Tax & Private Clients

Compliance Spain: Improvements to the Regulatory Framework

Fernando Martín ·

The updating of the Spanish legal framework and the importance it has accorded to compliance programmes in the country's various sectors, including games of chance.

In Spain, if we wish to discuss a genuinely novel and topical subject in the legal world, we must address compliance programmes: those mechanisms and controls which ensure that the activities of legal persons (companies) comply with the law.

Under the Spanish legal system, since 2010, but particularly following the reform of the Criminal Code, which entered into force on 1 July 2015, legal persons may be regarded as perpetrators of criminal offences. Before the reforms, the principle followed by Spanish law was to deny that these entities could commit criminal offences.

The criminal liability of legal persons has a distinctive structure, since it requires a series of conditions to be met. First, a natural person, whether a director or legal representative, manager or employee, must previously have committed one of the offences set out in Article 31 bis—a closed list of more than 26.

It is then necessary for the offence to have been committed for the direct or indirect benefit of the company, which will nevertheless be exempt from liability if it proves that it has implemented effective management, monitoring and supervision models aimed at preventing criminal offences.

It is hardly surprising that these programmes or models will be of considerable importance in Spanish law in the very near future.

New conditions

The State Prosecutor General's Office has emphasised that these programmes cannot have the sole objective of avoiding criminal penalties for the company; rather, their principal purpose must be to promote a genuine corporate ethical culture.

“The company must have a model for complying with the law in general and, of course, with criminal law, but not only with criminal law”, states Circular 1/2016 of that Prosecutor General's Office. They must also be clear, precise, effective, known to their intended recipients and set out “in writing”.

The mere existence of a programme will not suffice; its suitability for preventing the specific offence committed must be demonstrated, requiring an assessment of the suitability of the programme's content in relation to the offence committed. Accordingly, “they must be perfectly adapted to the company and its specific risks”.

These compliance programmes are an essential tool for companies to defend themselves against allegations of criminal offences. Furthermore, the Supreme Court has held that the burden of proof concerning the “suitability” of the programmes rests with the prosecution. At the same time, it has been established that legal persons enjoy the same rights as natural persons in criminal proceedings.

Anti-money laundering policy

Although compliance affects a wide variety of activities and legal rules, the prevention of money laundering occupies a particularly important position in relation to gambling companies.

In Spain, there are two distinct but complementary perspectives on this matter. On the one hand, it is regarded as a criminal offence and, as such, is defined in Articles 298 et seq. of the Criminal Code.

Alongside this, there are administrative rules whose principal purpose is to prevent money laundering by establishing reporting and cooperation obligations: obligations, actions and procedures intended to prevent money laundering.

Regulation from this second, administrative and preventive perspective on money laundering is contained in Law 10/2010, of 28 April, and its implementing Regulation, Royal Decree 30/2014, of 5 May.

The Spanish Law and Regulation on money laundering are the result of the transposition of Directive 2005/60/EEC. This means that Spain has merely incorporated into its legal system the rules and guidelines established by the European Union and international instructions on the subject, with some technical improvements.

In Spain, casinos and persons responsible for the management, operation and marketing of lotteries or other games of chance are regarded as obliged entities for the purposes of preventing money laundering in respect of prize payment transactions.

Modern mechanisms

The prevention of money laundering in gambling conducted over the Internet (online gambling) has certain specific characteristics which are addressed in Royal Decree 30/2014, of 5 May, under the generic heading “Non-face-to-face business relationships and transactions”.

Operators must identify players who receive prizes exceeding 2,500 euros (2,827 dollars)—this threshold does not exist for casinos—draw up a list of transactions liable to be regarded as presenting a risk, and establish procedures for detecting and assessing suspicious transactions—including stages of analysis, sources of information and the recording of results in writing. These obligations must be detailed in a procedures manual.

Business owners will also have to appoint a representative before the Executive Service of the Commission against Money Laundering (SEPBLAC)—the body responsible for promoting and coordinating the implementation of anti-money laundering legislation—and implement an annual plan of training activities for employees.

Breaches relating to prevention or money laundering may, depending on the circumstances, be regarded as criminal or administrative offences.

Fernando Martín Martín  ©

Partner, LOYRA ABOGADOS Y ASESORES

Article published in Revista Casino

More publications