Gaming & Gambling

Gambling Advertising. Nothing Is as It Seems.

Carlos Lalanda ·

Gambling advertising. Nothing is as it seems.

The Regulations on Commercial Communications relating to Gambling Activities (that is, advertising, promotion and sponsorship) being promoted and processed by the Directorate for Gambling of the Ministry of Finance and Public Administrations constitute a genuine metaphysical mystery, judging by the various criticisms and comments on their text voiced in recent days by numerous individuals, associations and various entities: none agrees with another. Even those who, by their very nature, ought logically to have spoken out and did not appear to be challenged and criticised for that. It is therefore difficult to know who is right and who is wrong in their arguments, or in their silences.

Let us summarise the positions for greater clarity: some criticise the text because it is too restrictive (compared with what happens today); or because it is too permissive (compared with what it ought to be); or because it benefits some sectors over others. Or because it is very imprecise; or because it is too precise in addressing certain specific situations.

For my modest part, I shall briefly analyse the legal framework to investigate what it appears to be and, perhaps with luck, what it really is.

The need for the Regulations.

It is indisputable that these Regulations are necessary, as stated in Article 7.2 of Law 13/2011 on Gambling, to the extent that the failure to adopt them thus far has placed authorised operators in a genuine legal paradox that is very difficult to understand: their authorisations contain no restriction on advertising or promotional activities beyond good taste or manners, or certain rules “outside the Gambling Law”. This was the intention of the Government of the day when it decided to launch an initial round of authorisations back in 2011 through the implementing provisions of the Decrees on Licences and Technical Systems, leaving these fundamental Advertising Regulations for later. On the one hand, Article 7.1 clearly states that only undertakings holding authorisations, and no others, may advertise, sponsor and “promote” their gambling products; but Article 7.2 then states that such advertising may only be restricted in the authorisation itself, and in accordance with the missing Regulations.

No undertaking is known to have opted to “restrict itself” in these advertising activities in the application submitted in the First Licensing Round, or in the second one now, which would certainly have bound it as a restriction on its own authorisation. Ticking a simple box on the official application form has sufficed for this purpose.

Thus, it seems logical and clear that “pirate” operators (that is, unauthorised operators) may not engage in advertising activities (and even so, some do); it is less so that undertakings authorised to operate some form of gambling are subject to no restriction whatsoever today.

Do authorised operators therefore currently have an unlimited right to advertise under the Gambling Law? Although it may not seem so, they do.

These are Regulations on the advertising, promotion and sponsorship of games of chance ……….. and also implementing provisions on certain matters identified as “responsible gambling”.

These are two different things.

A second part of the draft Regulations is devoted to introducing certain requirements relating to “responsible gambling and user protection policies”, which have rarely been addressed precisely and systematically in our law until now.

The first court judgments addressing the nature of gambling regulations stressed precisely that these are “protective” rules, that is, rules restricting business activity with the aim of protecting players or, as the case may be, consumers of gambling services. And it is true that this is connected with advertising, promotion and sponsorship.

However, the Gambling Law requires implementing regulations for the former, not the latter. Thus, this second part of the Regulations relating to “responsible gambling” is not so much necessary as, on the other hand, advisable to regulate, at least to guide practical action that has hitherto remained undefined and without substantive detail. On this point, the draft Regulations introduce some implementing provisions for what was set out in very general terms in Article 8 (Consumer protection and responsible gambling) and Article 15 (Participants’ rights) of the Gambling Law.

In this context, nothing is said about the so-called and self-styled Responsible Gambling Advisory Council, which has no defined legal structure and meets at the offices of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ), like a sort of friends’ club. Nothing about possible forms of public-private cooperation to make a public policy on responsible gambling truly effective.

In other words, on this point the draft goes beyond what the Law initially required, but does not take it to its ultimate consequences either.

Infringements, principles, recommendations and rules.

Without becoming too lost in this, what these or other regulations are concerned with is introducing conditions or restrictions in matters where non-compliance would constitute an infringement, in this case a serious infringement defined in Article 40 d) of the Gambling Law, and as such punishable by a fine ranging from EUR 100,000 to one million (subject to the downward adjustments introduced by Article 42 of the Law).

