Gaming & Gambling
The Constitutional Court judgment on the LGUM: initial analysis and implications for games of chance
·
A
judgment of the Constitutional Court awaiting publication declares several articles of Law 20/2013 on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM) null and void, which we briefly analyse below owing to their relevance from the perspective of their possible influence on the operation of gambling markets in Spain.
The judgment concludes an appeal challenging the constitutionality of several provisions of that Law, brought by the Parliament of Catalonia on the grounds that they encroached upon the powers conferred by the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.
The articles declared null and void are as follows:
- Articles 19 and 20 in their entirety, which set out the Principle of effectiveness throughout the national territory, from the perspective of freedom of economic initiative throughout the national territory and the effectiveness throughout the national territory of administrative actions (of the Autonomous Communities (CCAA)). By extension, Additional Provision 10, which established the aspects and definitions of the “authority of origin” and the “authority of destination”, is declared null and void. Furthermore, Article 6, which established the general concept of this principle, is deprived of substance, although it is not declared null and void because it was not expressly challenged.
- In connection with the foregoing, paragraphs b), c) and e) of Article 18 are also declared null and void. These described various circumstances considered to constitute restrictions on market unity, such as the establishment of:
- b): Requirements to obtain an authorisation, approval, accreditation, certification or recognition, or to submit declarations of responsibility or notifications or to register in a register in order to carry on an activity , in a territory other than that of origin.
- c) Additional qualification requirements in the case of professional activities.
- e) Technical specifications for the circulation of products or for their use in providing services, other than those established at the place of manufacture
- Part of the First Final Provision, which introduced a procedural privilege in favour of the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC), insofar as it required the automatic suspension of acts or provisions which it decided to challenge before the courts under this Law.
- The operative part of the judgment also expressly declares the validity of Article 26.5, b) of the Law, insofar as it is interpreted that reports of the State Secretariat for Market Unity are not binding where they are issued within the framework of the procedures under that article.