Gaming & Gambling

Comments on the Judgment of the CJEU of 4 February 2016 (Case \»Sebat Ince\»)

Carlos Lalanda ·

Comments on the Judgment of the CJEU of 4 February 2016 (Case \»Sebat Ince\»)

Once again, the European Court rules on a case concerning cross-border gambling, this time in relation to machines located in Bavaria where bets were collected for a foreign operator authorised in Austria, but not in Germany.

However, the judgment should be analysed carefully, rather than merely relying on the headline of the CJEU’s Press Release, which, at least in Spanish, is somewhat ambivalent and confusing. It states:

<p style=\" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">“European Union law may preclude the imposition of penalties for the cross-border intermediation of sporting bets carried out without authorisation in Germany”.

And this is indeed the final ruling for this particular case, Germany, where the applicable regulatory framework is convoluted as regards intervention in sports betting and its manifestations through terminals and the Internet channel. This is not a conclusion that can be extrapolated to other cases, and it is therefore appropriate to clarify the decision, so as  not to draw false general conclusions.

In Germany, the entire intervention regime rests on a chain of Federal Agreements or Treaties which  traditionally grant a public State Monopoly over lotteries, betting and other games of chance, and under which this monopoly power is “ceded” to the various German territorial Länder. This remained the position up to and including the 2004 Treaty.

Amid doubts concerning its application to the new channels for distributing gambling over the Internet (which could readily be classified as “supra-Länder” operations), the Federal Treaty was amended in 2008 to prohibit all organisation or intermediation of gambling over the Internet, although one Land was reluctant to sign it (Schleswig-Holstein.).

It is important at this point to revisit another, earlier judgment of the CJEU of 8 September 2010 (Case “Stoᵦ”), since, although it post-dated the 2008 Treaty, it dealt with a question concerning earlier facts under the 2004 Treaty, making a general ruling on the application of the EU principle of freedom to provide services and declaring that the EU Treaty precluded the German Monopoly (of 2004). The reason was that it did not meet the requirements established in the case-law which must be satisfied in such cases. Member States have, in principle, the power to establish monopolies in gambling matters, and even to transfer this power to regional bodies in accordance with their own political organisation (e.g. the “Digibet” case, also concerning the German Treaty); however, since this entails a reversal of the principle of freedom to provide services, monopolistic restrictions must be based on various objectives, as otherwise they cannot be permitted either.  These objectives must be justified by overriding reasons in the public interest, such as consumer protection and the prevention of fraud and of incitement to citizens to spend excessively on gambling (e.g. the judgment in Garkalns”),  ultimately, to prevent the risks and dangers which may, in theory, arise from the operation of games of chance; and they cannot be justified on other grounds, such as merely raising tax revenue. This justification was absent from the German Treaty and, consequently, the Monopoly appeared to be declared contrary to European law. However, that judgment also expressly stated that the Member State could decide to prohibit the Internet channel if this applied to all gambling, as occurred under the 2008 Treaty.

However, the German courts continued to receive challenges concerning sports betting, which remained subject to a monopoly, and concluded that the 2008 Treaty did not meet the requirements of Community case-law, just as the 2004 Treaty had not, and  prompted the legislative amendment which led to the signing of a new Federal Treaty, that of 2011, applicable from 1 July  2012, which sought to liberalise the sports betting market generally by providing for the possibility of granting several licences.

However, even so, these licences have still not been granted to date, and the European Court therefore examines whether this state of affairs is permissible and, in practice, whether the Austrian “cross-border” operator which the authorities seek to penalise in Bavaria may be subjected to the Monopoly restrictions when it has at no point had the opportunity to apply for a licence, because the licensing system has not yet been put into operation. This is what is actually at issue in this judgment and what warrants a forceful response from the CJEU: penalties cannot be imposed for the activity of intermediation in the cross-border offering of bets when the German monopoly over the offering of sporting bets  remains in force without adequate grounds.

It should be emphasised that the CJEU sets out the means of applying its criterion in a highly ingenious manner. The underlying reasoning could be summarised as follows:

  1. This is a case of “implicit disobedience” to CJEU judgments by the Member State, Germany, since what actually emerges from the foregoing account is that, once the shortcomings of the 2004 and 2008 Treaties had been identified, the solution provided by the 2011 Treaty was merely rhetorical.
  2. The CJEU chooses to apply the technique of the “nullity of unnotified Regulations” to the case in order to prevent the individual from being penalised. A regulatory provision imposing penalties which was adopted without the formal Notification to the European Commission that is mandatory for every Technical Regulation cannot be applied to the individual, and Bavaria omitted that notification in the case of the Regulation imposing penalties which implemented the Treaty within its territory.
  3. It interprets the process for granting Sports Betting licences contained in the 2011 Treaty as “fictitious”, and therefore the individual (an intermediary for another operator authorised in another Member State) cannot be prevented from carrying out that activity without holding a licence in Germany when the actual position is that there is no possibility of obtaining one.

It remains to be seen how the German national judge who made the reference for a preliminary ruling will react, although it is quite likely that the action to impose penalties will be annulled. And, consequently, that Germany will begin to remedy the defects and shortcomings in its intervention in gambling matters of which the CJEU has once again reminded it.

Madrid,  7 March 2016.

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez

More publications