Gaming & Gambling
At last, a coherent proposal
Carlos Lalanda ·
We have recently seen a flood of parliamentary, media and all manner of proposals and motions put forward by political parties and their spokespersons in various forums concerning gambling in Spain and improvements to its regulation.
Most have no practical effect, being impossible, absurd, untimely, mere wishful thinking, or simply propaganda. Yesterday, however, there was a publication in the [1] .
As a curiosity, and as evidence that we are dealing with a problem for which a solution is within reach, the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) has implemented a simple computer application for cases of “self-exclusion” (from gambling, that is, “self-inclusion” in the Register), which can even be used on a mobile telephone by installing a simple app. Although not everything could be quite so perfect, since it can only be downloaded from Google Play, being installable only on “Android” systems https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.appjuego.
The problem of the multiplicity of these Registers has already been addressed at several meetings of the Gambling Policy Council, which brings together and has among its objectives the coordination of all action in this field.
For the time being, its “general coordination” has been unsuccessful for various reasons: technical matters, political will, the blindness of the actors involved, etc.… in my opinion, all preceded by a fundamentally mistaken approach to the legal nature of these Registers.
Prohibitions, self-prohibitions, self-exclusions, and Registers
This subject is more complex than it appears.
It is one thing to prohibit a person or group of persons from gambling in general (e.g. minors, or persons declared legally incapacitated by a court), or specifically in certain cases (directors or employees of gambling undertakings in their own games, certain gambling authorities, sportspeople or referees); and another to deal with “self-prohibition”, which nobody, not even the courts, has yet managed to interpret precisely: a temporary waiver of a civil right, conditional, brought within an administrative framework, etc.
General statutory prohibitions (and the consequent penalties for non-compliance) can be complied with in ways that do not require a “special register”. Minors do not even have the capacity to contract for gambling services. To prove that someone is of legal age, for example, it is sufficient to produce a document, and there is no need for a “Register of minors”.
However, if the intention is to compile a list of the other “prohibited persons”, a “Special Register” becomes necessary, populated with judicial documents (persons declared legally incapacitated, or prohibited by a court decision imposing the restriction of civil liberties), or documents of another kind, although in some cases these partial prohibitions do not entail a corresponding obligation to register in any Register (by way of exception, prohibitions affecting directors and gambling business owners, relatives, etc. must be registered by means of a declaration by holders of State online gambling licences, and these are “partially prohibited persons”)
Finally, “self-prohibited persons”, who have been defined in legislation since the decriminalisation of gambling in Spain in 1977, under a very particular solution that can only be implemented in practice because Spain has a highly conducive legal identification system (through a compulsory, standardised and universal national identity document, or DNI), which does not exist in every Country.
“Self-excluded persons”. Until the State legislation on online gambling of 2011, self-prohibition was understood solely as an “administrative” legal mechanism, but the practices of the new operators, most of them from the English-speaking world, began to pave the way for “contractual self-prohibition”, which takes effect only between the contracting parties and is recorded in private registers. It is as though traditional casinos or bingo halls had an office where an individual decides to have themselves registered so that they will not be admitted at times of clouded judgement or loss of willpower (as indeed exists in some countries where there are no “registers”)
The Motion of the Socialist Parliamentary Group therefore concerns the coordination of the “Autonomous Community and State Administrative Registers”, which record and register those persons who have acquired the status of “prohibited persons” by being registered for one reason or another, and because this is also prescribed by the various rules governing prohibitions, as well as those governing registration. These Registers require urgent “coordination” to avoid the absurdity of someone voluntarily deciding and declaring that they consider themselves “self-prohibited” in one Autonomous Community, but not in the neighbouring one.
I would instead propose genuine “unification”.
Coordination or Unification of Registers
It seems to me that the Proposal under discussion does not go far enough; and that the real problem, namely the exchange and collection of data between the various Registers (in other words, a problem of bureaucratic management), should not be confused with the constitutional distribution of powers.
No one has spoken out in these terms, framing this problem in relation to the freedom to gamble (or its waiver for any reason), which by its nature is not “territorial”, but strictly personal. The regulation of “prohibited persons” has successively been included in the respective Gambling Laws, mistakenly without controversy, as though “territorial” competence over games of luck, wagering or chance entailed the power to interfere with the civil freedom to gamble, which only the State may regulate. Whether someone “self-prohibits” or “self-excludes” does not depend on any administrative authority, but on the individual. If someone registers because they consider themselves addicted, they cannot be regarded as such in one Autonomous Community but not in another.
From this perspective, it is the sovereign State that decides on the limits of this freedom, as happens when someone is declared legally incapacitated through judicial proceedings (there are no “Autonomous Community judges”, and judgments apply throughout the State). And if a “Register” is established (of prohibited persons, self-prohibited persons, etc.), it is the State that must regulate and manage it, with the tasks falling to the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) when regulating supply. “Coordination” in this field cannot be “from the bottom upwards across the map of Autonomous Communities”, but must be “from the top downwards”.
It is true that, until recently, technical difficulties have prevented this principle from being properly applied and implemented, and that the CCAA are important building blocks in the construction of this system. But now, when the State and its central powers over State-wide gambling, and above all online gambling, have led to the technical sophistication of this Register, and operators are even required to implement the interconnection of their servers with it before being granted their definitive Licence, the “technical” solution is within everyone's reach, and the legal interpretation I propose is feasible.
From that perspective, what is required is not an “interconnection” between separate Registers, but the adaptation of the current rules (or their interpretation in accordance with the Constitution without any need to amend them) to a solution involving a “single, centralised Register”, to which everyone (Autonomous Community administrations and, where appropriate, gambling operators when required) is connected.
Of course, this requires, on the one hand, greater sophistication in the application of the Directorate-General for Gambling, and, on the other, the willingness to implement imaginative technical solutions so that all business owners can adapt to them. Once again, engineers coming to the rescue of lawyers.
That is where we stand, in times of uncertainty and technological change across all sectors.
In the meantime, coordination is welcome
Since the solution I propose probably requires changes that are too rapid and bold for the political times in which we find ourselves, the “coordination” sought by the Socialist initiative appears worthy of praise in the meantime.
Even if it amounts only to a wish to “promote” mechanisms for interconnecting the registers, rather than a clear and resolute mandate to implement them. This impetus will very probably take concrete form (without any need to process anything in Congress) in the Agenda for meetings of the Gambling Policy Council, although that is another matter: the “how” and the “manner” in which the decisions adopted by this Council take effect, a subject to which I have already referred more than once.
[1] See most recently the