Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Castilla La Mancha in Albacete (Second Section), of 15 March 2018
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Castilla La Mancha in Albacete (Second Section), of 15 March 2018 examines the tax consequences of gambling losses, for the purposes of their inclusion in the players’ personal income tax (IRPF) framework, in a case concerning tax years preceding the reform introduced by Law 16/2012 (with effect from 1 January 2012). Until that legislative amendment, the literal wording of the Law indicated that players placing bets were required to take into account only those games in which “winnings” arose, but not those in which the player’s position was a “losing” one. This was irrespective of whether the winning or losing games formed part of the same series or session of games, involved the same organising company or took place on the same day, in the same month or over the same full tax year. Thus, even where the final annual calculation resulted in losses, players were required to pay tax on winnings which they had not in fact obtained. Such was the “confiscatory interpretation” subsequently followed by the Tax Inspectorate in drawing up numerous inspection reports.
The 2012 amendment to IRPF, which now permits the deduction of losses, was enacted following the approval of Law 13/2011 and the commencement of online gambling operations, and eliminated any possible confiscatory interpretation. However, numerous tax inspection reports were drawn up on the basis of data obtained from operators concerning betting and gambling in previous tax years.
The Court opts for a rational interpretation of that provision, which could well have been clarified through a prior binding tax ruling, given the irrationality and absurdity of that interpretation. An earlier Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid had already foreshadowed this more rational approach, supported by the Explanatory Memorandum to Law 16/2012 itself, which justified the amendment to the wording of the Law by reference to the need to “clarify” the tax provision.