Gaming & Gambling

Gambling Levy Expert Wanted

·

For some time now, many years, references to the problem of the “Gambling Tax Levy” have been a recurring feature of all the professional and business meetings that we have occasion to attend concerning the commercial operation of games of chance. This is because  this “levy” is  one of the most important and decisive  factors in this activity. A special tax, additional to the many others that tax numerous aspects of our lives.

Hundreds of commentaries and articles have been written about this special tax since it was first applied to so-called games of luck, wagering and chance in 1977, when a long prohibitionist interlude in our law was coming to an end and a new era of private commercial operation was beginning. Like two sides of the same coin, this “Gambling Tax Levy” has been regarded as inherent in the corresponding authorisation to carry on the activity, and this is still how the first possibility encompassed by the taxable event is defined.

The old “levy” must change.

But much has changed since then, over these 36 years, and although the “taxable event” and the “taxable person” remain the same, almost all the other elements and conditions of taxation have changed, and a reformulation from every perspective is necessary.  Today, what really is this “levy”? What circumstances does it cover? What differences are there between the situations to which it applies? Who should bear it? Which Administration should apply and collect it? What would be the fairest amount to pay? Should the “levy” be included in the framework and objectives of a broader tax policy?

While some of the foregoing questions are prospective, concern expediency, or look to the future, many of them should have been answered long ago. Some years ago, there was a judicial pilgrimage concerning certain legislative excesses promoted by successive Governments operating from a prohibitionist conception of games of chance, and the annulment by the ordinary and constitutional courts of several provisions that exceeded certain constitutional or ordinary legal limits was achieved.

But it proved impossible to get to the heart of the matter, owing to the ungenerous Spanish judicial system, which, as in other cases, was stranded in a veritable “bubble”, as I have had occasion to point out in other articles. Despite the warnings of many scholars and legal commentators who regarded the levy mechanism as a genuine aberration, the plain truth is that it has been difficult or impossible to get to the substance; by way of example, the Supreme Court has refused to examine a single appeal concerning the levy applied to bingo, for the simple reason that the amount of a judicial claim must be calculated by reference to the value of an individual “card” (which never exceeded 6 Euros), rather than the total amount being challenged (which may run to several million Euros). Furthermore, practically all the courts before which numerous grounds of unconstitutionality have been raised have refused to refer any question to the Constitutional Court (TC), save in relation to the aforementioned excesses in 1990 and 1996; and the same applies to possible references for preliminary rulings to the Court of Justice of the European Union raised in relation to the EU regulatory framework. And only these courts may do so, not the individual appellant.

The difficulty of undertaking any real change to the levy

Since these judicial avenues were closed, around 2005, any attempt at amendment has been entirely blocked by the immovability of the Tax Administration of the Central State or of the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), which fear any amendment from the perspective of their respective interests. The State, despite being the “nominal holder” and collecting nothing, confines itself to silence and hibernation “just in case”;  the CCAA, fearing a reduction in their revenue or accusations from the general public of lowering taxes on gambling businesses, respond only in a convoluted and distorting fashion, year after year amending and patching within their jurisdiction what remains fundamentally the same, but increasingly makes this levy a veritable regulatory “puzzle” and a veritable tax “frankenstein”.

It is enough to recall that there are currently, apparently, 3 technically distinct “Gambling Levies” in force: that deriving from a Decree of 1966, that under the Decree-Law of 1977, and that under the Law of 2011; yet these in turn provide for several different systems of application depending on each game, on whether gambling takes place in physical premises or online, or on whether it is operated in one Autonomous Community or another. Multiple systems for accrual, calculation of the taxable base, tax amounts, rates, reliefs or exemptions, methods and deadlines for payment, and even whether or not the resulting tax debts due may be deferred. If we add to this the difficulties arising from incompatibility with other taxes such as VAT, or the recent reformulations of personal income tax (IRPF) applicable to winnings, the fact is that this complex system requires the presence of genuine “full-time gambling levy experts” for a proper understanding of the whole, if steps are to be taken in any direction that will clarify the situation and provide consistent answers to the foregoing questions.

