Tax & Private Clients
The stir over compliance – Circular 1/2016 of the State Prosecutor General’s Office published
·
Probably every business owner in the gambling sector and, indeed, throughout the country has heard, even if only in passing, about “this compliance business” and feels more or less curious and more or less apprehensive depending on the contacts they may have had with that turbulent world, particularly its more “Anglo” variety.
Recently, following last year’s reform of the Criminal Code and its particular implications for the criminal liability of legal persons, various articles and opinions have been written. These have now been joined, a few days ago, by the publication by the Public Prosecutor’s Office of Circular 1/2016, which describes and sets out a unified framework of criteria to be taken into account when determining whether or not a company is criminally liable for the commission of an offence and which (seemingly) sheds a little (more) light on this nebulous subject.
Let us briefly recall that the function of the Public Prosecutor’s Office, in accordance with its Organic Statute, is none other than to ”promote the administration of justice in defence of legality, citizens’ rights and the public interest protected by law, of its own motion or at the request of interested parties, as well as to safeguard the independence of the Courts and to seek to uphold the interests of society before them”. It will therefore always be the Judges and Courts that have the final say, albeit guided, among other things, by the criteria that the Public Prosecutor’s Office may invoke in a particular case.
First, the Circular takes the view that, in order to bring criminal proceedings against a company, it is necessary to establish the prior commission of an offence (there are up to 26 offences that legal persons can commit) by a natural person who forms part of the company and has a certain degree of decision-making power. In addition, the conduct of the persons referred to above must be aimed, directly or indirectly, at benefiting the entity.
Furthermore, for a legal person to be held criminally liable where the offence has been committed by one of the persons referred to in Article 31 1 bis b) (employees and other subordinates), the criminal act must have been committed as a result of a serious breach of the duties of supervision, monitoring and control by one of the persons entrusted with those obligations (e.g. the directors), meaning that those persons subject to such duties may also incur personal criminal liability for an offence committed either intentionally, by commission through omission, or through gross negligence.
This is where compliance programmes or plans (let us call them compliance, in honour of their Anglo-Saxon origins) acquire particular importance, being essential to securing an exemption from criminal liability for legal persons or, at least, mitigating it.
However, the Public Prosecutor’s Office stresses that the mere existence of a programme will not suffice: its suitability for preventing the specific offence committed must be demonstrated. Accordingly, programmes “must be perfectly tailored to the company and its specific risks”.
These compliance plans, like suits, must be bespoke rather than prêt-à-porter: they cannot be the same for a small company as for a multinational, nor can they be the same for a company in the food sector as for an operator of gaming halls, casinos or sports betting. It is necessary to understand the risks and needs of each sector and reflect them in an all-encompassing compliance plan which must contain, at a minimum, a risk map, the obligations of each member of the company, those responsible for their supervision, monitoring and control, and the consequences of non-compliance, among other obligations laid down by the Criminal Code and further qualified by the Public Prosecutor’s Office in its publication.
Among the most important criteria for assessing the degree of liability, according to the Public Prosecutor’s Office, are the conduct and involvement of the company’s board of directors and senior management in relation to compliance plans. The company’s liability cannot be the same where the offence is committed by one of its directors or a senior executive as where it is committed by an employee.
In this context, the role of the compliance officer, who is entrusted with supervising the crime prevention model, acquires particular importance. This must be a specific body of the legal person with autonomous powers of initiative and control. What truly matters for present purposes is that the legal person has a body responsible for the regulatory compliance function, whether internal to the company or not. Many of its functions will be all the more effective the greater the degree to which they are outsourced, as is the case, for example, with training for executives and employees or with whistleblowing channels, which are more widely used and more effective when managed by an external company able to guarantee greater levels of independence and confidentiality.
In the Gambling Sector, compliance (compliance), in many jurisdictions, goes beyond what has been stated in relation to the exemption of the legal person from liability and has as its ultimate objective the protection of gambling licences or concessions, which are regarded as a “privilege”, as well as the prevention of reputational problems that may affect the company, its principal executives and shareholders and, why not, the gambling industry as a whole.
Companies operating in certain jurisdictions where compliance requirements apply enter into associations or business relationships with others (for example, suppliers) that have been granted licences in those jurisdictions and must therefore pass an “examination” in line with those standards. Likewise, companies involved in credit financing transactions of some magnitude, or which issue or plan to issue debt or list shares on secondary markets, require more sophisticated compliance plans and structures, which have points of connection with other areas such as auditing, finance, operations and taxation.
At LOYRA, we have been working to encourage and support our clients in the area of compliance not merely since last year, but since almost time immemorial, as we consider it an area of considerable added value for any company in general, with the additional advantage, since last year, that it may lead to exemption from criminal liability if it is genuinely implemented as another aspect of corporate culture.
®Loyra Abogados y Asesores For the full text of the Circular, click here: Legal Report on the Public Prosecutor’s Office Circular This news item has been published in some of the sector’s leading media outlets: JocPrivat and elRecreativo.com.