Gaming & Gambling

Coronavirus Relief for Gambling Levies in Catalonia.

Carlos Lalanda ·

 These are difficult times everywhere, and the urgent decisions required of those in government may lead to ambiguities and confusion which, already commonplace in normal times, may now even be justifiable.

In Catalonia, in view of the emergency arising from the health crisis we are experiencing, and the widespread closure of establishments and activities, it has been necessary to adopt various economic, social and administrative decisions affecting individuals and businesses falling within the jurisdiction of the Generalitat, in Decree-Law 11/2020 published on 9 May; and it is likely that those relating to the Fiscal Levy on Gambling applicable to automatic machines were left until last in order of importance.

And this may be why the “relief” approved for that Levy is, grammatically and legally, very difficult to understand, and we shall attempt to analyse it.

In Decree-Law 7/2020, of 17 March (published on the 19th), Catalonia had already adopted the general decision to “suspend” the time limits for filing and payment of taxes within Catalan competence until the lifting of the state of alarm declared by the Central Government to manage the health crisis. The time limit for self-assessments of the fixed-rate Levy ordinarily expired on 20 March.

Relief/reduction of fixed amounts for the Machine Levy.  

The Explanatory Memorandum to the Decree-Law being published makes it very clear that the intention is to introduce, for this fixed-rate tax, “relief” from the tax liability, of a temporary nature and limited to the period during which the state of alarm remains in force. The first paragraph of Article 5 clearly states that this relief is “equivalent in percentage terms to the number of days during which the state of alarm has been in force”. Fair and logical when the establishments in which the gambling machines are operated have been closed since 14 March by legal mandate, without it being known how long they will remain so.

It seems to me that the message is clear and unambiguous, and that there was almost no need to say anything further.

However, Article 5, which goes on to set out the administration of the relief, confuses and even distorts the announcement, leaving the exact amount of the relief and when it must take effect open to difficult and uncertain interpretation.

The Gambling Levy in Catalonia applicable to the various categories of gambling machines, quantified by means of fixed unit amounts per machine, involves the following tax elements:

. The tax period is quarterly, based on calendar quarters (Law 26/2009)

. The quarterly chargeable event occurs on the first day of each quarter (Law 26/2009)

. The payment period by means of self-assessment runs for the first 20 days of the last month of each quarter (Autonomous Community Decree 2/2014, pursuant to statutory delegation)

Taking the example of type “B” gaming machines, with a fixed quarterly amount of 1,005 euros (Law 5/2017), the position until now was as follows

  • The quarterly chargeable event had already occurred on 1 January (€1,005), and on 1 April (€1,005)
  • The payment period for the first quarter ran from 1 to 20 March and, as it was suspended by Decree-Law 7/2020 before its expiry, many companies had probably not paid the tax liability at that time, nor have they paid it yet (although they may do so if they wish); the payment period for the second quarter will not begin until 1 June, so it is likely that the suspension under Decree-Law 7 will not affect it.

Now following the Explanatory Memorandum to the new Decree-Law strictly (and also applying correctly and meticulously the constitutional principle of ability to pay under Article 31.3 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)), it would appear that the Catalan legislature's intention is as follows:

  1. First-quarter amount. To grant retrospective relief of 198.79 Euros (18/91 of the total)
  2. Second-quarter amount. To grant retrospective relief in an amount not determined but capable of being determined when the state of alarm is lifted. For example, if it is lifted on 26 April at 00:00, the relief would be 251.25 Euros (25/91 of the total).

The dates and amounts for payment for each of the quarterly periods would then be as follows:

  1. First-quarter self-assessment (806.21 Euros). To be filed no later than Monday 27 April (25 April is a Saturday and 26 April is a Sunday, non-working days for tax purposes)
  2. Second-quarter self-assessment (753.75 Euros). To be filed during the ordinary period, from 1 to 20 June.

Is this what Article 5 of the new Decree-Law says? It says neither the first nor the second. The text in Spanish:

<span style=\" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">“Relief from the amount payable is established …………………………..at a percentage equivalent to the number of days during which the state of alarm declared by Royal Decree 463/2020, of 14 March, has been in force, relative to the total number of days in the calendar quarter corresponding to the first self-assessment time limit commencing after the date on which the state of alarm ends. This relief shall be applied on one occasion only in the self-assessment corresponding to the aforementioned quarterly assessment period.”

It is necessary to examine the legal text in depth and draw on tax-law principles to unravel the true requirement being approved.

Imprecise terminology

 In terms of the technical concepts of Administrative Law and its variant, Tax Law.

