Gaming & Gambling

Judgment 79/2017 of the Constitutional Court of 22 June 2017

·


The Constitutional Court Judgment
of 22 June 2017 declares several articles of Law 20/2013 on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM) null and void, which we briefly analyse below owing to their interest from the perspective of a possible influence on the activity of gambling markets in Spain.

The judgment concludes a constitutional challenge brought by the Parliament of Catalonia against several provisions of that Law, on the grounds that they encroached upon the competences under the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

The articles declared null and void are as follows:

  • Articles 19 and 20 in their entirety, which set out the Principle of nationwide effectiveness, from the perspective of freedom of economic initiative throughout the national territory and the nationwide effectiveness of administrative actions (of the Autonomous Communities (CCAA)). By extension, Additional Provision 10, which established the aspects and definitions of the “authority of origin” and the “authority of destination”, is declared null and void. In addition, Article 6, which established the general concept of this principle, is deprived of substance, although it is not declared null and void because it was not expressly challenged.
  • In connection with the foregoing, paragraphs b), c) and e) of Article 18 are also declared null and void, which described various circumstances considered to constitute a restriction on market unity, such as the establishment of:

b)   Requirements to obtain an authorisation, approval, accreditation, certification or recognition, or to submit declarations of responsibility or notifications or to register in a register in order to pursue an activity in a territory other than that of origin.

c)   Additional qualification requirements in the case of professional activities.

e)   Technical specifications for the circulation of products or for their use in providing services, other than those established at the place of manufacture.

  • Part of the First Final Provision, which introduced a procedural privilege in favour of the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC), in that it imposed the automatic suspension of acts or provisions which it decided to challenge before the courts under this Law. The operative part also expressly declares the validity of Article 26.5, b) of the legislation insofar as it is interpreted that the reports of the Secretariat of State for Market Unity are not binding where they are issued within the procedures under that article. In relation to gambling, we shall analyse below its possible influence on gambling in Spain and on the various matters in which this LGUM had hitherto been applied. As an urgent preliminary assessment, the following can be stated: The challenge brought by the Catalan Parliament concerned several further articles of the LGUM, which the Court directly declares valid and consistent with the Constitution, as well as other provisions and principles which are examined together and therefore remain in force. Naturally, the other articles that were not challenged also remain in force, since this was not a “constitutional challenge to the Law in its entirety”. In particular, Articles 16, 17 and 18 (Guarantees of freedom of establishment and movement), as well as the corresponding Article 5 (Principle of necessity and proportionality of actions by the competent authorities), are declared valid, and these have formed the basis of most of the reports by SECUM and the CNMC when addressing matters relating to gambling and the actions and rules of various Autonomous Communities in the gambling sector. It also expressly upholds other challenged articles which in fact do not apply directly or indirectly, or apply only to a very limited extent, to gambling (Article 14.2 and Third Final Provision, paragraph 1). It declares the validity of certain other general provisions concerning the intervention of the Secretariat of the Council for Market Unity and the CNMC (Articles 26 and 27), as well as the general consideration of the scope of the State competence underpinning this Law (Fourth Final Provision). The judgment constitutes a true “manual” on the constitutional interpretation of the distribution of competences between the Autonomous Communities and the State, and in particular the scope of the State competence for the “general organisation of the economy” (Article 149.1.13 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)), on which the LGUM is based.

    We may extrapolate that the various instances of its application to the gambling sector remain, in principle, unaffected, since most of them, or the most significant, involved the application of articles not affected by the judgment. This is the case with the decisions adopted in relation to the multiplicity of security deposits required for registration in Registers.

    However, the approaches and advances concerning the mutual recognition of approvals of gambling products in the various Autonomous Communities must be urgently reconsidered.

    Conversely, the Court makes various observations concerning possible action by the State to give effect to the principles enshrined in the LGUM, and does not rule out the possibility that it may produce its effects through the establishment of “common standards” in matters where the legal regimes of the various Autonomous Communities coincide, which is precisely the field within which the Gambling Policy Council operates in terms of its competences and objectives.

More publications