Gaming & Gambling

Enigma in the Balearic Islands

Carlos Lalanda ·

The recently published Law 14/2019 of the Parliament of Illes Baleares, of 29 March, (B.O.I.B. of 2 April) includes a sole Additional Provision on “legislative adjustment” with an enigmatic text:

\»The issuance within the territory of the Autonomous Community of the mandatory and binding reports on public security matters provided for in Section 2.1 b) and Section  1.1.D) of the Annex to Royal Decree 123/21995 on the transfer of functions and services from the State Administration to the Balearic Community in matters concerning casinos, gambling and betting is hereby discontinued, with retroactive effect from 8 December 2001, the date of entry into force of Decree 132/2001, of 30 November, on regulatory measures concerning gambling\».

It is not very common for a provision to abolish an obligation to issue reports with retroactive effect extending back almost 18 years. We must bear in mind that all those reports must already have been issued, and that it is impossible for them physically to \»disappear\» from the archives now;  the same applies to their effects,  by virtue of a parliamentary decision taken now.

These are the reports which the Central Administration reserved to itself, on a “mandatory and binding” basis, in relation to administrative authorisations for the installation, opening, operation and modification of all types of gambling activities and the establishments in which they take place; and for the renewal and expiry of those authorisations. The Royal Decree cited, published in the Official State Gazette (BOE) of 21 February 1995 was not so much a regulatory provision emanating from the Council of Ministers, but was in fact a \»means\» of agreeing to publish a \»negotiated rule\»: the Agreement of the State–Illes Baleares Joint Transfers Commission, setting out the transfers of powers in matters concerning gambling. Accordingly, its effectiveness and repealing effect \»for the future\» are not beyond dispute either, if the State did decide to reserve any of its intervention functions.

Finally, to complete the enigma, the aforementioned prospective mandate and its retroactivity \»to the fullest extent\» are inserted into a Law devoted to regulating strategic industrial projects in Illes Baleares, which have nothing to do with gambling.

These reports have been and continue to be issued by the police in all proceedings relating to gambling establishments, and one may ask whether there is some obscure intention behind their abolition, or whether the aim is to remove their supposedly \»binding\» effects, or, finally, whether the Balearic Parliament, in a bold exercise in support of a business activity, has decided to join the European trends towards liberalising the provision of services, embodied in the State Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM), and is at last eliminating a procedural requirement which it considers \»unnecessary\».

Since the Explanatory Memorandum says nothing about this Provision, and industrial projects have nothing to do with gambling establishments, some investigation into the matter is necessary.

 UNRAVELLING A MYSTERY

The first line of enquiry must examine the procedural incorporation of this provision into Law 14/2019, which is in fact the subsequent passage as a Law of Decree-Law 5/2018 on the aforementioned Industrial Projects, adopted as a matter of urgency and subsequently ratified in January 2019, and which said nothing about gambling or this particular “legislative adjustment” now being added. During its passage through the Balearic Parliament, the Additional Provision was introduced by means of “Amendment 1531” of the Socialist Group, on 12 February 2019, without any accompanying justification.

When it reached the Economy Committee, on 7 March, the Amendment was approved without any debate or discussion, in a separate vote, by 7 votes to 3. Finally, the Record of Proceedings of 19 March shows that there was likewise no explanation, discussion or debate concerning it, and the Provision was also put to a separate vote and approved by 33 votes in favour, 2 against and 16 abstentions.

I must acknowledge that, had I been one of the members of the Parliament, I would have abstained, for what sense does it make, without explanation or justification, to introduce an Additional Provision which has nothing to do with the subject matter of the Law and which, in such a peculiar manner, orders a State rule to cease to have effect, with retroactive effect extending back 18 years?

But the doubts which arise are much greater… was this Agreement still in force in Illes Balears, 24 years after its publication in the BOE? Had the State reserved, and does it still reserve, this function as a form of “coordination” or “cooperation” with the Autonomous Community of Illes Balears?

But also …… can the Balearic Parliament formally repeal or render ineffective, for the future, an Agreement of the aforementioned Joint Commission, and declare the retroactive effects which it declares? What is the meaning or purpose of all this?

TWO OR THREE PRECEDENTS ON THE MATTER.