  • “Relief” is a technical tax term, equivalent to a quantitative reduction in the tax liability. In this case the relief is clearly “temporary”, that is, applicable to the periods affected by the declaration of the state of alarm. However, it is not relief of an exact amount determined in the Decree-Law, but rather an amount capable of being quantified. It seems to me that it affects two tax liabilities, for the time being, unless it is extended much further (those corresponding to the First and Second tax periods), although the legal text appears to refer to only one (the “first time limit”, in Spanish, the “first deadline”, in Catalan) (and “on one occasion only” in Spanish, “on one occasion only” in Catalan).
  • “Tax period” is the temporal element to which the taxable event relates. In Catalonia, it is quarterly. Each quarter an amount payable and a liability are calculated, distinct from the liability for the preceding or following quarter.
  • “Payment period” for the liability. This is the period prescribed for fulfilment of the payment obligation. In Catalonia, for the Gambling Levy on automatic machines, the start and end dates of the period in each quarter are established by regulation. This is a more precise term than “time limits”, which in Tax Law normally refer to the days for fulfilling other, different tax obligations, those arising from assessment or deferment, and which only begin to run when the assessment or collection measures are notified.
  • “Suspension” of deadlines is not the same as “interruption” of time limits. This confusion is very common, aggravated by the bad habit in Tax Law of referring almost exclusively to the “time limits” for paying the liability. Royal Decree 463/2020 itself, introducing the state of alarm, expresses this impeccably in its Third Additional Provision: “deadlines are suspended and time limits are interrupted” for processing, with reference to all procedures of public-sector entities, although all tax procedures were subsequently excluded by Royal Decree 465/2020, and Article 33 of State Royal Decree-Law 8/2020 refers, once again, to the “suspension of tax time limits” (and not to “deadlines”).

The Fiscal Levy on Gambling in Catalonia and in all the other Autonomous Communities, like many other taxes, has prescribed payment periods as part of its administration. The quarterly payment period in this case runs between two clearly established days or “fixed deadlines”: from the 1st to the 20th of the last month of each quarter, the March period having already ended.

Under Article 14 of Catalan Decree-Law 7/2020, the deadline of 20 March was SUSPENDED, but not “interrupted”. When the suspension is lifted, no time limit WILL RESUME; rather, the self-assessment will have to be filed immediately (and this is on a very favourable interpretation of the date for fulfilment of the obligation, which by that date will already have passed, as it has already passed today). Strictly speaking, on the day the suspension is lifted, the first-quarter self-assessment for 806.21 euros should already have been filed, unless, for example, deferment of payment has previously been requested.  Nothing in the second tax payment period has been suspended, because it has not yet begun.

Uncertain interpretation of the meaning of Article 5 of the new Royal Decree-Law

 As matters stand, the text published today plunges us into manifest confusion.

The relief is granted with quantitative clarity and a clearly retrospective intent, since two tax obligations had already arisen and were already enforceable.

However, when it comes to its effective application, the wording refers to “on one occasion only” (and not two). And it makes matters worse by referring to the first self-assessment “time limit” (or “deadline” in Catalan) which “commences after the lifting of the state of alarm” (the same in Spanish as in Catalan).

If the state of alarm is lifted on 26 April, the first period (for filing self-assessments and payment) to commence thereafter will be that from 1 to 20 June which, as we have seen, corresponds to the second tax period (that of the 2nd quarter of the year).

In these circumstances …. what would then happen to the first, if it must be dealt with immediately, or has already been paid during the ordinary period?).

It seems to me that, in respect of this first tax period (1st quarter of 2020), there may be two solutions depending on the circumstances:

  • Where the self-assessments have not been filed owing to the “suspension” currently in force. In that case they would have to be filed for the reduced amount (in the example given, €806.21) before the suspension is lifted, paying the tax liability or requesting its deferment. See above: it might be acceptable, with reservations, to file them on the day following the end of the suspension.
  • Where the self-assessments have already been filed for that first quarter, for the full amount applicable before the Decree-Law, in the example €1,005. In that case it would be appropriate to request rectification of the self-assessments to €806.21, and a refund of the difference on the grounds that it constitutes an undue payment.

A further unknown: what would happen if the state of alarm were lifted on 21 June, after the 2nd quarterly payment period had elapsed? Would the relief then be applied in the payment period for the third quarter?

In short, the appalling drafting of the tax provision, although to some extent justifiable for the reasons of urgency indicated, appears to us to require an equally urgent interpretation by the Catalan bodies responsible for administering and applying the tax, once again in terms of tax and constitutional justice.

Madrid, 9 April 2020

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

www.loyra.com

More publications