Gaming & Gambling
The Government’s General Agreement with the O.N.C.E.
Carlos Lalanda ·
The Government’s General Agreement with the O.NC.E. (Organización Nacional de Ciegos de España)
The text of New Statutes of the ONCE” 31-12-2019) has been made public in digital publications and on social media; accordingly, the analysis can now be completed.
To understand its scope better, it is also useful first to review briefly the regulatory framework governing the ONCE.
What is the ONCE and what is its legal regime?
A distinguished lawyer for the ONCE once went so far as to say in public, when asked about this subject, that “the ONCE is what it is”. So I would not venture to contradict him here, although I must humbly set out some general principles so that the rest may be understood.
Thus, the ONCE’s legal regime has historically and nominally been framed as that of a “public-law corporation”, according to the terminology predating Law 40/2015 on the Legal Regime of the Public Sector; and it was, and remains, governed from a very distinctive perspective. On this we all agree, including the very wording of the Laws in which the Organisation is mentioned.
Law 5/2011 on the Social Economy, in its Third Additional Provision, defines the ONCE as a “unique social economy entity” whose organisation and operation comply with the provisions of the laws and the specific rules applicable to it, consisting essentially of Royal Decree 358/1991 on the reorganisation of the ONCE (amended several times), and its own Statutes. Among other matters, it recognises its “own legal personality and full capacity to act and to organise itself… and that it exercises functions delegated by the public administrations throughout Spanish territory, under the Protectorate of the State…”. It also provides that, in order to fulfil its purposes, it enjoys a series of public authorisations in the field of gambling.
This Law of 2011 regulates the existence and regime of associative entities and mutual societies of various kinds, and it might be understood that the ONCE is mentioned here because it is an organisation of “members” who, under its Statutes, must be blind or have a severe visual impairment. From this perspective, one might nevertheless enquire whether we are in fact dealing with an entity of an “associative” nature. (And whether it is also subject to Organic Law 1/2002 on Associations).
This legal “uniqueness” appears and reappears from every possible perspective in which the ONCE holds an exceptional position, without being comparable to other entities. It is accorded privileges in procedural and tax matters, in Social Security contributions, and even in postal matters, through various specific provisions. We could almost certainly award the ONCE the title of “champion” entity of the Additional Provisions of the Laws which mention it and to which it is subject. In Spanish law, Additional Provisions usually contain exceptions to the general regime of a legislative instrument.
In particular, in the field of gambling, on which I shall focus more closely in this commentary, when Law 13/2011 on the Regulation of Gambling established the entire regime applicable to operators of games, betting and lotteries marketed nationwide (the ONCE being one such operator), it excluded the ONCE on account of its uniqueness (Second Additional Provision), referring and deferring, once again, to its own rules on organisation and its regime.
Following Law 40/2015, which classifies Public Sector entities, it is unclear, and may have to be ruled out, whether the ONCE can be categorised as a \»State autonomous body \»(O.A), or as a “public business entity” (E.P.E), still less as a “State-owned commercial company” (S.M.E), or a State public sector foundation (F.S.P., although Fundación ONCE appears to be one), or an \»independent administrative authority\» (A.A.I.).
Thus, few options remain for bringing its regime within any legal definition beyond the basic principles outlined above. This does not alter the fact that the ONCE has always been subject to certain “ad hoc” regulatory rules, even if they were “unique, particular or individual” rules, both before and after the Spanish Constitution of 1978. Whilst this did not create any conceptual difficulty in the pre-constitutional period, in the post-constitutional period its explicit statutory basis and primary regime are contained in Royal Decree 358/1991 (the principal legislation currently in force, amended several times), which once again reiterates this uniqueness, its autonomy and self-organisation, and its importance in providing social services primarily to blind people, with express reference to “functions delegated by the Public Administrations” and under the Protectorate of the State. This Regulation also recalls that it pursues social, economic and business activities, but always informed by principles and values of solidarity, the absence of a profit motive and the objective of the general interest (which brings it closer to an associative entity of the kind mentioned above).
In addition to the Royal Decree of 1991, there are certain basic rules concerning the conduct of the games it operates, such as Royal Decrees 1336/2005 and 1706/2011 concerning the authorisation of the ONCE to operate instant lotteries, which are clearly “regulatory” in nature, albeit unique because only the ONCE operates them; but there are also other provisions which do not properly have that “regulatory” character, but rather concern self-organisation, most of which are approved internally by the General Council of the ONCE as the highest body within the organisation. These are indeed “published in the Official State Gazette (BOE)”; in fact, their publication is ordered by the Secretary-General of the Ministry within which the ONCE’s Protectorate is situated. But solely for the purposes of general information.
These “rules” include, for example:
- Principally, the ONCE’s Statutes (the current ones published in the BOE of 21 December 2019), which plainly affect and govern the Organisation’s internal relations, and public knowledge of which (by way of a Notice) is necessary because they may affect numerous “third parties” who have dealings of one kind or another with the ONCE.
- But also other rules on self-organisation, such as the detailed Regulations governing its lottery formats (which have effects in relation to players and bettors who ultimately constitute a very substantial body of “contracting parties” for lottery services).
The ONCE’s regulatory pyramid in its capacity as a lottery operator. The Agreement with the Government as its apex and cornerstone.
