Gaming & Gambling
The child who won the \»el Niño\» prize
Carlos Lalanda ·
What could happen did happen. In the lottery called “el Niño”, run since time immemorial by the Spanish State and latterly by SELAE, the odds of winning the first prize in this year’s draw were 1 in 100,000 (as 100,000 numbers had been issued)
And although the odds are very slim, anyone who places a bet can win, which is why this and other draws or bets based on chance are so popular. However, these odds are cancelled out or reduced to 0 in the case of a minor, because minors cannot place bets.
Unless they do place bets. And then the odds remain very slim, the same as those of all other bettors, but they may win on occasion.
This is what has happened, according to the news reported in every newspaper, with the exuberant joy of a young first-prize winner, including the obligatory photograph in some media outlets, described with delight and joy.
The boy is proud that he is going to spend part of the money on gifts for his parents.
The nullity of the betting contract.
If what is being said is true, the reality is that the lottery contract does not exist, and this would oblige SELAE, at most, to refund the stake to the minor’s parents….. without paying the prize to anyone.
This is one of the consequences arising from the application of the Spanish Civil Code to the case, because one of the basic requirements for contracts has not been met: consent by a person with the capacity to enter into them, which a minor does not have in this case (Articles 1261 and 1263 of the Civil Code). This also occurs in the case of persons deemed to lack the capacity to gamble, redesignated as “excluded” or “prohibited” persons, and entered in the official registers.
Although this is probably not the only consequence, because under Law 13/2011 on the Regulation of Gambling, which applies without exception to lottery games, the following constitutes a serious infringement:
“Art. 40 b) Allowing access to gambling activities to persons who are prohibited from doing so, in accordance with Article 6 of this Law, provided that the gambling operator knows or ought to know that such prohibitions apply.”
The first consequence described is not an idea of my own: one need only turn to a recent judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid of 30 May 2017 in which it was held that the holder of a winning ONCE lottery ticket was not entitled to receive a prize of 35,000 euros, nor was ONCE obliged to pay it, because the bettor who presented himself to collect it was included in the Register of Gambling Exclusions of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) (that is, just like a minor, he could not validly place a bet). This ground for nullity, which is expressly incorporated into the regulations governing ONCE games, is generally unknown to the uninformed public at large.
As for the second, one need only look at the sustained media campaigns targeting the alleged admission of minors to gambling in premises authorised to admit the public in several Spanish cities. These campaigns take it as understood that this is reprehensible conduct subject to an administrative penalty. As in the case of the minor who won a prize in el Niño, such cases are very exceptional, but, as we can see, conspicuous.
Outcome
It is time to acknowledge and reflect on these realities: that the obligations and prohibitions in the basic rules governing games of chance apply equally to all types of operators and games, and that all of this must be taken very seriously.
Of course, it is very likely that the winner’s parents will ultimately go to collect the prize, stating that they were the ones who bought the one-tenth lottery ticket, but then the news would become something akin to lottery “fake news”. Beware: in the case of the judgment referred to above, ONCE did not believe the ruse that the excluded person’s wife had bought the ticket, and kept the 35,000 euros.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Madrid, 6 January 2018.