Delving into the legal system, we find some surprising milestones:

1. On 11 January 1995 (the very day of the Joint Commission Agreement), a Cooperation Agreement on gambling matters was signed between the Ministry of Justice and the Interior (Mr Benlloch) and the Regional Minister for Governance (Ms Cirer). The Agreement was embodied in a Resolution published in the same  BOE of 21 February 1995 and it provided that the Ministry's Gambling Control Service would act at the request of the services of the Autonomous Community to monitor compliance with the provisions in force, and would undertake the permanent inspection of those premises. But note that the so-called “public security report” is defined as “mandatory” (it does not say “binding”); furthermore, it then refers to those reports which the bodies of the Autonomous Community “consider necessary”. The reality is that, at that time, under all the sectoral regulations, establishments required centralised authorisation from the National Gambling Commission, and it was therefore necessary for the Civil Governor's Office to “submit” a report”, without which no authorisation was granted.

Our on-the-ground investigation confirms that, to this day, this Agreement remains in force and no one has terminated it, and that these police reports continue to be prepared at the request of the bodies of the Autonomous Community.

2. As early as 2011, the Balearic Parliament had abolished the requirement for these “reports” under Royal Decree 123/1995 in the First Final Provision of Royal Decree-Law 7/2011, by ratifying it, and then also in Law 4/2012, which urgently adopted the Penalty Regime for gambling activities. Moreover, in the same legislation, this time in the Third Additional Provision, it declared that, in authorisation proceedings for all types of gambling activities, no reports, whether mandatory or binding, would be required other than those expressly provided for in the Autonomous Community's own legislation on the matter. In other words, it was almost identical to the 2019 provision, but without the retroactive effects now added.

It is true that the 2012 Law was “repealed”, together with the aforementioned Provisions, upon the entry into force of the current Law 8/2014 on Gambling in the Balearic Islands, but this was because it replaced the body of penalty rules for which it had actually been enacted. Perhaps this “excessive repeal” is what has led to these reports, already removed in 2011, now being “removed once again”.

3. Finally, very specific Supreme Court case law has expressly addressed this matter and these reports in the Balearic Islands. The judgment of the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Supreme Court of 29  March 2012 had expressly declared that these reports were mandatory and binding because the subject matter with which they deal (public security) falls within a power vested exclusively in the State, Article 149.1.29 of the Spanish Constitution (CE), and this is precisely what is reflected in the Agreement of the Joint Commission, over which the Autonomous Community has no power of disposition (in the case at issue, by failing to obtain the police report in proceedings for the authorisation of a gaming hall in 2005)

This judgment upheld the reasoning of an earlier Supreme Court (TS) judgment of 27 June 1998, which addressed the matter in relation to Catalonia, but it has also been repeatedly applied by the High Court of Justice (TSJ) of Illes Balears on 27 November 2008 (in relation to gaming halls), and likewise in its judgment of 15 January 2013, when ruling on the challenge to the relocation of the casino from Calviá to Palma de Mallorca, “partially” annulling the relocation (agreed in 2009) owing to the absence of these reports.

Finally, the Supreme Court judgment of 2012 already referred to and cited the Balearic Decree-Law of 2011 as confirmation of this reasoning. Against this background, if we conclude that these reports had already been removed from the Balearic legal system in 2011, we cannot quite understand why they are now being removed again, and, moreover, with retroactive effect.

 RESOLVING SOME UNKNOWNS WHICH IN TURN GIVE RISE TO OTHERS

Without knowing the precise background to the immediate reasons for this Amendment 1531, which must undoubtedly exist, it must be acknowledged that, formally, it is possible and lawful to introduce into a Law provisions or rules which have nothing to do with its main content, not to mention “omnibus” Laws, which encompass matters of a very diverse nature. This is a very widespread practice in all Parliaments, and is understandably criticised because it prevents precisely an in-depth debate, in context, on the matters concerned. Often, for reasons of urgency (as it happens, this is one of the last Laws formally adopted during this regional parliamentary term), the opportunity is taken to make decisions which cannot be delayed, using the route of “amendments”.

But apart from the formal aspects of the case, what is at stake is the very essence of intervention by the State and the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) in these activities, the provision of gambling services, which are business activities and do not involve any public service which the Administration must provide.

In these 24 years since the transfers to Illes Balears were agreed (it was one of the last to implement transfers in this area),  many things have changed. State powers in gambling matters have been vested in the Ministry of Finance since 2011. The Community of Illes Balears has not only assumed these powers but has also exercised them through legislation, to the point of adopting a Gambling Law, as well as numerous provisions on gaming machines and gaming halls, bingo and casinos, horse-race betting and, most recently, sports betting.

