Gaming & Gambling
Commentary on the Constitutional Court judgment of 22 November 2023 declaring the question of unconstitutionality terminated for loss of its subject matter as a result of the subsequent amendment to the Law on the Regulation of Gambling
Fernando Martín ·
Following the information note published by the Constitutional Court concerning the question of unconstitutionality referred by the Supreme Court, on which this firm has already commented, we have obtained access to the full judgment delivered by the Constitutional Court and published on that Court’s website.
Background. Question of unconstitutionality referred by the Supreme Court
As will be recalled, in the proceedings challenging Royal Decree 958/2020, of 3 November, on commercial communications concerning gambling activities (Royal Decree on Commercial Communications), the Supreme Court decided to refer a question of unconstitutionality to the Constitutional Court.
In that question of unconstitutionality, the Supreme Court considered that, through Article 7.2 of Law 13/2011, of 27 May (Gambling Law), the legislature had abdicated its responsibility in favour of the power to make regulations. In other words, Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law allowed Garzón’s ministry to regulate gambling advertising, which, by its nature and because of its connection with freedom of enterprise, ought to have been regulated by Parliament through legislation. The regulation of a matter such as gambling advertising, intrinsically linked to freedom of enterprise, was left in the hands of the Government, potentially infringing the Constitution, which requires matters relating to freedom of enterprise, including advertising, to be regulated by Parliament through legislation.
On that basis, the Supreme Court asked the Constitutional Court whether Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law was compatible with the Constitution.
Entry into force of the amendment to the Gambling Law introducing the new Article 7 bis
During the proceedings before the Constitutional Court, as noted in the judgment under consideration, the State Counsel defended the validity of Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law, arguing that restrictions on gambling advertising are justified on moral grounds and do not require specific legislation for their regulation. ONCE took the same position, arguing in favour of the restrictions imposed by the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications that Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law was entirely valid.
On the other side, the Asociación Española de Juego Digital supported the unconstitutionality of the Article, suggesting that it also affects freedom of information. For his part, the State Prosecutor General also concluded by requesting a judgment declaring Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law unconstitutional.
However, after the question of unconstitutionality had been referred, Law 23/2022, of 2 November, amending the Gambling Law, was enacted, introducing a new Article 7 bis on gambling advertising under the heading “General principles for the advertising, promotion and sponsorship of gambling activities”. In short, this new Article 7 bis has established the general principles for the advertising, promotion and sponsorship of gambling activities, focusing on social responsibility and the prohibition of certain advertising practices.
The Constitutional Court’s view on the legislative amendment resulting from the new Article 7 bis of the Gambling Law
The Constitutional Court considers the introduction of Article 7 bis into the Gambling Law relevant to assessing whether Article 7.2 of that Law complies with the Constitution, which was the question referred by the Supreme Court. According to the Constitutional Court, this inclusion is important because it determines how advertising legislation in this field is assessed. In short, and for greater clarity, the Supreme Court had raised the absence of clear guidelines on gambling advertising in the Gambling Law, but the new Article 7 bis has remedied this deficiency.
Furthermore, since the challenge brought before the Supreme Court did not contest specific administrative actions taken under the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications, for example, specific penalties imposed under that Royal Decree which would have to be examined by the Constitutional Court, it follows, in that Court’s view, that the question of unconstitutionality loses its relevance and is therefore declared terminated. In other words, according to the Constitutional Court, any defect in Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law has been remedied by the new Article 7 bis.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Constitutional Court judgment under consideration concludes that the defects identified by the Supreme Court in Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law, which allowed a ministry to regulate matters reserved to Parliament, have been corrected by the guidelines and rules laid down in the new Article 7 bis of the Gambling Law and, since this Article 7 bis has neither been questioned nor challenged, the proceedings before the Constitutional Court must be brought to an end.
Next steps
The case file will next be referred back to the Supreme Court so that it may continue the proceedings challenging the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications, lifting the stay of those proceedings which it had ordered and hearing the parties’ submissions on the implications of the judgment for the challenge to the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications. We will continue to follow these proceedings, as important questions concerning the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications remain to be resolved.