Gaming & Gambling
Gambling duty on premises. In particular, gaming machines. Position as at 4 May 2020
Carlos Lalanda ·
Almost 2 months after the declaration of the state of alarm by Royal Decree 463/2020, with all gambling establishments closed under a mandatory suspension, there is a glimpse of light at the end of the tunnel, and we now have “scenarios” for the opening of premises accessible to the public in the phased lockdown-easing Plans (not legislation) that the Government is announcing.
However, although hospitality premises have a prominent place in this process (with highly controversial measures envisaged or being prepared), these Plans say nothing about premises where gambling is conducted, such as casinos, bingo halls, gaming halls or betting premises, nor about the measures to be adopted within them, nor about the gaming machines installed in them. For the time being, in legislative terms all these premises are included in the Annex to Royal Decree 463/2020, (Decree declaring the state of alarm, suspended activities), and the resumption of activity in hospitality and catering premises, expressly provided for in the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Ministerial Order of 3 May, applicable on the Islands of Gomera, Hierro, Graciosa and Formentera, a preliminary legislative experiment for everything that will follow.
Thus, it is not clear whether the Phases for opening all these premises, either fully or with capacity restrictions, will be synchronised with the resumption of the operation of machines, in the absence of any public health exception and, importantly, because the machine operator decides to do so for business reasons.
For their part, the tax measures agreed in these exceptional circumstances which affect the operation of these establishments have so far been very limited, although, in general, deferrals have been agreed for payment of the quarterly tax liabilities that had accrued when the closure began to apply. Only in some cases have more radical measures been taken, such as reducing the tax liabilities payable for those periods
CASINOS, BINGO HALLS, BETTING PREMISES
The tax rates for casino games (at gaming tables), bingo (bingo games of different types) and betting have not been included in any administrative measure issued to date and have not changed, probably on the basis that they are proportional to the amounts wagered or to gambling profits. Nor has any longer-term measure been adopted in relation to them, such as future reductions in rates more suited to the reality that is expected, or the strengthening of tax relief that remained in place by law in some cases to encourage investment or the retention of jobs (on the contrary, in certain Autonomous Communities, such as Murcia, the gradual abolition of this relief was approved last month).
Moreover, beyond Gambling Duty, nothing or almost nothing has been adopted regarding the respective Tax on Economic Activities (IAE) liabilities on establishments (or on elements of the games), in line with the mandatory closure of these establishments, the IAE also being a tax charged at fixed amounts. In particular on this point, and as is well known, casinos bear an excessive tax burden for each gaming table.
GAMING MACHINES IN GAMING HALLS, HOSPITALITY PREMISES AND OTHER GAMBLING ESTABLISHMENTS. Fixed tax charges
Unlike the special proportional taxation of certain games, some urgent measures have indeed been adopted in relation to the fixed tax charges on gaming machines in several Autonomous Communities, which are also subject to enforced inactivity. In general, by deferring or suspending the quarterly payment due at the time the state of alarm entered into force, but also some measures of greater or lesser significance regarding the fixed tax charge, depending on the territory. Below, here is a
In the near future, the taxation of gambling in land-based establishments and of machines in particular, and the extent to which it is payable, will depend on varying scenarios: Leaving aside any analysis of games taxed proportionally, it must be firmly maintained that tax debts would only be constitutionally enforceable when gambling actually takes place, when gaming machines are actually operated, although the taxation technique of fixed charges again conflicts with, and is particularly sensitive to, the interpretation of each of the scenarios. It now only remains for us to examine the operation of the above scenarios and their effect on the enforceability of Gambling Duty in the case of fixed tax charges. In the first scenario (during the state of alarm), and pending the inclusion of gambling establishments in the lockdown-easing phases, the resumption of the installation of machines could only be envisaged in a few cases in hospitality establishments (certainly not in Phase I, their placement on terraces being inconceivable and even prohibited, (and nothing has been said either about their use in the hospitality activity of merely “dispensing food”). But in Phase II, with considerable doubts, and certainly in Phase III, with the full opening of bar counters, and even with capacity restrictions, their installation could indeed resume in all types of establishments. In these few cases, the statutory reductions in tax charges agreed would remain valid and applicable, as they relate to the legal situation, irrespective of the “actual” situation. In the second scenario (once the state of alarm has been lifted), and if there were restrictions such as capacity limits, the reduction measures would not apply, and the corresponding fixed tax charge would accrue normally from then onwards (the proportional reduction in some Autonomous Communities applies only during the formal state of alarm). In this scenario, machines with the status of “temporary suspension of authorisation” would give the proprietor flexibility to choose to retain this authorisation status if considered appropriate, or to move to “active” status and pay tax in the manner prescribed for these cases. In the third (the machine operator decides not to reinstall them, even once the state of alarm has ended, for strictly business reasons, e.g. until the end of the year). Here, there would only be an opportunity to avoid taxation in those cases where it is possible to maintain the “temporary suspension” of authorisations, in the manner permitted in each Autonomous Community for all or part of the operator's stock of machines. We continue to insist that, given the close relationship between ability to pay and this special special taxation of games of chance, it will always be possible to request the rectification of self-assessments submitted, whether paid or not, when the tax contribution corresponds neither to the actual operating activity nor to that presumed when the Budget was approved, when the respective sovereign Parliaments and Assemblies set the accounts and revenue budgets for the entire year, and the various tax charges were fixed. When we were living in what is now the “Old Normal” Madrid, 5 May 2020 Carlos Lalanda Fernández. Loyra Abogados (www.loyra.com)
VARIETY OF TAX SCENARIOS AND SITUATIONS.
THE THREE SCENARIOS AND THEIR EFFECT ON THE DUTY