Gaming & Gambling
Comments on the recent amendments to Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling
Patricia Lalanda ·
Amendment of Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling
The Official State Gazette (BOE) of 3 November publishes Law 23/2022 amending Law 13/2011, of 27 May , on the regulation of gambling. It must be said, however, that a large part of this Law (its First and Second Final Provisions, whose texts are longer than the main body of the Law itself) does not relate to Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling (“LRJ”), but to Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, of 16 November, approving the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users and other supplementary laws, the “General Law on Consumers and Users”, an addition which has little to do with the LRJ and was introduced during the parliamentary proceedings, constituting a tactic about which many members of Parliament complain, not without reason.
Below, we shall analyse only the provisions relating to the “amendment of the LRJ”, although we shall see that, once again, some of them have nothing to do with it, but are instead “attached” to the LRJ in a technically artificial manner.
Leaving both sets of provisions aside, this is not a substantive amendment of that Law, since it remains in force almost in its entirety, and we may rather regard it as a “patch intended to stitch up some legislative seams” concerning certain matters that had been left unresolved as the current Government sought to implement certain policies in this area. There have been other previous amendments to the LRJ that were more important than this one . For example, Law 3/2013, which abolished the original establishment and regulation of the never-born National Gambling Commission; or the latest noteworthy one, Law 11/2021, which already incorporated certain provisions relating to the fight against fraud.
Initial content of the Bill. The “legalisation of the SIGMA Service”
The Bill initially approved by the Government and submitted to Parliament contained a single, very specific substantive matter: the statutory regulation of the so-called “Global Betting Market Investigation Service (SIGMA)”. This is a genuine administrative “Service”, in the formal sense of the term, created and assigned to the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) to operate an IT tool, and, as such a “Service”, it was already operating within the DGOJ's Subdirectorate-General for Inspection, as recorded in the “2018 Gambling Activity Supervision Strategy”. An allocation of functions does not normally require an Act of Parliament and does not have to be debated in the Spanish Parliament. It is assigned to the administrative body and the civil servants carry it out in practice.
This Service has been operating normally to support the activities of CONFAD (National Commission to Combat the Manipulation of Sports Competitions and Betting Fraud), an interdepartmental body established by Order PCI/759/2019 of the Ministry of the Presidency, Relations with Parliament and Equality. This Commission, in which the DGOJ participates, primarily serves the police authorities and assists investigations into betting fraud, which normally has criminal implications. Also represented on this Commission are the Directorate-General for Sport, the Higher Sports Council, the Directorate-General of the Police, the Directorate-General of the Civil Guard, and representatives of the gambling sector in Spain.
As a large quantity of data is processed, it was necessary to provide this processing with a solid lawful basis, namely a statutory one (rather than mere public interest and/or legitimate interest); it is unequivocally established that the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (the “DGOJ”) is the controller of these data. The bodies and entities that will cooperate with SIGMA are also listed: the Higher Sports Council, sports federations, professional leagues and gambling operators. From the perspective of data protection legislation, they are classified as processors, that is, service providers to the DGOJ itself, but with one qualification: they may only have access to the data provided by each of these bodies. In other words, the Higher Sports Council, for example, will not be able to access the data provided by gambling operators, or vice versa. The DGOJ alone will be able to centralise all the information, which will then be disclosed to the State Security Forces and Corps and the autonomous police forces. The processing of special categories of data is expressly excluded, such as personal data revealing ethnic or racial origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, or trade union membership, genetic and biometric data, and data concerning individuals' health, sexual orientation or sex life, as well as any other data that are irrelevant or unnecessary. Gambling operators will have to take particular care not to disclose data relating to responsible gambling since, in our view, these may be considered health data. The maximum period for processing (retention) of these data by SIGMA is set at one year.
This basic statutory regulation of this database was the initial and sole purpose of the Bill submitted to Parliament, and it is approved as submitted, technically by adding a Ninth Additional Provision to the LRJ, and it is worth emphasising that:
- There is already an Agreement between the DGOJ and the Higher Sports Council (BOE of 30-8-2021), for the “disclosure” of the data referred to, since without its cooperation it would be impossible to pursue its objectives.
