Gaming & Gambling
GAMBLING TAX APPLICABLE TO GAMING MACHINES. Position as at 11-4-2020.
·
General position as at 11-4-2020.
With 4 weeks having elapsed since the state of alarm was first imposed in response to the coronavirus crisis, a further extension of the state of alarm until 26 April (at 0:00) has been approved, and it will also probably be extended beyond that date, through successive \»changing states of alarm\».
For the time being, this situation has resulted in the closure of all establishments open to the public in which automatic gaming machines were being operated, and the Public Authorities responsible for the Gambling Tax applicable to these machines have responded in different ways regarding its collection.
Years ago, upon acquiring powers to administer, collect and regulate this tax, the Autonomous Communities opted to retain the effective tax administration formula originally introduced at State level, consisting of levying fixed annual amounts for each automatic gaming machine, with different amounts depending on categories, types and classes. Moreover, in some cases the full amount continues to accrue on 1 January; in others, liability is divided into successive quarterly or half-yearly accruals.
The closure of establishments means that the taxable event has not occurred or will not occur for a period of varying length but very specifically defined in law (neither can the authorisation granted be exercised nor can gambling take place), and for that reason, and in accordance with the Constitution, it is essential to establish measures and mechanisms recognising this exceptional situation, which must result in a reduction in the tax burden corresponding to the temporary absence of the taxable event. Any other solution would clearly run counter to constitutional principles of taxation, as we have already indicated in previous comments.
Different measures adopted by each Autonomous Community
So far, only some Autonomous Communities have responded in this area, as summarised in where the various measures adopted to date can be seen, and which may be classified as follows:
- Autonomous Communities where relief from/reduction of the fixed amounts has already been allowed by legislation in a proportion more or less equivalent to the period of closure under the state of alarm: Andalusia and Extremadura have agreed to 50% relief on the amount payable for the second half-year, in addition to postponing the deadlines for the payment periods. In the Valencian Community, Canary Islands and Catalonia a much more precise legislative decision has been adopted: the amounts payable for the first and second quarters are reduced in proportion to the period of closure.
- Autonomous Communities which have opted to \»extend\» the payment deadline, that is, the dates for payment of the amount corresponding to the first or second tax instalment (Aragon, Cantabria, Castilla la Mancha, Madrid, Navarre, Murcia and the three Basque Territories); also in the preceding cases where relief has been granted on the amounts payable (except in Catalonia, where they have been \»suspended\»). In the case of Galicia the payment deadline for the first self-assessment has also been extended until 30 June, as the state of alarm has, in turn, been extended beyond the previously envisaged date of 20 April.
- Autonomous Communities which have opted to \»suspend\» the deadline for filing self-assessments (Catalonia and Asturias). This mechanism simply means that, on the day the state of alarm is lifted, the scheduled filing deadlines will come back into force. In the case of Catalonia, the suspension came into force on 19 March, meaning that self-assessments for the 1st quarter which had not yet been filed (with a scheduled deadline of 20/1) must have been filed when it is lifted; in both Communities, however, the measure would affect the next payment period, from 1 to 20 June, if the state of alarm were still in force.
- Autonomous Communities which have not adopted any relief measures in relation to fixed-amount gambling taxes. (Castile and León, Illes Balears, and La Rioja). Furthermore, in the Autonomous Cities of Ceuta and Melilla neither reductions in the amounts payable nor extensions or suspensions of deadlines apply, since they are governed by State legislation, which has not so far reduced the amounts payable, and self-assessments must be filed within the same deadlines as before, although a deferral of payment may be requested. Some of those in this group are likely to adopt a measure relating to this tax, since they have not even adopted measures relating to other taxes and may be about to do so.
We can already see that the picture today is varied, and that taxpayers' reactions to the different situations vary markedly, depending on the extent of the response given by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA).
Possible measures for taxpayers
In the face of the varied measures taken by the respective taxing authority, the responses of the affected taxpayer, afforded greater or lesser relief, are contingent on several factors. Although suspensions or extensions of payment deadlines are always welcome, unless they are accompanied by a reduction in the amount payable in one form or another, the taxpayer will ultimately be compelled to respond. We outline the various situations and possible actions:
Autonomous Communities in which the amount payable is annual and has not been reduced or made subject to relief.
It will be necessary to wait until the end of the state of alarm, but also until the end of the annual tax period, to determine the actual consequences of the premises closure measures. With that information and evidence a claim may be submitted, and, if it is rejected, avenues of appeal before the economic-administrative bodies and the courts may be pursued, seeking the amendment of the self-assessments filed and of the accrued tax liability and, where appropriate, repayment of amounts unduly paid.
Autonomous Communities in which the amount payable is quarterly/half-yearly and has not been reduced or made subject to relief.
It will be necessary to wait until the end of the state of alarm, and also until the end of the quarterly or half-yearly tax period, to determine the actual consequences of the premises closure measures and, as in the preceding case, submit the aforementioned claims.
In this case, it is also possible to apply for/notify the so-called \»temporary deactivation\» of the authorisation in the specific cases where this is envisaged as necessary, to prevent \»accrual\» (that is, the obligation to pay) in subsequent tax periods. This mechanism varies, and in some Communities it is not provided for under that name in the Gaming Machine Regulations, or is permitted only in respect of part of each company's stock of machines. In these cases, and provided that closure or inactivity of the establishment is clearly anticipated for subsequent periods, it is advisable in any event to submit the deactivation request, even if it is subsequently necessary to pursue appeals should that request be \»rejected\» or \»declared inadmissible\».
Autonomous Communities in which the amount payable is quarterly and has been reduced or made subject to relief
This is the most favourable situation, but it is necessary to check whether the reduction is adequate (proportionate to the days of closure, at least) or depends on other conditions, as in the case of Andalusia, Extremadura and the Valencian Community, where the reduction has been made conditional upon keeping the administrative authorisation in force, that is, \»paying tax without any reduction \» in the last two quarters of the year, even if the establishment in which the machine had been installed remains closed.
In the cases in this group, since these are tax periods which have not yet elapsed and in respect of which tax has not yet accrued, temporary suspension of the authorisation could also be chosen, on the same terms as indicated for the situation of the preceding group.
Thus, although in most cases relief has been afforded in respect of the most pressing obligation, namely payment, it is necessary and urgent for the various competent Public Authorities to comply with the constitutional principle of ability to pay and to reduce or amend the amounts payable, since otherwise taxpayers will need to use the instruments and avenues of appeal provided for by law.
Madrid, 11 April 2020.
Loyra Abogados.