The “drums” of change to the levy

Recent calls for attention and alarm in the crisis in which we find ourselves are leading to a kind of consensus that something must be done, and no longer merely in response to the demands being made for the hypothetical arrival of major investment projects in gambling establishments (Eurovegas, BCN World, and previously Reino de D.Quijote or Gran Scala), but also by the recently designated and authorised online gambling sector, which faces the unviability of its business as a result of having to pay tax in the current manner; or in response to the absence of criteria for resolving the taxation of gambling spanning more than one Autonomous Community. Above all, however, the disappearance of many businesses operating traditional gambling establishments, or their being on the brink of collapse, and the consequent reduction in tax revenue for the territorial Treasuries, appear to have brought the need for change and reform back off the shelf, to the point that the Autonomous Community Administrations themselves are suggesting that this must be addressed, and urgently.

A sense has taken hold that amendment or reform may arrive in a somewhat curious manner, such as someone misplacing a comma when legislating, or an amendment being introduced at the last minute into each year's Budget Accompanying Law, about which nobody explains anything; or even that it may be approved without debate, or appear in the Official State Gazette (BOE) in a correction of errors. “Experts” are being sought here and there who might put matters right, but the fact is that no opportunities are in sight for undertaking full and genuine reform.

The levy on games of chance is a State tax, devolved to the CCAA insofar as its taxable event can be located territorially, and thus falling largely within the remit of the Autonomous Community Treasuries, which receive almost 100% of its current revenue. The natural channel through which this drifting ship can be brought back on course therefore lies in the forums and institutions where the financing of the Autonomous Communities is discussed and decided. Not for nothing does the entire regulatory framework depend on the structure of the Laws on Financing and on the Devolution of Taxes to the CCAA. And the constitutional framework entails this system being reviewed,  discussed and, where appropriate, renewed every 5 years, albeit with much debate and disagreement.

There is no news that anything concerning the Gambling Tax Levy has been discussed, or has appeared on the agenda, in this forum, currently centred on the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council, about which occasional reports of disagreements or heated debates are heard. In one of its five-yearly proposals, someone recalled the particular nature of this levy, and moved towards an initial system of devolving revenue; this devolution was then extended to administration and finally to its full legislative regulation, that is, moving practically towards total and unconditional devolution, which ultimately led to a situation of territorial fragmentation. This was why, in 2011, its application to online gambling had to be patched up in great haste, whereby, even though it does not fall within one of the cases of devolution, its State revenue is divided up for allocation to the CCAA according to the territorial proportion of the respective players.

The Committee of Experts for the new LOFCA

But we are on the threshold of a further five-yearly review of the application of the Organic Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities (LOFCA), and for many other reasons unrelated to all the issues raised, although sharing common roots,  we are at a point when the entire Financing System must, and will, once again be reconsidered and discussed. The winds of reform of the entire Tax System have become a veritable storm which the Government must confront, this time unable to deal with it through a Decree-Law subsequently to be ratified by the Spanish Parliament. It has therefore appointed a so-called “Committee of Experts for Tax Reform”, at the Council of Ministers meeting of 5 July last, with the formal mandate to submit a Report by February 2014, which will presumably serve as the basis for reaching some agreement and taking some action shortly thereafter.

At recent sector meetings, I have heard the Autonomous Communities' tax officials admit, in their own words,  that their hands and feet are tied when it comes to leading, or even introducing, substantial changes to gambling taxation, and they have many reasons for saying so and for invoking this “Committee of Experts” as an opportunity to channel this clamour spreading everywhere. But ….. who are the experts included in this “Committee” which could have such a great influence on resolving the problems of the Gambling Tax Levy?  Having examined the list, and being certain that it comprises  prestigious legal academics, experts in Tax Law, or economists specialising in Public Finance or Business Studies, I nevertheless cannot find a single publication, report or specific study by any of them examining, in depth or superficially, our much-debated and vilified “Gambling Tax Levy”,  which is very probably absent  from the Committee's work agenda.

Hence, in the face of this new opportunity to undertake some minimally effective line of work, I have taken the liberty of giving this article the title of an advertisement, highlighting the glaring absence: “GAMBLING LEVY EXPERT WANTED”.

Madrid.11 November 2013

Carlos Lalanda.

Partner at Loyra Abogados. www.loyra.com

Article published in some of the sector's leading magazines: Sector del Juego, elRecreativo and Joc Privat

More publications