Gaming & Gambling
The Gambling Law in the Bill to Combat Tax Fraud
·
The Official Gazette of the Spanish Parliament has published the Bill on measures to prevent and combat tax fraud, currently at the amendment stage; it also takes the opportunity to amend the current Law 13/2011 on the Regulation of Gambling, although most of the articles amended do not concern tax matters as such. This amendment had already been submitted to public consultation in 2018 and is now being proposed again, with some new features.
According to the Bill's Explanatory Memorandum, the targeted amendment to the Gambling Law seeks to assist in combating fraud in gambling activities, in its various manifestations, and in particular by enabling appropriate mechanisms for cooperation in preventing and combating the manipulation of sporting competitions and combating fraud that may arise in sports betting. Nevertheless, it is worth examining the various initiatives separately
The first group of measures (aimed at operators) comprises the following:
- The addition of a subparagraph f) to Article 10.4 (rights and obligations of licensees), requiring them not to use trading names or websites, etc. which are identical or similar to those of unlicensed operators
- The amendment of Article 10.5 of the Law, adding two new subparagraphs: f), the obligation to draw up a fraud prevention manual including the procedures and measures implemented to identify fraud scenarios, with an obligation to inform the competent authority of transactions identified as fraudulent; and g) to ensure due diligence in monitoring participants' activity in accordance with consumption patterns, deposit and expenditure levels, means of payment, etc., with a view to preventing fraudulent and risky practices. These measures are complemented by various provisions adopted in the recent Royal Decree 958/2020 on Commercial Communications and other additional provisions
A second group of measures concerns amendments to certain requirements for obtaining an administrative licence, which must be met at the time of application (and consequently throughout its term, on the pretext that they may be reviewed):
- The amendment of Article 13, subparagraph c), concerning the absence of a record of very serious infringements in the last 4 years, the scope of which is extended to entities belonging to the same corporate group; and subparagraph k): non-payment of any financial penalties by entities belonging to the same corporate group.
- The addition of a paragraph 13.4: the need to provide evidence of compliance with the personal requirements applicable to licensees whenever any change in the share capital occurs.
The third group of provisions extends the regulator's powers under Article 21, paragraph 8, expanding the list of those required to provide information to include suppliers of games or gambling services and sponsored entities, in relation to any operators or organisers with whom they have dealings who lack the requisite authorisation; they may also be required to cease providing their services. Furthermore, the addition of a paragraph 15 expressly includes the power to combat fraud in sports betting.
In the fourth group of amendments, Article 24 (Inspection and control) adds a paragraph 6 enabling the authority responsible for gambling regulation to access data held by Spanish sports federations for the prevention of prohibited participation by players in betting.
As regards sanctioning measures:
- A new serious infringement is created by adding a new subparagraph ñ) to Article 40 (serious infringements), consisting of promoting or facilitating participation from Spain in gambling activities through websites other than those lawfully authorised by operators holding the requisite authorisations. This addition resolves the uncertainty created by certain court judgments which excluded from the scope of the infringement some particularly striking instances of sponsorship of football clubs.
- Subparagraphs e) and n) of the same Article 40 (serious infringements) are amended, concerning failure to comply with the duty to provide information or to cease providing services as laid down in the Law; and failure to comply with the requirements and obligations relating to responsible gambling and player protection laid down in the rules and provisions in force.
- A new instance of a minor infringement is added, aimed at players: participating on websites not authorised in Spain through the use of IP address masking techniques, that is, pretending to do so from a location outside Spain.
Another amendment consists of the inclusion of a new Article 47 bis, for the purpose of publishing, through the website of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ), decisions imposing penalties for serious or very serious infringements which are final at the administrative stage. This article also provides for the publication of a list of unauthorised website domains on which gambling has been offered unlawfully without a licence.
Lastly, an Eighth Additional Provision is added, providing for the supply of information by SELAE SME SA to the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT), requiring monthly reporting on prizes paid, whether or not subject to withholding tax, identifying the recipient and their legal representative and providing other information relevant for tax or fraud prevention purposes.
Significant new developments
Regardless of the relative significance of the amendments outlined above, in our view the following merit particular attention:
- Players as new persons liable for infringements
- The classification of breaches relating to responsible gambling as infringements.
- The agreement between the AEAT and SELAE.
Players as new persons liable for infringements under the Gambling Law
Until now, action by the Spanish authority was directed only at the provider of games or betting; the measures and controls adopted by the DGOJ in respect of unlawful websites (that is, those without a licence in Spain) consist of requiring their owner, in their place of origin, to implement a voluntary block on access to their server from Spanish IP addresses; or, failing this, directly blocking those websites' Internet access nodes in Spain by issuing the appropriate requirements to the telecommunications entities owning those nodes.
By contrast, a proposed new sanctioning provision specifically targets the player, introducing a minor infringement consisting of
“Participating from Spain, through the use of techniques for masking Spanish territorial IP addresses, in the gambling activities referred to in Article 2.1 offered through websites other than those lawfully authorised by gambling operators holding the requisite authorisation”
The penalty for minor infringements under the Gambling Law ranges from a written warning to a fine of 100,000 euros.
This goes far beyond the merely anecdotal: it is the first time since the repeal of Articles 349 and 350 of the 1944 Criminal Code by Organic Law 8/1983 that the State has had coercive power over citizens for participating in unlawful gambling. The repealed 1944 Criminal Code defined the offence in Article 349, second paragraph, as follows:
“Players who attend the respective (gambling) houses (shall be punished) with (penalties of) short-term imprisonment and a fine of 1,000 to 2,500 pesetas”.
And Article 575 of the Criminal Code, also repealed in 1983, identified as persons liable for a minor criminal offence:
“those who, in public places or establishments, promote or take part in any kind of games of chance which are not merely for pastime or recreation”
Not even in its vestiges in the Anti-Smuggling Law, which remained in force until 2011, had the State ever adopted a policy of imposing penalties on players. Nor did any administrative infringement make any reference to this conduct, as it fell within the personal sphere, sacred and beyond the reach of Administrative Law.
It is sufficient (or so it seemed) that the Civil Code prevents a Spanish judge from admitting a player's action to claim winnings from unlawful betting or a game of chance; and there is all the more reason for such an action to be inadmissible where that unlawful gambling is offered over the Internet by purported organisers or servers whose location is unknown or, in many cases, very far from Spanish territory.
Classification of breaches relating to responsible gambling and player protection as infringements
Another new development of considerable conceptual significance is the inclusion of a serious infringement for failure to comply with the requirements and obligations imposed in relation to responsible gambling and player protection, which lends a degree of coercive force to the rules which, here and there, impose obligations of this nature on the basis of the very ambiguous and general Article 8 of the Gambling Law. The statutory wording of the infringements currently in force contains no specific provision concerning the penalties applicable to such breaches and, in accordance with the general principle under Article 25.1 of the Spanish Constitution (CE) (“lex certa”), there is no valid basis for imposing penalties. Admittedly, the breadth and generality of the terms in which this new infringement n) is drafted in the Bill do not provide complete legal certainty either, and it should be made somewhat more specific.
Cooperation between SELAE SME SA and the AEAT
The Law's requirement to formalise an agreement between a State agency and an entity owned by that same State is striking. This is yet another confirmation that the tax obligations applicable to private undertakings also apply to SELAE, which, by its nature, is governed by Private Law.
Madrid, 17 November 2020
Gambling Practice. Loyra Abogados