Gaming & Gambling
“De-escalation” for gambling premises. A small sudoku of phases and terms.
Carlos Lalanda ·
The beginning was easy: the suspension (that is, closure) was ordered of all those establishments, or rather activities in establishments, listed in the Annex to Royal Decree 463/2020, of 14 March. These included gambling and betting establishments such as casinos, bingo halls, gaming halls and betting premises; and also others classified within the hospitality and catering category where machines are installed.
A Decree in form, (adopted at a meeting of the Council of Ministers), but exceptional in that it is equivalent to provisions having the force of law, and requires subsequent ratification by the Congress of Deputies. It was subsequently amended on three occasions and extended on as many occasions, although the latest extension (Royal Decree 514/2020, of 8 May) already offers a glimpse of an approaching end to the state of alarm, and adopts terminology hitherto non-existent: “de-escalation”, not provided for in the Dictionary of the RAE, still less in Spanish legal provisions. It has mountaineering connotations.
So now comes the difficult part: interpreting the situation envisaged in the provisions now published in the Official State Gazette (BOE), and in particular attempting to do so with regard to premises and activities relating to gambling. And searching them for any indication that might allow us to anticipate what will happen next.
Agreement, Decree, Plan and Order
It is worth clarifying matters and putting everything in its proper place: the Government (its Council of Ministers) approved an initial Decree, 463/2020, of 14 March; the Congress of Deputies authorised the latest extension until 00:00 on 24 May by an Agreement of 6 May 2020, subject to certain conditions; Royal Decree 514/2020, of 8 May, reproduces what was authorised by Congress and, subsequently, the Minister of Health approves, among others, Order SND/399/2020, on 9 May, also incorporating many of the criteria set out in advance in another, separate “document”, the so-called “Plan for the de-escalation of the extraordinary measures to address the Covid 19 pandemic”(also called “Plan for the transition towards the new normal”) also “approved” by the Council of Ministers at its meeting of 28 April 2020, but without the status of a legal provision. This is a “Plan”, which is neither binding nor open to legal challenge, something akin to a framework for decision-making which, until embodied in a Decree, Order or resolution, has no coercive force. A kind of decision-making tool, created ad hoc, to serve as a link between the Committees of technical experts constituted on an exceptional basis and the bodies empowered to take decisions (the Council of Ministers in some cases, but also the Minister of Health in others). Particular account should be taken of Annex II to that Plan which sets out the indicative forecast for lifting the restrictions and refers to sectors of activity or economic categories.
In a last-minute manoeuvre, the scheme also includes a kind of “co-regulation” between the Central Government and the Autonomous Communities, already termed “co-governance” in an Order that has been issued.
Thus, in these days of crisis we are all learning new terms, new concepts, which also follow one another at a dizzying pace over time and in the Official Gazette almost every day (two were published this Saturday, numbers 129 and 130).
What of gambling establishments and activities in all this?
In reality, as regards the various gambling establishments, there is little beyond what has already been said (inclusion in the Annex to the initial Royal Decree 463/2020, as a “suspended” activity). We must therefore undertake an exercise in interpretation wherever we find any indication or hint in what has already been published.
Order SND/399/2020 finally gives “normative effect” to many of the criteria envisaged in the Plan, which provides for 4 phases (the current Phase 0, plus Phases I, II and III), and this first Order is devoted to implementing Phase I, and will apply only from 11 May (Monday), in the territories indicated in the Annex. For the time being, these do not include major cities such as Madrid, Barcelona or Valencia.
This Phase I, and this Order, do not apply to any gambling premises or establishment, with the curious exception of State Lottery Points of Sale, although in fact these were not expressly mentioned in the March Decree. Perhaps owing to terminological confusion, the second paragraph of Article 10.3 refers to the reopening of “entities holding concessions for public gambling at State level” (except for those points of sale located in shopping centres or retail parks without an independent entrance). The lapse is forgiven since this is a Health Order, but the only “concession holders” for these games, which in fact refers to lotteries, are ONCE (in respect of ONCE games), and some former “Lottery Agencies” (no more than 100 will remain), which did not opt to move to the private-law regime like the other thousands of remaining points of sale, and which continue to be regarded as holders of an “administrative concession”
It is true that in this Phase I there is a specific regime for hospitality and catering premises, where type B gaming machines are normally installed, but only the reopening of outdoor terraces is permitted, precisely where the placement of these gaming machines is not permitted under virtually all gambling regulations.
