Gaming & Gambling

If you do not like it, do not enter

Carlos Lalanda ·

The latest media campaigns concerning gambling in general (or rather, the “anti-gambling” campaigns) call for necessary reflection from every perspective.

After an initial spate of unfounded reports, a set of arguments began to be introduced on social media, and subsequently in parliamentary and assembly forums, drawing them into discussions of all manner of issues, in many cases distorted by an evident lack of knowledge of the reality.

Minors, gambling addiction, allocation of taxes, admission controls, gambling advertising, celebrities, addicts, police.

Terms that make up a decidedly appetising menu which has ultimately become “fodder” for the media. It is what sells. It increases audiences or website visits. More and more social media.

Data

Beyond any heated analysis, and with the data on the table, it all appears to be a complete exaggeration, which does not withstand even a cursory empirical analysis…… something that many, laden with prejudices, do not wish to see. Some basic strands of data to bear in mind:

Data on gambling activities. On the rise or in decline?

  1. The advent of online gambling, before and after 2012, when it was legalised, made it possible to access games of chance from PCs, mobile phones and tablets, without having to attend premises open to the public.
  2. The advent of new forms of betting, as early as 2008, but becoming widespread precisely with online betting from 2012 onwards. In the public mind, it is difficult to distinguish figures and data on “physical” betting on premises from those on online betting.
  3. The introduction of new types of machines in gambling establishments, “gaming halls”, including betting “corners”. Gaming halls and betting premises are confused with one another.

All the numerical distortions that appear in published material suffer from a genuine lack of knowledge of the actual (or “approximate”) parameters of the 3 strands above, which reveal an increase in business activity. This is logical in new lines of business that did not previously exist.

However, other subsectors of gambling activity in general show declining figures, as is the case with the principal subsectors by volume:   machines, bingo halls and casinos.

Lotteries fluctuate upwards or downwards, depending on products and periods, but overall remain stable.

Data on players.

Traditionally, there were exact data on bingo and casino users, and estimates concerning users of gaming machines in gaming halls and hospitality establishments; all of these were very small in relation to the total population; there were also data on users of public lotteries and football pools, who were far more widespread.

In the case of online gambling and its advent, the data are exact, centralised and immediately available to the DGJ (and to the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT), through the Agreement signed by both), making it possible to undertake an in-depth analysis of their composition and characteristics.

Finally, the numbers of “self-excluded persons” and gambling addicts have always been considered “minimal” and residual, as have those of minors who, circumventing more or less effective controls, gain access to gambling.

 Data on the economic importance of the gambling sector

Several of the “macro” parameters confirm that we are dealing with a sector with the following characteristics:

  1.  numerous businesses, large and small, which are the direct providers of gambling, but also of numerous ancillary and complementary activities that generate or make possible a significant percentage of GDP. In overall terms, this is estimated at 0.9%.
  2. traditional exceptional tax contributions specific to gambling feed the coffers of all the Autonomous Communities. In overall terms, private gambling alone contributed almost €1,100 million in 2018.
  3. An evident generation of employment of every kind, quantified more or less approximately. In overall terms, almost 100.00 direct jobs, twice as many if indirect jobs are included.

All of the above constitutes the “ABC” of gambling data, without which it is very difficult to hold an informed opinion. When the “micro” data are presented.

Distortions of data

Very few refer to the above categories of data beyond certain specific areas, and it is difficult to “cross-reference” them with one another and bring them together to establish causes and effects. It is therefore necessary for all those involved to reinforce their dissemination and reliability.

Businesses must make an additional effort to “contribute” their own data to research and statistical institutes or bodies, helping to centralise and simplify the results.

Public authorities must work on and “share” the data they collect directly and even pursuant to a legal obligation. This applies to the various authorities overseeing gambling as well as the tax authorities, both regional and central. Even health data concerning those affected by gambling addiction are partial or non-existent. And even the data gathered in surveys on problem gamblers or those with an addiction are insufficient and defective in their collection and analytical processing.

All of this remains very limited and inadequate.

Economists and analysts of every kind, and even communicators, should, finally, endeavour to synthesise the economic importance of the sector. The creation of “Observatories” or similar bodies, public or private, is one of the initiatives being pursued in this important field.

 Remedies.

 Is it possible to make up for “lost time” in the eyes of public opinion?

This remains an unknown. Whatever each party needs to do, let them do it.

Gambling businesses (public and private). An increased effort in the area known as “Responsible Gambling”. This is one of the manifestations of Corporate Social Responsibility that is gaining ground throughout the world in all kinds of businesses and activities. This action should not exclude the departments dedicated to this matter at SELAE or ONCE.

Public officials. Regulators. Gambling regulation must adapt to the times and to “logic” (or common sense.). Measures are being adopted to strengthen controls on players and prevent excesses at every level. Gambling advertising requires a transition towards where it always used to be:  moderation. Restrictions on the unrestricted advertising and promotion of online gambling (this is legally its current status) are a kind of common demand, except only in certain distant decision-making offices of online operations, and in some closer ones belonging to broadcasters, media outlets and entities that are the financial beneficiaries of the excessive advertising of certain games of chance.

 Public officials responsible for implementation. Parliamentarians, Governments, gambling services, various supervisors of the activity, and even behavioural psychiatrists in public hospitals. Let the cobbler stick to his last. It is logical and obligatory that each, within their duly substantiated and informed public policies, should have a share of the task. They have more than €1,100 million a year (the proceeds from the private sector alone) at their disposal to address them. This is the revenue from the Gambling Tax, a unique and special tax, with different forms. Use it. Someone has made an approximate calculation of this figure since the legalisation of gambling, understood as the normalisation of an activity widely demanded by society. And this amount exceeds €30,000 million; it seems to me that it is even more.

The joint nationwide police operation carried out last week (called ARCADE), and its recent findings and data, are tangible proof that supervisory action already exists on a routine basis and without fanfare, and that what we are facing is a product of media exaggeration.

Summary. Law, rights and hashtags.

The widespread concern among business owners who even see their establishments attacked is understandable; although, as always, the law is also there.

In a recent protest on the streets of Madrid, incensed protesters criticised police officers for preventing damage to premises through their mere presence there. This is normal in a State governed by the rule of law, unlike past eras of looting and human sacrifices on public pyres. Just as it is normal for this activity to be subject to extensive and abundant administrative intervention in business activity, following its normalisation back in 1977 with the removal of its age-old criminalisation, which extended even to players until 1983.

Let no one be deceived: the possibility of a “generalised expropriation”, or even a partial one, of authorised gambling activities and businesses was ruled out long ago, with the guarantee afforded by the Constitution and the various Laws of the Spanish legal system. By legal certainty. By the exercise of rights and freedoms, such as the right to gamble.

However,  the remedies for the present concerns and fears of an entire business sector lie rather in the battle over image and communication in current times, beyond the legal approach, which has little scope here. Nowadays, circulating a good “motto” or slogan on social media (a simple hashtag on tweeter, such as, for example, the one built around a phrase circulating yesterday: “#if you do not like it do not enter “) is more important than winning a brilliant appeal before the Courts.

Without prejudice to recourse to the law, of course, when necessary. For the protection of rights.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Loyra Abogados.

Madrid, 8 October 2019.

More publications