Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the CJEU of 16 October 2025: “A shot that backfired”.

Carlos Lalanda ·

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has delivered judgment in Joined Cases C‑718/23 to C‑721/23 and C‑60/24, following requests for a preliminary ruling submitted by the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community.

I. Context and Subject Matter of the Main Proceedings

The main proceedings arise from a series of actions brought by several operators of gaming halls, amusement arcades and gaming machines against the Conselleria d’Hisenda i Model Econòmic of the Generalitat Valenciana. The purpose of these actions was to secure the annulment of various provisions of Valencian regional legislation on gambling and the prevention of gambling addiction, specifically Decree 97/2021. Although they also appeared to seek the (indirect) annulment of several provisions of Law 1/2020 (involving the High Court of Justice (TSJ) in referring questions concerning infringement of European law to the CJEU), or to the Constitutional Court (TC) (questions concerning constitutional infringement)

The applicants argued that the regional legislation (or rather the statutory provision), by imposing restrictions, constituted an unjustified restriction on freedom of establishment (Article 49 TFEU) and the freedom to provide services (Article 56 TFEU).

The contested provisions (which are all contained in the Law, but not directly in the Decree) mainly concerned:

1. Minimum Distances: A requirement to maintain a minimum distance of 850 metres between gaming halls/betting premises and certain educational establishments, and 500 metres between certain gambling establishments.

2. Renewal of Licences: Retroactive application of the minimum distance of 850 metres to existing gaming halls applying for renewal of their licence or authorisation.

3. Moratorium: Introduction of a moratorium for a maximum period of five years on the granting of new operating authorisations and licences for gambling establishments and type B gaming machines.

4. Restriction on Operation: Prohibition on renewing authorisations to operate type B gaming machines on hospitality premises following the entry into force of Law 1/2020.

5. Advertising Restrictions: Restrictions on gambling advertising and promotion at regional level.

II. The Reference for a Preliminary Ruling …a form of “`kicking the can down the road” by the TSJ of the Valencian Community?

Although the reference to the CJEU was initially interpreted by many as a prelude to the TSJ of the Valencian Community accepting the appellants’ arguments, at the time it seemed to me to be a kind of delaying excuse on the part of the Spanish court deciding the case, which was and has proved to be a “double-edged sword” whose consequences will extend to many of the restrictions imposed to date in the Valencian Community and in the other Autonomous Communities, both in a manner “unfavourable” to the various gambling operators, although also “favourable”, as an incidental consequence, in some instances, as we shall see below.

The CJEU declares some of the questions referred inadmissible at the outset, and does not rule on others, owing to the inconsistency or vagueness with which the Valencian Court raised them, probably motu proprio, through being unaware of and failing to specify certain elements of the challenge.

In fact, there was a risk that the reference for a preliminary ruling might have been declared inadmissible in its entirety, since it should be recalled that the action directly concerned several articles of Decree 97/2021, which did not in any way implement the provisions of the Valencian Gambling Law alleged to be in breach.

III. Questions on Which the Court of Justice Does Not Rule.

The Court of Justice decides to limit its analysis and does not rule on the interpretation of Articles 26 TFEU and 56 TFEU.

• Regarding Article 56 TFEU (Freedom to Provide Services): The Court applies its settled case-law, noting that where a national measure concerns several fundamental freedoms simultaneously, it is examined in the light of only one of them if the others are entirely secondary. In this case, since the Valencian legislation lays down requirements for establishment and for obtaining authorisations to provide services, that legislation was considered to constitute primarily an obstacle to freedom of establishment (Article 49 TFEU), its effects on the freedom to provide services being merely a consequence of the restrictions imposed on the former.

• Regarding Article 26 TFEU (Market Unity): The Court observed that the main proceedings do not concern the competence of the European Union or its institutions to adopt the measures provided for in that article.

IV. Questions Declared Inadmissible

The Court of Justice declares inadmissible the fourth question referred for a preliminary ruling in Cases C‑718/23, C‑719/23, C‑721/23 and C‑60/24, and the second question referred for a preliminary ruling in Case C‑720/23.

These questions concerned whether the national legislation (minimum distances, moratorium and advertising restrictions) was contrary to EU law by imposing obligations only on privately owned gaming halls but not on those that are public establishments. They also asked whether this distorted competition in the sector.

The circumstances leading to their being declared inadmissible can be summarised as a failure to comply with the requirements laid down in Article 94 of the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice:

1. Lack of a Definition and Legal Framework: The referring court did not define the concept of «public gambling establishments» to which it referred.

2. Omission of Applicable Restrictions: Nor was the applicable national legal framework for those public establishments provided, or the restrictions potentially applicable to them set out.

3. Irrelevance of the Public/Private Distinction: The Court noted that the restrictions to which the questions related (casinos, bingo halls, gaming halls, etc.) do not apply according to whether the establishments are public or private, but according to the territorial scope of the regulation (national or regional), depending on the type of gambling. Accordingly, it could not be considered that there was a single market for the various types of gambling such that different regulation would undermine competition.

In other words, the intended issue was not properly raised: the intention was to bring SELAE and ONCE games into this matter, or perhaps also because the contested Decree does not address anything relating to these operators.