Focusing on the regime of rules that allow it to conduct its gambling activities and operate its various formats and commercial products, the entire regulatory pyramid described above rests, in the post-constitutional period, on one final “peculiarity” at its “apex”: it is constructed on the foundations defined in the Twentieth Additional Provision of Law 46/1985 (amended by the Fourth Additional Provision of Law 55/1999), which in turn refers to the “General Agreement between the Government of the Nation and the ONCE”. More recently, the Second Additional Provision of the Gambling Law “excludes” the ONCE from its application insofar as it differs from the provisions of that Twentieth Additional Provision and the Agreement. In reality, however, the aforementioned Twentieth Additional Provision (naturally published in the BOE) is an “empty provision”, since it refers entirely to the “Agreement” to determine the actual regime and limits of lottery authorisations, even to define the boundaries of any form of gambling other than lotteries.
Thus, this “Agreement” is the cornerstone of the entire regime governing gambling authorisations, which makes it surprising that it is not published in any official gazette, as is the case with all the other Acts or Regulations of the Organisation referred to above which lack regulatory force. Reading it directly, now that we know its contents, leads us to an initial interesting consideration regarding its legal force: the Agreement defines and declares itself to be a \»Cooperation Agreement\» between the State Administration and the ONCE (Final Provision, first paragraph); and in respect of anything requiring a general legal rule, it has the status of a “mere Protocol of Intent”. (Final Provision, second paragraph). Its signature does not give rise to legal obligations for the State (same paragraph), and legal privileges or exemptions do not bind the “future legislature” (paragraph 4).
These statements prompt obvious reflections on the statutory references to this Agreement found everywhere (is it binding or not? How, once again, might this Agreement be classified within Spanish law?).
From the perspective of the gambling regime on which we focus more closely in this commentary, this reflection extends, among many other matters, to the status within the hierarchy of rules of the Regulations governing the ONCE coupon and active lotteries, which have not hitherto been regulated by Decree (there is one governing instant lotteries). Another consideration: in the absence of other regulation in the Gambling Law, what the Agreement says is decisive in ascertaining the actual limits of the concession to operate lotteries, such as the value of the prizes offered, the potential commercial rollout of its products, and other arrangements which the State must necessarily regulate and limit, as it does in all its intervention in gambling generally.
“Findings or new developments” on reading the Agreement?
Through the ONCE’s Statutes and other general rules governing the lotteries it markets, we already know indirectly almost everything that the “Agreement” might regulate, and we therefore cannot identify any significant “new developments” from reading it. However, certain milestones can be confirmed which could only be justified if they “appear” in the Agreement; a careful reading also invites us to note certain details and to maintain certain important questions arising from its comparison with the rest of the legal system. Let us list some of them:
- The Agreement contains the Government’s commitment to allow the ONCE to set itself a long-term objective expressed as a maximum authorised volume of sales revenue of EUR 4,000 million for 2012, and an issue volume of EUR 12,000 million (Articles 13.2 and 15, 1 and 2), although these expected volumes have never been reached (I refer to the published official figures and data).
- When it has been necessary to exceed the operational limits imposed, the Agreement has been amended, in 2014 and 2015. As regards the ONC coupon, these limits were revised in 2015 (maximum coupon prices and a prize of EUR 90 million for the extraordinary draw). Subsequently, the ONCE approved the implementation of these provisions. A further revision took place with the introduction of International Lottery (Eurojackpot) draws, a format which it was considered commercially appropriate to add to the lottery offering at the time.
- The basic characteristics of different lottery formats are defined (which is of interest for comparison with the subsequent regulations for each of them and the rollout of some of those products. (Articles 16, 17 and 18). We reiterate that, under the Gambling Law, whilst the “previous” regulations remain valid, the regulations governing the various lotteries are still pending enactment (Third Transitional Provision of Law 13/2011).
- Guidelines are established for the rollout of the “sales network” and the elements for operating its games, including the Internet and the external physical network. Limits are also set on the “outsourcing of services” (Article 15.4)
- The operation of lotteries through the internet channel is addressed very briefly (Article 14.4), as is the responsible gambling “policy” (Article 15.4 d), to which only telegraphic references are made. There is no mention of, or limitation on, the advertising regime, making the recent Royal Decree 958/2020, approving the Regulations on Commercial Communications for Gambling at State Level, plainly significant and consequently applicable to the ONCE as well (once again, with several Additional Provisions and other provisions containing various exceptions for the ONCE).
- Particularly striking is the establishment of the foundations for interaction with other gambling operators, whether SELAE itself or even other land-based or online gambling operators, and for the possible acquisition of shares in operators of other online games and betting, and their financing; or the manner in which the ONCE’s sales network may be placed at the service of those operators. (Most of this potential expansion of its activities was already known, as it was included in the published Statutes). All of this is set out in detail in Section 14 of the Agreement, which merits a more considered analysis, particularly for comparison with commercial or European law.
- All of the above concerns the regulation of its position as an operator in the gambling sector. There are many other aspects requiring separate analysis, notably those concerning the regime of Corporación Empresarial ONCE S.A (CEOSA), which operates as the parent company of a commercial group with numerous activities other than operating lotteries (Section 10). Its expansion would also need to be assessed against the rules of commercial or European law.
- Finally, knowledge of the structure of the Agreement reveals that its expiry at the end of 2021 entails an obligation on the parties to sit down to negotiate in the second half of this year, 2020 (Provision 29.4). If a new ten-year Agreement is not signed, its contents will be deemed extended for a further two years.
One final reflection is this: such is the distinctive nature and complexity of the regime described that, beyond a brief and abbreviated commentary, the publication of the Agreement may merit a multidisciplinary study from a much broader perspective than the strictly legal. Almost a science.
Madrid, 22 December 2020.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Loyra Abogados.
www.loyra.com