Gaming & Gambling

Gambling Premises and Businesses: Towards Phase 4 of the “Easing of Restrictions”

Carlos Lalanda ·

In the Official State Gazette (BOE) of 30 May, Order SND/458/2020, of the same date, sets out the rules governing the application of the so-called “Phase 3” of the Plan for the transition towards a new normality (known as the Plan for the “easing of restrictions”).

Articles 41 and 42 establish the conditions for the reopening of gambling and betting establishments and premises.

Articles 18 and 19, meanwhile, establish the conditions for the provision of services in hospitality and catering establishments.

Let us review these conditions, the reopening timetables and, lastly, the current position regarding the approved “concessions” in respect of the fixed gambling tax liabilities applicable to gaming machines installed in any of these establishments.

Finally, we shall explore a hypothetical “Phase 4” of the easing of restrictions.

The conditions for opening in Phase 3.

Although doubts arose as to whether all these activities could reopen as early as Phase 2 (<a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">See in this regard our Commentary on Order 414/2020), the fact is that, until this Phase 3, gambling-related establishments and activities had not been expressly mentioned, with the exception of lottery Points of Sale, which were treated as somewhat akin to retail establishments, as early as Phase 1 in Order SND 399/2020. The argument was that, since they were expressly mentioned in the Annex to Royal Decree 463/2020 and its extensions (state of alarm) as a category distinct from other establishments, this express consideration was necessary, and analogy could not be used for that purpose.

In this new Order, Article 41 expressly mentions casinos, establishments for collective games of money and chance (a designation used in Madrid, recognisable as “bingo halls”), gaming halls, amusement arcades, raffles and tombolas, dedicated betting premises, and “other comparable premises and facilities…… as provided for in the sector-specific gambling regulations”. This last expression appears to encompass hospitality premises in which gaming machines are installed, or other establishments or areas characterised by the inclusion of these activities (e.g. betting at racecourses)

Opening in this Phase 3 is nevertheless subject to several conditions of greater or lesser importance:

  • The principal condition is that the maximum permitted occupancy is 50% of the authorised capacity, and that under no circumstances may there be more than 50 people inside the premises, including staff.
  • Systems must be in place to allow the strict counting and monitoring of occupants.
  • The positioning and use of machines must ensure an interpersonal distance of 2 metres.
  • The catering service adjoining gambling premises may reopen to the public in accordance with the rules for hospitality establishments.
  • In addition, various specific hygiene and/or prevention obligations are laid down in Article 42, concerning the use of gels or disinfectants, the cleaning and disinfection of machines, additional tasks involving machines or other shared items, ventilation tasks, etc. In this regard, it is necessary to recall, once again, the general hygiene rules laid down in Article 6, which supplement them.

For their part, Articles 18 and 19 govern the conditions for the opening of hospitality and catering establishments in this Phase 3, the principal new feature being the possibility of “consumption at the bar”, provided that a minimum distance of 2 metres between customers or groups of customers is ensured.

Unlike the previous phases—which only permitted consumption at tables, outdoors (Phase 1) or indoors (Phase 2), and led us to consider, together with the absence of any reference to gambling activities, that the installation of gaming machines on these premises was not permitted during those phases—it now appears that it is permitted, despite the same absence of any reference, because it is regarded as an activity ancillary to hospitality as such, more consistent with consumption at the bar, and because it is now possible to “establish a route to avoid crowding in certain areas and prevent contact between customers” (paragraph g). In no case is the use of these devices prohibited; their use must also, once again, comply, by reference, with the hygiene obligations laid down in Article 42 and, again, in Article 6.

Timetables

 As regards the timetable for the geographical application of the opening of these establishments and activities in Phase 3, reference must be made to the general dates being approved, which, although complex, can very probably be summarised by the following territories and dates:

  • 1 June: In La Gomera, El Hierro, La Graciosa and Formentera
  • 8 June: In most of the Territory, which is currently in Phase 2
  • 22 June: In the remaining Territories, which are currently in Phase 1.

However, the state of alarm is expected to be extended until 24:00 on 21 June, as appears likely to be approved next Wednesday. It has also been announced that the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) will even be given the power, during this final extension, to agree at any time to move between phases, and even to complete them. What will happen in those territories where the process has already been completed before 22 June? Or in those where this Phase 3 is in place on that date? Will there be a subsequent “Autonomous Community phase 3”, or even a “phase 4\»? What might they entail?

Phases, the state of alarm and restrictions

 We have already stressed in other commentaries that the phases of the easing of restrictions have been no more than components and stages of a “Plan”, approved as a guideline by the Council of Ministers, but without any regulatory force until they finally became the subject matter and content of the various Ministerial Orders 399/2020 (Phase 1); Order 414/2020 (Phase 2); and now Order 458/2020) (Phase 3), all of which have already been discussed.

And, indeed, they have adhered quite closely to what was planned, save for corrections of detail regarding capacity, temporal application, etc.

Under an exceptional legal regime such as the “state of alarm”, all these Orders have been issued under the principal direction of the Minister for Health, empowered for these purposes because this is a health crisis (just as responsibility would have fallen to another minister or authority in another Department had the subject matter been different).

Once the state of alarm is lifted, the “ordinary legal framework” in this case largely restores matters to their original position, and the respective Autonomous Communities, in accordance with their constitutional competence in health administration, must adopt the measures they consider appropriate, whether by maintaining the Ministerial Orders in force (as regards their substantive content), approving other measures, or even adopting a different Plan.

If, as is anticipated and announced, the final extension includes the power for the CCAA to decide which phases apply in their territory, and even to bring them to an end, it seems obvious to say that, at that point, or by the time the extension ends (presumably at 24:00 on 21 June), it would be advisable to have anticipated the restrictions that may apply…. If there are to be any.

“Phase 4” may even consist of a return to the “new normality”, with many or some of the restrictions currently in force, or perhaps none. It should be recalled, for example, that before the state of alarm was approved, some CCAA issued restrictive rules, as in Madrid (Autonomous Community Order 344/2020, of 10 March), pursuant to general State legislation such as the General Health Law, or Autonomous Community legislation, the Autonomous Community General Public Health Law; and that these may provide a basis for measures restricting economic activities to a greater or lesser degree, such as maximum occupancy limits for establishments or public entertainment events. This “Phase 4”, or “restricted normality”, may last for as long as the “Autonomous Community medical regulator” considers appropriate in the circumstances, naturally within the parameters of technical discretion, always subject to review under general principles such as proportionality, which must be observed in all cases.

The decisions adopted in this new phase will have to be scrutinised closely, since whether \»normality\» is full or restricted will depend on them.

The measures approved in respect of the Gambling Tax applicable to gaming machines are insufficient

Meanwhile, the measures adopted by the CCAA to address the tax consequences arising directly from the closure of premises and the suspension of all gambling activities remain insufficient, at least as regards the taxation of gaming machines through the method of “fixed tax liabilities”, which can only be reconciled with the constitutional principle of economic capacity if the machines can actually be operated.

We have referred to this in previous commentaries, and during these exceptional months some of them have been adopting measures to reduce these liabilities, in some cases by directly reducing the fixed liability, and in others by reference and in proportion to the duration of the state of alarm.

The position regarding these measures is summarised in the

More publications