Gaming & Gambling
Governing by “Agreement-Law”.
Carlos Lalanda ·
In these exceptional times, many complain of excessive governance by the Central Government and of the concentration of powers in a legal situation of a “state of alarm” declared as a consequence of the Covid 19 health crisis, a situation and state nevertheless provided for in the legal system in force.
Some are surprised that, at a stroke of the pen and following a meeting at Moncloa, citizens are stripped of certain fundamental rights and basic freedoms such as freedom of movement are restricted. From another perspective, some Autonomous Communities express perplexity at the assumption, under such a state, of many of the powers they had internalised as “their own”, supposedly derived from some form of primordial federalised sovereignty.
But all, or almost all, of this is provided for in the Constitution and in the Organic Law implementing it in 1981, as are the formalities for approval, by means of a simple Decree, without any prior procedure, and immediate submission to the Congress of Deputies. The sovereign legislative authority retains all its powers and, even with the requisite physical precautions to prevent viral infection in this case, must function fully in this situation.
The Decree and declaration have a duration limited to 15 days, and are adopted under a formal procedure and with safeguards. Government is thus conducted by means of a kind of “Agreement equivalent to a Law”.
Agreements with a “claim to be Law\» issued by several Autonomous Community Governments
Let us now consider how, in quite a number of Autonomous Communities, numerous meetings of the regional executives since late 2018 have resolved upon a so-called “suspension” of the granting of new gambling licences and authorisations, in many cases through mere “Agreements” which, by contrast, have no support whatsoever in the legal framework underpinning administrative intervention in this business activity.
Without any prior formality or any safeguard whatsoever. In some cases, with reference to indefinite time limits, or with a fixed date capable of extension without any condition.
This manner of governing, by means of a “general Agreement”, is provided for neither in the general laws governing the respective governing bodies nor in the specific gambling laws, and, if legal doctrine and case law on this issue were applied, these would amount to no more than mere orders or instructions to the officials responsible for processing licences, and would moreover contravene the Regulations which, as general provisions, establish the framework for the right of private parties to obtain the various licences and authorisations they regulate and which remain available to applicants. Business activity relating to games of chance is an “activity which is inherently free”, as the Constitutional Court held from a very early stage, and subsequently the courts of justice.
We thus find ourselves faced with Agreements which purport to rank above general administrative Regulations, something akin to “Agreements having the force of Law”.
Restrictions on the granting of gambling licences in several Autonomous Communities
As a consequence of a dubious “de facto state of alarm”, distinct from and preceding the now formal state caused by Covid 19, and encouraged by campaigns and hoaxes of various kinds and intentions, many Autonomous Community administrations, in a kind of headlong race between Governments, have for some time now adopted measures of various kinds, regulatory or otherwise, on the pretext of undertaking “planning” for these business sectors, which in many cases already existed, but without previously heeding it or having attached any great importance to it. Such “planning” is provided for in almost all regional Gambling Laws, but the courts have already warned that it must be undertaken with all legal safeguards. Let us recall the legal and constitutional principles and requirements: freedom of enterprise, a statement of reasons, proportionality …. and form ….. that is to say, they must be adopted by means of regulatory instruments (a Decree or Order); and be subject to the rules and safeguards governing the preparation of any Regulation.
There is a first group of Communities which, in one way or another, have respected and maintained, albeit in a convoluted manner, the formalities required for these interventions. We may thus cite:
The Governing Council of Extremadura approved, with lightning speed, Decree-Law 1/2019, which was subsequently ratified by the Extremadura Assembly, introducing numerous restrictions on the granting of new authorisations for gaming halls and betting premises (without suspending them entirely).
The Consello of the Xunta de Galicia did the same on 16 May 2019, but through a mere “Agreement” suspending the granting of new authorisations for gaming halls and betting premises; this was clearly provisional, since it immediately began processing a regional Decree which materialised on 4 July as Decree 72/2019. Then the Law on Fiscal Measures for 2020 established by law the maximum number of these establishments in Galicia, effectively preventing new applications.
The Governing Council of Madrid, for its part, approved the suspension of the granting of new authorisations to open bingo halls, gaming halls, betting areas and betting premises, in Decree 21/2020, of 26 February, following its urgent processing and with retroactive effect from the date on which the commencement of the procedure became known through its website. At least in this case the formalities were observed and it was subject to the consultations and safeguards which every general provision warrants.
In Cataluña, numerical limits have long been established by way of “planning which in practice prevented almost any new authorisation or licence, or made them highly restricted. A model which finally became established after a judicial odyssey.
