Gaming & Gambling
DGOJ 2017 Report
·
The Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) has published its \»Annual Report\» for the 2017 financial year. However, this time the Report provided is solely a report on the body itself, compiling and summarising its data in what is termed an \»Activity Report\» which sets out the numerous activities carried out during the 2017 financial year, broken down by its constituent Departments or Subdirectorates, highlighting the monitoring and inspection of the numerous licensed operators, but also action against unauthorised websites, or cooperation with other bodies in combating betting manipulation; it also describes the extensive institutional work undertaken by the members of this directorate, both in Spain and internationally. The complaints and enquiries dealt with are detailed. Lastly, information is provided on the other powers it continues to exercise which affect land-based gambling: management of the Register of Prohibited Persons and the granting of authorisations for gaming machines on ships.
The amount of \»administrative fees\» (distinct from Gambling Tax, about which nothing is said) collected by the DGOJ under various processing-related headings or through the levy of 0.75/0000 on the total amount wagered amounted to 15.4 million euros in that year. Revenue from these fees should not, by definition, exceed the \»cost of the service\», yet it amounts to more than twice the expenditure budgeted for this body.
By contrast, it no longer provides detailed information on gambling figures, as in previous years, beyond online gambling. Only the aggregate data for ONCE and SELAE are included. It should be recalled that the economic data relating to online gambling fall within its remit and oversight, and are already published quarterly.
Regarding this conspicuous absence, it is nevertheless announced that the data relating to the gambling market in Spain in 2017 will be presented shortly, using a new user-interoperable format that enables information to be selected by channel, regulator-operator and type of gambling, as well as information from previous financial years.
It should be recalled that the decisions of the Gambling Policy Council, which met on 12 September 2017, evidenced an effort to collect, synthesise and publish an overview of gambling in Spain, and not merely gambling falling within State competence. At that meeting, a 2017/2018 work programme was approved, which stated the following in relation to this point:
- III. PREPARATION OF A JOINT REPORT ON GAMBLING ACTIVITY IN SPAIN.
- a. Context and objectives
In keeping with the plurality of existing spheres of competence, there are currently various public administrative sources of economic and statistical information concerning gambling activity, at both State and Autonomous Community level, without prejudice to other private initiatives in this regard.
On the State side, the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling publishes its Annual Report which, in addition to accounting for its institutional activity, seeks to provide information on the economic activity of the sector as a whole.
Drawing on that experience, as well as that of the other Autonomous Communities, the initiative would aim to place responsibility for the preparation and publication of this type of information within the Gambling Policy Council.
A report on gambling activity in Spain containing up-to-date, reliable and relevant activity data requires coordinated action among the different gambling regulators. It is considered that greater coordination and participation among all the responsible authorities, resulting from the joint nature of the project, the common design of the product and the adoption of the outcome by the Gambling Policy Council, would strengthen the quality of the information currently published through the annual report, as well as its usefulness for public and private stakeholders, providing a
truly comprehensive view of the activity from the perspective of the competent authorities.
In view of the foregoing, the framework and working method for exchanging information and collecting data for the preparation of the report would be established within the Working Groups, with the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling being responsible for its preparation. - b. Work outline
Definition of the main variables relating to the content of the report: a catalogue of the minimum data to be collected and other added-value elements,
Design and content of the data collection questionnaires
Establishment of timetables for data collection and publication of the report.
Determination of the format, scope and content of the document to be published. - c. Tentative project completion date
End of 2018.
Although the Autonomous Communities currently have exclusive competence over games of chance, wagering and gambling conducted within their respective territories, and all of them have assumed it, the data and annual reports they publish sometimes prove to be very brief and delayed, and in some cases non-existent. Moreover, their structures are far from uniform, making action by the Central State decisive.
The State continues to retain residual centralising powers, to the extent of being able to require this type of informational oversight of devolved powers:
- The “coordinating” action in relation to economic or statistical information. To standardise the data, to establish minimum content, not only in respect of the economic figures for gambling, but also to contribute to public knowledge of the contributions to the public purse from Gambling Levy revenue and the number of jobs generated by the sector. The comprehensive information provided on “online gambling” contrasts with the scant information (and, as yet, non-existent information for 2017) on other subsectors, painting a distorted picture of reality, the faithful reflection of which is one of the objectives and the raison d’être of centralised, unified information. This competence and action must be strengthened.
- Among the provisions “forgotten” in the course of day-to-day work is Organic Law 9/1992, of 23 December, on the transfer of powers to Autonomous Communities which attained autonomy through the procedure laid down in Article 143 of the Constitution, which remains fully in force on two points of current relevance: it established the Sectoral Conference (on gambling); and, as regards the matter at hand, it laid down the “Forms of oversight” of the powers transferred to the Autonomous Communities in Title III. These include two essential obligations of the Autonomous Communities receiving the powers: \»to provide the information requested by the State Administration\», and \»to maintain the level of effectiveness existing at the time of the transfer\». The penalty for failure to fulfil these obligations is extremely severe: the Government may first issue a formal demand to the Autonomous Community and, if non-compliance subsequently persists, may even suspend the powers and services, reporting to the Spanish Parliament, and may go so far as to revoke the exercise of the transferred power.Thus, the Autonomous Communities should provide data and information, and, as could be observed year after year in the Report, not all of them do so, or they do not do so adequately; to the point of having led to the complete removal of this important public information, which can only be obtained very partially and belatedly by going from one Community to another,
- Furthermore, the State retains competence over “statistics for State purposes” (Article 149.1.31 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)) and there would therefore be no obstacle whatsoever, quite the contrary, to requesting information from Public Administrations, and even from citizens or businesses, with a view to producing a genuine and effective “Report on Gambling in Spain”.
Loyra Abogados