Gaming & Gambling
Gambling Tax in the Valencian Community. Measures relating to the state of alarm
Carlos Lalanda ·
Today's DOGV, Monday 30/3/2020, has published Decree-Law 1/2020, of 27 March, which includes, among other measures, tax measures affecting gambling tax in all its applications, and especially gaming machines, which in this Community, as in some others, takes the form of fixed quarterly charges of varying amounts according to type and category.
On the one hand, Article 9, referring jointly to Transfer Tax and Stamp Duty (ITPAJD), Inheritance and Gift Tax, and Gambling Tax without specifying types of gambling or establishments, refers to the deadlines for submitting self-assessments which have expired during the state of alarm, which <span style=\" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">are extended by one month from the day on which the end of the state of alarm is declared.
In the case of casinos, the tax period is quarterly and the next deadline for submitting self-assessments is 30 April; for electronic bingo, the tax period is monthly, and the deadline for submitting self-assessments expires at the end of the following month, so that, in respect of activity during February, the deadline expires on 31 March, and these will be deferred under that extension. In the case of ordinary bingo, the tax liability arises upon the purchase of bingo cards, which is clearly at a standstill at present.
The deadline for self-assessment of the tax on machines for the first-quarter period is set at 1 to 30 April, so that, if the state of alarm is lifted on 11 April, as envisaged, THIS EXTENSION WILL NOT OPERATE IN PRACTICE. It would only apply if the state of alarm were extended until 30 April. If the extension were to run until the 29th, there would still be one day left to submit the return.
On the other hand, in Article 10 (devoted exclusively to Gambling Tax applicable to gaming machines), it is provided that
\»a relief of 100 per cent of the gross liability for the tax on games of chance, betting or gambling shall be granted, in respect of the operation of automatic machines and devices referred to in Article 15.One of Law 13/1997, of 23 December, of the Generalitat Valenciana, regulating the Autonomous Community component of personal income tax (IRPF) and the other devolved taxes, for the portion corresponding proportionately to the days elapsed from the entry into force of Royal Decree 463/2020 until the date on which this state of alarm ends.
It shall be a requirement for the application of the relief that the machine remain in operation for at least the two calendar quarters following that in which the state of alarm ends.\».
It is commendable that this measure seeks to align the application of the tax with the principles of tax justice to which we have referred extensively in another commentary on this issue: \»Coronavirus and taxation of gaming machines. Crossroads\»
This measure admits and allows-
1. A proportionate reduction in the liability self-assessed for the first quarter, in a proportion of exactly 18/91 days (the sum of the days from the date of the state of alarm, 14-3, to 30-3, out of a total of 91 days in the quarter)
2. Self-assessment for the second quarter in proportion to the time during which, legally and objectively, the state of alarm remains in force. For example, if it is lifted on the envisaged date of 11 April, the reduction will be 11/91, in the self-assessment to be submitted from 1 to 20 July.
However, that text does not envisage that, even once the state of alarm has officially been lifted, it may be unviable to operate the machines in the establishments where they are currently authorised, owing to the public's understandable fear of resuming their former habits all at once. Even if many establishments reopen \»officially\», it will almost certainly be necessary to reduce the existing stock of machines, even temporarily (from two machines to one, or from 20 to 10, for example). The tax measure adopted does not envisage that it should be the business operator who decides how and how many machines can be operated once the suspension of activities has formally been lifted. The reduced fixed charge will apply in the second quarter in the aforementioned reduced proportion, whether or not the machine is installed.
If the measure is applied without more, the following situation may unfortunately be very common: it may be necessary to pay 80/91 of the second-quarter charge, even though the particular machine is not installed…… and, moreover, the remaining two quarters must inevitably be paid. Of course, if things go badly, it will be better to request the temporary suspension of the authorisation for the last two quarters and lose the reduction for the first and second quarters. Or better still, from now and before 31 March, to request the temporary suspension of the authorisation, avoiding the entire chain of subsequent quarterly obligations, and wait to see how the uncertainties identified are resolved: when the state of alarm will be lifted, and when the operation of establishments currently closed to the public can return to normal. There would still be time to decide in which cases it is advisable to resume activity, or initially to forgo the reduction gained in the first quarter.
The dilemma is indeed very complex: simply to accept the conditional reduction, with its evident limitations in terms of tax justice, or to request a temporary suspension which is much more closely aligned with the constitutional principle, but uncertain. The cumbersome position is that the Valencian Community's Gaming Machine Regulations provide (Article 26.8) that this suspension must be \»requested\» 30 days before the effective date of deregistration, when in reality it is a temporary waiver of the exercise of a right (that is, one to be accepted immediately by the Administration if it does not prejudice third-party rights); and only allow this in respect of part of each company's stock of machines.
Madrid, 30 March 2020
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.