V. Decision on the Merits (Article 49 TFEU)

However, the Court examines the remaining restrictions (distances, renewal and moratorium) in the light of Article 49 TFEU, and, contrary to what the appellants sought in the judicial proceedings, the CJEU finds no grounds for incompatibility with Community law; in fact, it “bounces” the final decision back to the Spanish court that referred the question, namely the TSJ of the Valencian Community …could anything else have been expected?

Restriction on Freedom of Establishment: The Court confirms that the measures at issue (distance requirements, the obligation to comply with those requirements upon renewal, the prohibition on renewing authorisations for machines on hospitality premises, and the moratorium) constitute restrictions on freedom of establishment, since they make the pursuit of the economic activity less attractive or impossible.

Justification and Proportionality: The restrictions are acceptable if they are justified by overriding reasons in the public interest and comply with the principle of proportionality.

• Public Interest Objectives: The Court recognises that the objectives pursued by the Generalitat Valenciana (protection of minors, reduction of exposure to gambling in everyday life and near educational establishments, combating the exponential growth in establishments, protection of public health and mitigation of social and health risks) are overriding reasons in the public interest capable of justifying the restrictions.

• Proportionality (General Conclusion): The Court concluded that Article 49 TFEU does not preclude the Valencian legislation (minimum distances, restrictions on the operation of type B gaming machines and moratorium).

This conclusion is based on the premise that it is for the referring court (the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community) to verify whether those restrictions in fact:

1. Are suitable for ensuring attainment of the objectives pursued.

2. Do not go beyond what is necessary to attain them, which means that they must reflect an effort to achieve those objectives in a consistent and systematic manner.

The European Court offers guidance for this assessment, indicating that:

• The existence of other measures (such as the prohibition on access by minors) does not automatically render the distance measures unnecessary, since the purpose of the distances is to prevent overexposure to and the normalisation of gambling in everyday life.

• Applying the new distance obligations to establishments already in operation upon renewal of their licence is not necessarily disproportionate, particularly if a period is allowed for relocation and conferring a competitive advantage on existing operators is avoided.

• The five-year moratorium is not disproportionate a priori, provided that it reflects a genuine desire to truly reduce gambling opportunities and is not inconsistent with the existence of other forms of gambling that are not entirely prohibited.

VI Conclusion No. 1. “Kicking it back”.

If there are any circumstances that would allow the restrictive measures to be declared null and void on grounds of their disproportionality, these must be assessed by the Court of Justice of the Valencian Community itself. If the TSJ of the Valencian Community “kicked the can down the road”, the CJEU “kicks it back”.

However, we have already noted that the subject matter of the action is Decree 97/2021, which does not implement any of the restrictions in the Law examined by the CJEU. In other words, its annulment on that ground would be inconsistent.

VII. Conclusion No. 2. “The Fall of a Myth”

The reasoning in the CJEU judgment, even though it has been something akin to being “extracted with forceps”, since the restrictions are contained only in the Law and are not decisive for the determination of an action confined to a direct challenge to a Decree, does not, from the perspective of European law, invalidate, a priori, the restrictions on distances from educational establishments that are in place or have been introduced by the provisions of many Autonomous Communities. Something for the various interests involved in this dispute to bear in mind.

VIII. Conclusion No. 3. “An Indirect Positive Knock-on Effect”

From the perspective of the interests of operators owning gambling establishments, by contrast, the restriction on the distance between gambling premises has been validated from a European perspective; although already upheld by numerous Spanish regional courts, it was disputed in others where it was not supported by a formally enacted Law. It is difficult to understand how this almost “settled” issue came to be among those referred to the CJEU, since the opposite outcome would have been catastrophic.

IX. Conclusion No. 4. “A Change in the Landscape Is the Best Solution”

It transpires that the amendment to the Valencian Gambling Law effected by Law 7/2023 by the new Regional Parliament, of the opposite political persuasion to that which passed the original Gambling Law, has changed the landscape as regards the application of the restrictive measures to which the Court refers. The distances from educational establishments (850 metres) and other premises (500 metres) remain in force for new establishments seeking authorisation, but do not constrain those already authorised. The same applies to the restrictions on gaming machines. To such an extent that most of the provisions contained in Decree 72/2021 have been deprived of practical effect (almost all the articles of Chapter I, on the relocation of premises, for example).

The Valencian Court will therefore now have to devote itself to an even more substantial task: deciding, as the CJEU instructs it, on the “proportionality” or otherwise of certain restrictions from a purely “theoretical” perspective (with no practical application whatsoever), and on others that will entail considerably more work: among other things, ruling on the possible referral to the TC of a question as to the constitutionality of the Valencian Law, which had also been raised by the parties.

It is even possible that, faced with such a vast and complex adjudicative task, it may decide not to deliver judgment on the merits. And thus leave everything as it is.

From the perspective of any interested party who considers themselves adversely affected by a provision, in order to obtain a practical solution, ultimately it is far more effective, as I said in another article, to await a change in the legislative majority that embraces their arguments. And even to vote to bring that about.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Lawyer at Loyra Abogados.

17 October 2025.

More publications