And, as a consequence of the conduct defined as an infringement, exercising the power to require media outlets or advertisers to cease such conduct, ” …providing them with a reasoned explanation of the infringement of the applicable legislation…” (Article 7.4).

Any other approach to the starting point and the destination is “beating about the bush”, since it is clear that, if no infringement precisely defined any of these forms of conduct, everyone would do as they pleased, within their budget and marketing beliefs. Beyond a philosophical disquisition, this serves to remind us that it is all very well for a regulatory provision such as the present draft to contain “general principles” on any matter, but what will actually make its application effective is for it to contain “rules”, and clear ones, since this is what the law governing penalties requires, and in this matter we are dealing with genuine restrictions on the freedom to conduct a business, which is the context in which any advertising and promotional activity takes place. In any regulations, “principles” must help to explain and illuminate the actual regulatory restrictions and conditions or prohibitions that must be observed and which, in this case, are scattered in general terms throughout Articles 7 to 11 of the draft, and specified in detail in Articles 12 to 18, which describe what “must or must not be”.

In other words, we should not interpret the articles of the Regulations as “recommendations”, but as genuine “rules”.

General rules and exceptions.

When analysing the numerous descriptions used in the draft text to prohibit or restrict, the effort made by its drafter to set out various possible situations in which it may apply is, at the very least, commendable, but one must persevere in reading it and not stop halfway, because many of them contain genuine exceptions that negate the original intention. It is a yes but no…….. that qualifies and overturns many of these apparent conditions, restrictions and prohibitions.

The restriction on advertising live betting, the appearance of public figures in advertisements, the sale of branded merchandise for children, the presence of minors in the Christmas El Gordo draw. Many rules are imposed, but almost all contain broad qualifications or exceptions.

Once again, almost nothing is as it seems until one reaches the end of the text.

Co-regulation and self-regulation.

A substantial proportion of the draft’s provisions is devoted to blessing and sanctifying certain actual co-regulatory practices that were introduced from the very moment the Law entered into force in 2011, in the absence of Regulations on advertising. Indeed, Articles 7 to 11 confer regulatory force on the principles contained in the Code of Conduct on Commercial Communications relating to Gambling approved by Asociación Autocontrol on 7 June 2012, to which many operators subscribe.

The “self-regulation”, or its derivative “co-regulation”, provided for in the Gambling Law in relation to advertising seeks to avoid excessive administrative intervention, whereas until now the control of gambling advertising was subject to prior authorisation and, above all, exclusively to administrative enforcement controls. Through this technique of “regulated self-regulation, within what is termed “advertising self-discipline”, the intention is to chart a course for businesses to “restrict themselves voluntarily” by subscribing to Codes of Conduct, non-compliance with which may have effects of various kinds: from mere “social disapproval” or reputational consequences to genuinely legal consequences: for example, cancellation of the licence.

For now, the aforementioned Code of Ethics subscribed to by many online operators has not been what it seems, but rather a sea of confusion, because, as explained above, the only statutory advertising restrictions concerning games of chance covered by Law 13/2011 that may give rise to a penalty relate to activities carried out by and for unlicensed operators; the others concern the content of the advertising message itself (misleading advertising, encouraging behaviour harmful to health or detrimental to human dignity, discrimination on grounds of religion, sex, race or nationality, promoting violence, inciting cruelty or abuse, etc.), which need not and do not have to be included in the Gambling Law because they are contained in other legislation. In fact, even in the audiovisual field there is no time restriction on gambling advertising, which was presumed to be prohibited under gambling legislation, but only on the broadcasting of programmes which themselves conduct a specific game, from 1:00 to 5:00 (Article 7.2 of Law 7/2010), except for gambling formats and products “with a public purpose”. The Code of Ethics must therefore be amended immediately upon publication of the Decree. And Autocontrol and similar entities will have to get to work. The possibility of undertakings themselves drawing up Codes of Ethics individually is not excluded.

But caution is needed: not everything is permissible. As matters stand, our Gambling Law attaches no legal effect to non-compliance with these rules of conduct, save for the disputed “copy advice” or prior consultation, which seeks to preclude any liability to penalties, and whose value and effect have been diminished by case law. Nevertheless, the draft Decree continues to attach considerable importance to it.

