Gaming & Gambling
From confusion to chaos.
Carlos Lalanda ·
It is fashionable to oppose betting and gaming halls. A trending topic. Television stations, radio stations, magazines, political parties, deputies, senators, parliamentarians of various kinds, municipalities, parliaments, associations of residents, doctors or, of course, compulsive gamblers, and even lifelong friends warn us of the unchecked proliferation of gambling premises, the excessive advertising of these games and the high percentages of minors engaging in these activities. Even ONCE warns us about it.
However, when you ask any of them whether they still play their weekly cupón or primitiva, or the Christmas Lottery or El Niño, or remind them of the constant, highly original ONCE or SELAE advertising spots, at any time of day, they fall silent, thoughtful and confused for a moment. But then they all carry on with the same refrain.
Confusion
Let us not look for conspiracy theories. From a legal perspective, this intensification has an explanation and earlier origins: it began back in 2011, when the wording of the National Gambling Law was being finalised, purportedly to protect users of online gambling offerings. That Law came into being to regulate those offerings, because all the others were already clearly and sufficiently regulated.
Until then, excessive gambling by a player, or their uncontrollable compulsion, was labelled “irresponsible gambling”, and someone coined the opposite term to muddy the waters a little. Gambling advertising was prohibited or restricted to a ridiculous degree, and cases of compulsive gambling were considered a lesser evil, deserving treatment and capable of being controlled. Until then, no one could overtly be “persuaded” to gamble through loans or promotional offers, on pain of committing an infringement. Such was the previous Law.
With the Gambling Law, contrary to what was intended, almost all of this changed. Not because these matters were formally disregarded, but because the rules were born with little “sincerity” as regards their application. Ambiguous terminology took hold in some cases; references to subsequent rules were not followed through. An artificial realm was established through gambling operators’ “self-regulation” techniques. Ultimately, we are now faced with a National Gambling Law containing provisions that are empty or have been emptied of substance, precisely in the matters that concern us today. I shall be a little more specific.
- Contrary to what it appears to announce, Article 7, which refers to all kinds of gambling at national level, including lotteries, does not prohibit the advertising of games of chance. It only prohibits advertising of those that are not authorised, while those that are authorised are subject to Advertising Regulations that do not currently exist. Subject to the general rules restricting advertising messages, advertising is virtually unrestricted in the absence of Regulations. The self-regulatory regime that was devised is, by definition, voluntary, and alien to the Spanish coercive tradition of “carrot and stick”. The vast national lottery campaigns that already existed before the Law are, in practice, unrestricted and even increase year after year, without any moderating rules or controls. Despite warnings from various sectors about this legal loophole, and an almost unanimous outcry, and despite several drafts of the missing Regulations having already been processed, no one can understand why they have still not been approved.
- Article 8.2 provides that “operators may not grant loans or any other form of credit or financial assistance to participants”. Normal online gambling practice involves the provision of welcome “bonuses”, whereby “amounts are provided to play for free”, to be repaid or not, depending on the circumstances (with many or few conditions that distort their true classification). And even if they were “promotional mechanisms” rather than financial ones, they are not regulated either, as Article 7 also requires for promotional activities.
- The Sixth Additional Provision of Royal Decree 1614/2011 excludes “free” games from the application of the law, which, once again and without any additional regulation, opens the way for their use by at-risk members of the public, as they do not require a user account.
- Quantitative and temporal limits are imposed on deposits into players’ accounts, but at the same time the Resolution of 16 November 2011 approves a so-called “responsible gambling test”, which allows this limit to be exceeded by completing a simple online questionnaire.
- Furthermore, with all this regulatory vagueness and interpretative laxity, even lottery betting by minors does not result in any kind of penalty, as far as is known. (On the contrary, what is known is that they go with their parents to buy lottery tickets, as though they could legally do so).
- Only the day before yesterday, the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) had to intervene with a Technical Note to clarify which bets, in its view, players, referees and directors in sporting competitions may not place, because the Law literally refers only to “events and activities” in which they are participating (in other words, this may be understood to mean the matches in which their team is playing or which they are refereeing). The Law does not say in “competitions”, and no one has thought to amend the Law to make this clear.
But that is not all.
The purported identity checks on players accessing gambling accounts have, right up to now, rested on an “a posteriori” regime; and only in a recent Resolution issued in the past year has a timid step been taken towards “a priori” verification. Which still has implementation periods and exceptions.
The tangle of exceptions and counter-exceptions contained in lower-ranking regulatory provisions (Orders regulating specific games) means that authorisation is being granted, to give one example, for games in which a random draw for a house-banked prize of 1,000,000 euros is considered poker, merely because the draw takes place in the context of a poker game.
Furthermore, from another perspective, that of tax collection, and at the height of its appetite for taxation, the State in fact allows legal entities and commercial companies to play and win lotteries, provided that it collects more tax on winnings.