- This tool is physically housed within the DGOJ and is incorporated into the LRJ, which is the principal legislation regulating this economic sector, but it could have been housed within any other Department connected with sport or with the Security Forces it serves.
The other provision contained in the Bill submitted to Parliament was a brief addition of a DGOJ function to those listed in Article 21 of the LRJ. This proposed statutory function, which was ultimately approved, consists of
“protecting groups of at-risk gamblers by assessing the effectiveness of responsible or safer gambling measures aimed at these groups which, in compliance with the applicable regulatory obligations , gambling operators must develop”
Although this is a vague definition which overlaps with other functions already held by the DGOJ, inherited from the National Gambling Commission (Article 21 already has another 17 paragraphs in the list), it seemed rather to be intended to “legalise” the concurrent “Regulation developing safer gambling environments”, still pending approval, the legislative process for which had begun and was already well advanced when this Law was promoted. Perhaps this amounts to an acknowledgement that many of the provisions included in that Decree require a statutory basis in order for it to be successfully incorporated into our legal system, which so requires.
Even so, the ambiguous and redundant wording of that paragraph appears barely to “legalise” much more than the term used by the draft Royal Decree (the “assessment of measures”), since it provides no further detail.
Other amendments to the LRJ introduced during the amendment stages
Other amendments to the LRJ, with varied content, have been added during the parliamentary proceedings to the Bill initially submitted to Parliament in the brief terms outlined above:
A/ An Article 7 bis is added, entitled “general principles for the advertising, promotion and sponsorship of gambling activities”, introducing the concept of “social responsibility”, around which the prohibitions relating to the content of commercial communications revolve.
This addition most probably arises from an event collateral to the passage of the Law: the Supreme Court has referred a question of constitutionality concerning Article 7. 2 of the LRJ, which has created considerable legal uncertainty. This article constituted the sole statutory basis which the Government sought to provide for the recent Royal Decree 958/2020 on Commercial Communications for Gambling Activities, a piece of legislation whose passage was lengthy and controversial, as was its final content. Should the Constitutional Court decide to declare it void, this new Article 7 bis is now available and would partly, although not wholly, remedy this hypothetical lack of statutory basis.
B/ A paragraph 3 is added to Article 8, expressly referring to possible Cooperation Agreements with the Autonomous Communities to interconnect the various existing Registers of Prohibitions on Access to Gambling (registers of prohibited persons), a task which had already been undertaken with some of them (Castilla La Mancha and Cantabria) in order to coordinate prohibitions at the different State and autonomous levels through IT developments. Although this legislative solution is one way of addressing this problem, we have already stated in other commentaries that the amendment could have taken a different, more “daring” direction: claiming exclusive competence, applicable throughout the State, to regulate and maintain this Register, since we are dealing with a restriction of a civil liberty (the freedom to gamble), which cannot, in our view, be assumed at Autonomous Community level (Article 149, 8 of the Spanish Constitution: Civil Legislation). For the same reasons that the existence of Autonomous Community Criminal Records Registers would be absurd.
C/ And Article 13, 2 c) of the LRJ is amended, relaxing the requirement to have no record of infringements in order to obtain a State gambling licence, by removing the reference to records of very serious infringements under the Autonomous Communities' Gambling Laws.
Another approved provision which (likewise) has no intrinsic connection with the LRJ.
Finally, the Law as approved adds a new Tenth Additional Provision to the LRJ entitled “Guidelines for the safer use of non-fungible digital assets, loot boxes or mechanisms for monetising users' participation in video games”.
As is apparent from the title, this is a mandate to the Government concerning video games, which would rather require a specific Law for that purpose, which is what, at least as regards “loot boxes”, is already contained in the text of a Preliminary Draft Bill submitted to public consultation in July. Ultimately, this artificial last-minute addition could have been avoided.
Law 23/2022 amending Law 13/2011, of 27 May, as approved, entered into force on Friday 4 November.