52 TEU and Article 355 TFEU, Union law applies to the territory of the Kingdom of Spain and, accordingly, to Ceuta and Melilla. Protocol No 2 to Spain's Act of Accession of 1985 establishes special arrangements for customs and indirect taxation—hence the Tax on Production, Services and Imports (IPSI) instead of VAT—but does so precisely on the premise that both cities form part of the territory of the Member State. Their residents are Spanish nationals and, therefore, Union citizens, with identical rights and protections.

5. Judicial protection and predictability for investors

The tax regime—a Corporation Tax relief under Article 33 of Law 27/2014, increased from 50 to 60 per cent by Royal Decree-Law 22/2026, of 1 September, pending parliamentary validation; a personal income tax (IRPF) deduction pursuant to Article 68.4 of Law 35/2006; and IPSI as a local tax authorised by State law—is likewise Spanish State law, in force since 1955, overseen by the Tax Agency and compatible with the European framework. It is not an exception to the legal system, but an internal economic adaptation provided for within it.

Conclusion

For those considering establishing a presence in Melilla or Ceuta, the relevant issue is not the noise generated by public statements, but the regulatory architecture. And that architecture is that of the Spanish State and the European Union: the same Constitution, the same administrative laws, the same courts, the same European citizenship, and a constitutional amendment procedure that makes any modification of the territory legally unavailable.

At LOYRA, we have been assisting gambling operators and technology companies in establishing themselves in Melilla and Ceuta. Our assessment, in exclusively legal terms, is that the applicable framework offers the same degree of predictability and protection as any other part of the national territory.

Patricia Lalanda Ordóñez
Partner, Loyra Abogados

This article is for general information purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For specific matters, we recommend an individual analysis of each case.

More publications