The gambling taxes generated by football pools (decreasing every year) continue to be allocated, through inertia or legal acrobatics, to pre-constitutional purposes, whose sources of funding are consequently reduced each year. Moreover, those generated by online gambling are distributed among the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), in the absence of any other allocation criterion, but there are also voices and proposals calling for them to be allocated to other purposes (as though they could be distributed twice).
In this scenario of confusion……… how can the distortion of facts and figures be avoided?
No one turns to reliable data, but rather to indirect or second-hand data. Whether there are many or few compulsive gamblers. Whether an increase from 100 to 140 gaming halls in a given territory is an increase of 40% or 140%. Arithmetic and exponential increases are spoken of interchangeably. Whether young Spaniards hooked on betting account for 0.0001% or 15% of the total population, or of all young people; even the very concept of youth varies from case to case. A mere Power Point slide in a report on the Internet is considered absolute truth.
Very few people know, given the scarcity of information on the subject, the scale of the multibillion-euro contribution made by special gambling taxes to the public purse.
Very few people are aware of the hundreds of thousands of jobs and the millions in investment that the gambling sector generates for the country’s economy.
But now we have moved from confusion to chaos.
Persecution and Chaos
In practice, no one today distinguishes whether the criticism is directed at online or land-based betting, at gaming halls, or whether the advertising being demonised is for online poker or land-based casinos, or whether the bingo being advertised is at a particular venue or online. Or whether it is directed at advertising on billboards in football stadiums or on players’ shirts. Almost no one discusses whether it is misleading, or whether it is addictive and attractive to minors, or not; it makes no difference.
This criticism has moved into a phase of social “persecution”. And there are many examples.
A recent study by the Catalan Audiovisual Council published last week denounced the advertising of games of chance during “restricted hours”, but closer examination reveals that a “Locobingo” website appears in first place (which is not a gambling website), and any reference to the vast number of SELAE and ONCE advertisements at all hours is omitted. Nor does it specify whether any penalty proceedings have been initiated against the channels or media outlets by the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC), which has competence in this matter, if the conduct in question is unlawful.
In a magazine, the Secretariat of Facua stated that in Spain there were <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">600,000 compulsive gamblers undergoing treatment, and that action was needed. There are no official figures, but they would not reach 10,000.
The other day, a motion was approved by Madrid City Council requesting thorough inspections of gambling premises by the municipal police, which is, of course, their duty. But, to great surprise, another group opposed it on the grounds that it was not within their remit to do so.
Anti-gambling demonstrations are being called in some neighbourhoods.
Not long ago, a town council approved a requirement that all machines in bars should be activated only by the bar proprietor using a remote control. Like cigarette vending machines
The recently approved Aragon Sports Law indiscriminately prohibited sports sponsorship by betting brands, without prior notice or debate. Only yesterday, a motion was approved in the Aragonese Parliament calling on the Aragonese Government to take control measures in gaming halls, without knowing that the Regulations had been amended to that effect a couple of months ago. The motion also approved the urgent establishment of electronic systems for voluntary registration in the Aragonese Register of Excluded Persons, when there is already an “app” created for that purpose by the DGOJ, and available on all mobile phones (I tell a lie, only those using technology from the “Android family” for now)
Also recently, a residents’ association I know approved a ban on the opening of a gaming hall that had already been authorised by the Town Council and the Autonomous Community. Because of its “social danger”.
In another municipality, the mayor contacted a businessman by email, imploring him, for everyone’s sake, not to open the premises he was about to open, because several residents’ associations were asking him to do so.
Only yesterday, a Decree-Law was approved in Extremadura requiring premises to be more than 300 metres away from educational establishments… are they going to move those that are currently closer? Are they going to compensate their owners?
In short, we are in a phase of “demonisation”, persecution and, ultimately… chaos.
I suggest a careful reading of “La edad de la Penumbra” (Catherine Nixey, 2018), which describes in great factual detail the situation in Alexandria at the beginning of the fifth century, when Bishop Cyril’s Christian hordes, inflamed by the preacher and ultimately by fear of demons and hell, and with the aim of eradicating any vestige of paganism or heresy, dismembered Hypatia for being the custodian (and also for being intelligent and a woman, of course) of the last remains of the library that held the accumulated knowledge of ancient times, which they also burnt.
It is also advisable to watch “The Fall of the Roman Empire” again, which recounts that same period of confusion, chaos… and subsequent darkness. As an anecdote, and in passing, an old friend tells me that, in this film shot in a village in Madrid, he and another man were hired as Roman plebeians, and took advantage of the scene of final chaos and confusion to rub against Sofía Loren. For them it was an achievement, although for the actress it was a great affront.
Postscript: I had drafted this article before seeing the publication today of Extremadura Decree-Law 1/2019 on gambling in that Autonomous Community. It does not in any way change my impressions of confusion, persecution and chaos; rather, it confirms them. But that is for tomorrow’s article.
Carlos Lalanda
7 February 2019