But in other Autonomous Communities there has been less good fortune in terms of safeguards, in this mad race to restrict the exercise of a business activity regulated to the point of exhaustion in all of them, and we thus find several Government Agreements published in the respective Official Gazettes, this time in their striking section entitled “Other provisions”, intended for everything that cannot be classified within the category of general regulatory provisions. The growing list includes at least the following to date:
In Murcia, the Agreement of the Governing Council of 19 September 2018, which suspended the granting of new authorisations and favourable reports for the operation of bingo halls, gaming halls and betting premises until their planning was approved. A year and a half later, nothing is known of it.
In Navarra, the Agreement of the Government of Navarra of 30 October 2019 proceeded to suspend the granting of new authorisations for the opening of new betting establishments, gaming halls and bingo halls, for a period of 6 months
In La Rioja, Resolution 78/2019 published the Agreement of the Governing Council of 12 November 2019 on the temporary and transitional “urgent planning” of authorisations for gaming halls (a maximum of 34) and betting shops (a maximum of 8) for a period of 6 months.
The Governing Council of Castilla La Mancha was already in the habit of restricting, by simple Government Agreement, the granting of new authorisations for machines and licences for gambling establishments, so it was easy for it to reproduce a further Agreement on 11 December 2019, published on the following 18 December in the D.O.C.M., which directly plans this activity from 2020 to 2023.
In Asturias, the Agreement of the Governing Council of 14 November 2019 extended for a further 8 months the previous Agreement of 26 March 2019, which suspended the granting of authorisations to open gambling establishments for an identical period.
In Illes Balears, the Agreement of the Governing Council of 10 January 2020 was published, resolving to “commence general planning of the gambling sector“, and suspending the granting of new authorisations for casinos, bingo halls, gaming halls, betting areas and betting premises.
And in the País Vasco, where “planning by Decree” exists, the Resolution of 14 January 2020 also published the Agreement of the Governing Council of the same day on the review of the previous planning, and the processing of new applications for authorisation or modification of gambling premises, and of new permits for gaming machines, was “suspended”.
At least in these last 7 cases, a possible “administrative appeal for reconsideration” or even an appeal before the administrative courts was offered as a safeguard, as is available against any individual administrative act.
In addition to the foregoing, in Canarias, where very specific planning for gambling establishments already exists, and its amendment has been under study and analysis for several years, Decree-Law 3/2010 of 5 March provides for the suspension of the granting of new enabling instruments for gaming halls and betting premises until the planning is definitively approved. As it was not ratified within the period laid down in the Statute of Autonomy by the Parliament of Canarias (in a state of “closure”), that Decree-Law has not in fact acquired definitive force of law, and the Government of Canarias has opted to approve a new Decree-Law, with some additions, which will probably follow the same path.
Lastly, in Cantabria, the Resolution of 3 April 2020 publishes the Agreement of the Governing Council of the preceding 19 March, suspending the granting of operating authorisations for new gaming halls and betting premises pending approval of a new Gambling Law. Without even considering the possibility of a mere appeal any longer. And its publication has been relegated in the Official Gazette to the “Miscellaneous” section.
The Autonomous Communities which have not so far pronounced so abruptly with drastic measures of this kind, errors and omissions excepted, are Castilla y León, Aragón, Comunidad Valenciana and Andalucía, which, for one reason or another, have already restricted by regulation the limited possibilities for new openings.
Real alarms, fictitious alarms
All the measures and actions described above are said to have been based on a situation of social and health \»alarm\».
The widespread impression is that the current alarm, this one real and health-related, caused by the worldwide Covid 19 pandemic, has buried and exposed the artificiality and irrelevance of the other, the “anti-gambling alarm”; and the respective Governments which intervene in and restrict business activities relating to the gambling sector in their respective territories will have to change course and focus their activity on the other great alarm and emergency already perceptible among us, the economic alarm.
The strength of the economic sector of games of chance, and in particular that of land-based establishments, has been and remains its labour-intensive nature and its generation of special tax revenues for the public purse, within the context of leisure activities, particularly in symbiosis with the hospitality sector. This evidence renders all the restrictive actions described above ineffective and inefficient, and now even ridiculous.
On the contrary, public action in its role of promoting economic activity must undertake and encourage both the maintenance and the creation and opening of any activity considered lawful, setting aside the prejudices and restrictive tendencies that have emerged.
The Governments of the Autonomous Communities, in fulfilment of their public service role, will have to play their part in the search for every euro, wherever it may be, and this must be their priority in the times ahead. That is where the next round will be played.
Madrid, 20 April 2020. Thirty-eighth day of the state of alarm due to Covid 19.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Loyra Abogados
www.loyra.com