Let us not be confused: I recall a singular historical moment when many bingo businesses in a certain Autonomous Community, embroiled in a “war” of promotional activities, agreed that the “gourmet menus” offered in their restaurants would not fall below EUR 7. This “self-regulation” was of no use to them, because they all committed a very serious infringement, as “any promotion” of their businesses was defined as an infringement, including offering such tasty menus at such a low price.

A genuine legal effect in relation to self-regulation would arise from a hypothetical amendment to the Law, making non-compliance with a voluntarily adopted Code of Ethics an infringement; or from a review of the authorisation.

Not everything is as it seems, including in the field of self-regulation.

Bonuses

Article 13 of the draft. Bonuses or bonus awards are the essence of so-called “promotional” activity in the case of online gambling and betting. In general, and for all types of business, they are already covered by the Consumer Law. However, the Gambling Law, specifically Article 8.2 (that is, within the very article relating to consumer protection and responsible gambling policies), establishes a clear and specific prohibition which states: “operators may not grant loans or any other form of credit or financial assistance to participants” …are “bonuses” included in this prohibition? Because, if so, they can hardly be treated in the Regulations in the way that they are. In the case of bonuses, once again, nothing is as it seems.

Sponsorship and children’s sports shirts

Although the terminology is somewhat confusing, to “sponsor” something is not equivalent to making altruistic contributions for the benefit of a cause or a charitable, cultural or sporting entity. That would be closer to patronage. Advertising sponsorship, which is what the Gambling Law covers, is precisely that: the subject matter of the “advertising contract”, as it is termed in legal scholarship, entered into with persons or organisations who undertake to carry out certain advertising activities in support of the “sponsor’s” message within the context of the sponsored party’s ordinary activity.

Article 12 of the draft seeks to ensure that advertising messages do not affect the content or its characteristics, and places particular emphasis on the protection of minors, so that gambling advertising will not be permissible in activities, sporting events or broadcasts…. but only where exclusively minors participate or where they are specifically aimed at minors; ……. Yet I cannot think of any practical case falling within this definition.

Furthermore, the use of betting operators’ trade marks on goods or services specifically designed for minors is restricted…. that is, the typical sale of children’s shirts bearing the operator’s brand. But the same article provides for a possible exception where the sponsor and the sponsored party develop educational campaigns expressly aimed at minors.

Nothing is as it seems.

These Regulations concern online gambling and betting, and lotteries ……. excluding the entire Autonomous Community sphere.

One final note on the scope of these Regulations. To which cases would they apply? It seems clear that they will apply to online gambling of “State-wide scope”. But also to all kinds of State lotteries, those of SELAE and ONCE …….. with their corresponding exceptions. As some have already pointed out, two different and conflicting systems for regulating gambling advertising coexist, depending on whether the gambling is State-wide or confined to an Autonomous Community. Thus, the paradox arises that, by tradition, the advertising rules applied to gambling within the boundaries of an Autonomous Community are generally much more restrictive than the much more liberal rules applying to State-wide gambling. This is still how the Autonomous Communities’ Gambling Laws are designed. Could those businesses that consider themselves discriminated against and disadvantaged in carrying out their advertising activities claim “more favourable treatment”?

The Gambling Law itself restricts its own application in this respect, pursuant to the requirement and combined effect of Article 2, paragraph 1, in fine, read in conjunction with Article 1: that is, it applies only to advertising activities relating to gambling of State-wide scope. For example, it does not apply to advertising activities for “Autonomous Community online” gambling (a term that many find unfathomable).

But it also relinquishes control over any “physical” manifestation of advertising by its own State licensees in a specific territory, for example, a billboard in a public space, because in these cases the authority competent to impose penalties will be, in accordance with its particular Autonomous Community Gambling Law… the Autonomous Community authority!!!!……. (Article 36.4 of the Gambling Law (LJ)). In other words, in these cases it will be necessary to consult the advertising rules in each of the 17 Autonomous Communities (CCAA). To this we add that, in audiovisual advertising, we already have certain restrictions concerning the protection of minors……, with their corresponding exceptions in relation to gambling “with a public purpose” (we no longer know what this really means, as SELAE acquired a “private” nature).

The consequences of this cocktail are unpredictable. A veritable interpretative quagmire awaits us.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández, Founding Partner of Loyra Abogados.

Article also published in Azarplus: http://www.azarplus.com/noticia.php?idnoticia=6664

More publications