Gaming & Gambling

Change of Government and Gambling

Carlos Lalanda ·


Last Saturday we woke up to a new Prime Minister. And this very week there will be new Ministers.

We ask ourselves whether this means that, in the short and medium term, anything will change in a heavily regulated sector subject to extensive intervention, such as gambling.

Living as we do in a State governed by the rule of law, our first recourse is to trust in legal certainty. We must therefore review the legal framework within which this activity operates and the foundations on which this intervention rests; and, as far as possible, undertake a predictive exercise.

Statutory and constitutional framework

In Spain, intervention by the public authorities in this sector is two-headed: one part falls within the competence of the Central State and is numerically the smaller (State gambling and online gambling), while the other falls within the competence of the Autonomous Communities and is the larger (land-based gambling in establishments open to the public).

Hence, first of all, we must point out that the change in the national Government affects a smaller part of this intervention.

From the perspective of this being a business activity, the general principles applicable are freedom of enterprise and freedom to provide services, both enshrined in the Constitution and the EU Treaties.

A change of Government such as the one that has taken place by no means entails an amendment to the Constitution or to the Treaties with Europe. Consequently, we are not facing a paradigm shift in the current framework for intervention in gambling.

Regulatory changes under way and planned amendments

In light of the foregoing, we must analyse whether this abrupt and unexpected change of Government may lead to a change in the current direction of legislation or regulations.

The principal legislative change currently being processed at State level is the amendment to gambling taxation included in the 2018 General State Budget Bill, approved by the Congress of Deputies and awaiting approval by the Senate at its sitting on 19 June. This is a relatively significant amendment which reduces the rates of gambling tax for online gambling and grants certain tax benefits to Ceuta and Melilla, which could constitute a kind of “pull effect” encouraging certain online gambling companies to establish their registered offices in these Autonomous Cities, coinciding also with the forthcoming “Brexit”, which includes Gibraltar and requires some entities registered there and licensed in Spain to change their registered offices. The Bill also contains an amendment to the exemption threshold for the special levy on lotteries, this time under personal income tax (IRPF). The three sectors concerned (online licensees, the territories of Ceuta and Melilla, and SELAE) should not change their expectations, bearing in mind that the new Prime Minister expressly undertook to respect the passage of this Law through to completion.

The regulatory amendments under way may indeed be affected, particularly the long-awaited Regulations on Online Gambling Advertising, the passage of which seems never-ending. The draft Decree was shelved in 2015 upon the dissolution of Parliament and taken up again in 2017; a new head of the Ministry within which the Directorate-General for Gambling sits may pursue approaches in this area very different from those now extensively debated and almost definitively settled in the text. All the more so if we consider the recent non-legislative motions adopted in the Congress of Deputies and the Senate on this matter. Regrettably, Regulations which are necessary under the Gambling Law itself may once again be consigned to “the limbo of the just”.

The other regulatory amendments being processed at the instigation of the Directorate-General for Gambling are those which complete the third call for applications for general online gambling licences. With the application period currently open until December, many potential applicants are awaiting those amendments before making their decisions. The call for applications can only be understood and completed in conjunction with the processing of the Ministerial Orders amending the various games (which was announced as imminent), and the Order on strengthening player safeguards and control over online gambling. Although nothing prevents the continuation of these procedures already initiated at the instigation of the Directorate-General for Gambling, the new Minister should take swift action in this regard or extend the application period.

And this is irrespective of a change in the holder of the office of Director-General for Gambling, which is the most likely outcome in the context of a change in the political colour of the Government.

Medium-term changes. Elections and resulting maps.

The medium term is much more unpredictable, in all scenarios. In addition to the mandatory elections in the Autonomous Communities next May 2019, national elections will be brought forward, most probably to this very year, 2018, or to next year. The only Autonomous Communities unaffected by this constraint are Catalonia, the Basque Country, Galicia and Andalusia, which are free to set their own electoral timetables.

Gambling policies, always within the constitutional framework referred to above, and in view of the shifts between political parties, may change markedly in the medium term, both at State and Autonomous Community level.

And there is considerable uncertainty in this regard, since, apart from a few very specific statements, the approaches and proposals of the main political parties in this area are unknown, or even erratic. Significant efforts to engage with the centres directing party political action will be necessary and advisable, in all areas.

Several amendments to Autonomous Community gambling laws are currently under way which could be affected to varying degrees (the Valencian Community, where the process is most advanced, but also Galicia or Murcia); to this must be added the disruption arising from a recent judgment in Illes Balears, which may also lead to some legislative change. And the exceptional legislative amendment in Extremadura to introduce large leisure and gambling complexes (known as “Legio”).

The application of numerous sector-specific regulations  and the ongoing processing of amendments to several regulations require a minimum degree of continuity in the Autonomous Community Government teams which promoted them, and could likewise be affected if those Governments also change.

In many cases, a substantial proportion of the problems and needs of this economic segment have been addressed through regulation. Whether the policies adopted by those responsible in the Autonomous Communities in recent years have taken root within their respective spheres will be highly decisive for their continuation, and this remains to be seen.

One final prediction: the map of the national Parliament and the parliaments of the Autonomous Communities will be highly fragmented in the near future. As a consequence, radical legislative and regulatory changes in the gambling sector will be very unlikely.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Madrid, 4 June 2018.

More publications