In Phase II of the Plan (which will require a further implementing Order) there is likewise no mention of the resumption of gambling activities or the reopening of gambling premises, although by analogy with those conceptually closest to them, the interpretation that they may open, with a maximum occupancy of 1/3 of their official capacity, would be admissible. This phase envisages hospitality and catering premises opening their doors, but only for “table” service, meaning that customers will not be able to use the bar and will probably not be able to move around to approach the gaming machines either.
In Phase III of the Plan (which will also require a further implementing Order) they are not expressly mentioned either, although it is to be expected that in this phase too they will be treated in the same way as those in the closest categories, which may open with a maximum occupancy of 50% of their official capacity. In hospitality, this phase will already allow the use of the bar, with appropriate “social separation” (another new term being coined) of 1.5 metres, according to this Plan, so it appears that the use of gaming machines and other vending machines will then be feasible.
In turn, the Phases are to be applied flexibly, although reference is initially made to their implementation in a <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">very illustrative visual timetable, also Annex III to the Plan . But since the phases or “steps” (hence the term “escalation”) may entail measures moving forwards or, conversely, “regression” (another new term to bear in mind), the fact is that anything could happen to the sector-specific timetable for opening gambling establishments.
Clues, indications, generalities
As matters stand, and with the Order published today, there are only a few indirect reference points in it that may serve our purposes.
- Article 6 refers to the “hygiene measures required for the activities envisaged in this order”, many of which can be extrapolated to any premises or establishment reopening in the near future, so they will have to be taken into account. In particular, paragraph 6 encourages “payment by card or other means that do not entail physical contact between devices, avoiding, as far as possible, the use of cash”. It is a pity that, to date, Gambling Regulations have been so unreceptive to the introduction of means such as these for the use of gaming machines.
- Article 4.2 (measures for workers’ hygiene), which may also serve as a reference for other activities to reopen in later phases, refers to “clocking in by fingerprint”, but not to eliminate or prohibit it; rather, if it is retained, to “disinfect the clocking-in device before and after each use”, notifying workers of this measure, which can surely be extrapolated to gaming machine button panels.
- Article 11.3 regulates more expressly the activity of “automatic sales, “vending machines”, self-service laundries and similar facilities, the operator of which must ensure compliance with appropriate hygiene and disinfection measures for both the machines and the premises, and inform users of their proper use by displaying information notices”. It also refers to the general hygiene and cleaning rules in Article 6. This mention is made because in this phase there are premises or shops that may incorporate such machinery, which, in general, could be equivalent to gaming machines included in subsequent phases.
- By way of interpretation, in Article 9, places of worship, we find an initial normative reference to distances between those attending ceremonies: spaces with individual seats: one person per seat, with a minimum distance of one metre to be maintained; in spaces without seats: one person per square metre. Always one metre between people. With specific recommendations on the use of face masks and disinfection of the spaces used or to be used “before each service”; and that, during the activities, the disinfection of the objects touched most frequently is to be repeated.
Ultimately, we will have to await subsequent Orders to learn all the details, which appear likely to be very extensive.
Lotteries, online gambling, land-based establishments
We have already mentioned that, as regards lotteries, the foundations have been laid in this Phase I for SELAE and ONCE points of sale to reopen to the public, with the requisite distances and hygiene recommendations, so both operators will shortly determine the resumption of draws (EAJA in Catalonia has already done so for its own, although the Order refers only to those at State level.).
Online gambling and betting were at no time prevented from maintaining their offering, subject to the advertising restrictions examined on another occasion.
Land-based gambling and betting will therefore be the last to resume their activities, and it would be best to focus attention on another forum created for this purpose, which will address measures “by sector”. This is scheduled to meet on the second Wednesday of every month.
Madrid, 9 May 2020
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Loyra Abogados
www.loyra.com