Regional Decree 132/2001, of the Government of Illes Balears, to which the Additional Provision under discussion refers, regulated administrative measures in the various gambling subsectors in the Autonomous Community which, at that time, even though the powers had been transferred, had to apply the respective State regulations on gaming machines and gaming halls on a supplementary basis, and by then the General Casino Regulations (Decree 34/1997) and several additional rules on bingo had already been adopted. Has the Parliament considered, and does it consider, for the second time, that since then the \»powers were \»transferred in their entirety and that the \»full\» exercise of that intervention no longer requires these reports?

INTERVENTION IN GAMBLING: THAT CONSTANT ENIGMA TO BE RESOLVED.

From the perspective of carrying on a business activity,  the focus should be on greater precision and predictability in the rules which restrict or impede economic activity, while of course seeking to balance the other interests at stake. Legal certainty is the true victim of these unresolved enigmas.

The debate as to \»who\» should intervene in the gambling business and \»how much\» is a matter which will always provoke discussion. However much a Parliament may decide, for ever and with a time machine travelling backwards, to eliminate police reports from the granting of authorisations. Other \»fronts for debate\» will surely open up.

In the light of the Supreme Court decisions referred to, it is not clear that the Parliament of Illes Balears  can, for its part and in the exercise of its legislative power, “render ineffective” the aforementioned Royal Decree which incorporated the Agreement of a Joint Transfers Commission into the legal system. Yet this is what happened in 2011 and now again in 2019. The State did not challenge the aforementioned legislative declaration in 2011 or 2012 by means of a conflict-of-powers procedure, and even so the police services continued, and continue, to issue the reports as though nothing had happened. We do not know whether they will continue to do so now, or whether the State, or the Autonomous Community, will simply \»terminate the Cooperation Agreement\», which remains in force.

The complexity of Spain's State of Autonomous Communities has fuelled constant, almost Byzantine discussions as to what the law in force is in many cases, and the Constitutional Court has a large number of cases concerning the determination of the extent of the powers of the State or the Autonomous Communities.

If the Autonomous Community effectively assumed its powers, no longer requiring the supporting “coordination” or “cooperation” of State officials, this does not mean that the State no longer retains concurrent powers, but which ones? Let us explore this briefly:

  1. in matters of “public security”, over which it has exclusive power (Article 149, 29 of the CE). Yes, of course, the State continues to retain power over certain aspects of public security applicable to gambling establishments, as it does over many other establishments (for example, the effects arising from Royal Decree 1338/1984 on security measures in public and private entities and establishments), particularly in relation to safes, and which contains specific provisions on  casinos, gaming halls and lottery sales outlets). But it would be fallacious to interpret this Royal Decree as giving State officials a power of veto over authorisations.
  2.  it is also thought that there is, strictly speaking, a matter of  “public order”.  It is sufficient to recall that, in those early Gambling Regulations contemporaneous with the transfer Decrees, gambling authorisations were also regarded as “discretionary” on public order grounds, and that the constitutional reservation in this area has been justified by case law. But the content of \»public order\» has been  \»transmuting\» over time, and it is difficult to invoke this ground of competence, which is not in fact expressly enshrined in the Constitution, and is identified more as an element encompassing security in relation to other values such as sanitation, decorum, etc., as a form of purely
    material or external order in the street, expressing public tranquillity. Within a changing society, far more dynamic than the legislative and judicial apparatus, I find the possible State \»veto\» difficult to justify.
  3. Finally, it is fashionable to invoke the matter of \»public health\» as an additional ground for intervention in gambling, following recent propositions concerning gambling as a cause of pathological gambling. This is an offshoot of the more recurrent and broader matter of consumer protection. But these matters have nothing to do with intervention by the State police (those of the Ministry of the Interior).

In all these treacherous areas, the \»swords remain drawn\», and no definitive solution can be predicted in the short term.

Thus, in the absence of a final solution, and I wish to confine myself to the obvious, the removal of any “Report” from authorisation proceedings is something which should always be welcomed in any sector, and the decision of the Balearic Parliament should not be spurned. Maintaining unnecessary procedures or reports appears only to feed an unnecessary bureaucratic apparatus and legal uncertainty for the pursuit of a lawful and comprehensively regulated business activity such as this.

The abolition of the aforementioned reports in such an enigmatic manner has, at least, some symbolic value in practice. Moreover, it serves as an example, because in other Autonomous Communities, with Agreements and Decrees identical to those of the Balearic Islands, they continue for now to be issued on a \»mandatory and binding\» basis.

That their effects should “relate back to 2001” is another matter, a true mystery which only a Court will be able to unravel.

Madrid, 11 April 2019.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

More publications