Gaming & Gambling
An imminent Royal Decree-Law
Carlos Lalanda ·
I do not know whether the national Government currently intends to prepare (or has already drafted) a Royal Decree-Law on Urgent Measures concerning Games of Chance and Betting.
But there are many cards on the table suggesting that this decision will be taken in the coming days, weeks or months, in view of the indications appearing day after day.
After more than a year in which the current Government has navigated tempestuous seas and stormy twists and turns, the subject of games of chance and betting (or the other way round, which amounts to the same thing) is one of those which, without anyone knowing exactly why, commands majorities or unanimity unheard of in the current political squabbles.
All that is needed is for the current political hiatus to become more or less clear in all scenarios, and it is about to become clear, for the Government, whether acting in a caretaker capacity or exercising its full powers, with or without a coalition, to adopt the first measures on various subjects. Among these, one is emerging as a candidate in every betting pool, an expression never more apt than here: swift and urgent measures on certain aspects of games of chance and betting.
Intervention in this sector would display two characteristics typical of the Royal Decree-Law technique: urgency and popular appeal. We would see afterwards whether necessity and effectiveness were also present. And others more specific to this case: silencing media noise and pleasing party supporters.
As far back as the Transition period, the Socialist Government of 1987 approved, by Royal Decree-Law, nothing less than the entire Penalty Regime for games of luck, wagering or chance (RDL 2 /1987), following a judgment of the Constitutional Court (TC) which exposed a gap in this essential aspect of regulation. It was subsequently processed as a Law.
The Royal Decree-Law formula was also used more recently, by the Popular Party Government in 2012, precisely to postpone the date of entry into force of the Penalty Regime under Law 13/2011, on the Regulation of Gambling, and the system of advertising sponsorships which were illegal at that time.
The same technique has lately been used in the gambling sector, at Autonomous Community level, more recently with the example of Decree-Law 4/2012 of Illes Balears, which also urgently approved a Penalty Regime that had lapsed in that territory; or, more recently still, Extremadura Decree-Law 1/2019, on measures concerning responsible gambling in land-based gambling establishments in Extremadura.
But what matters might this new and hypothetical Royal Decree-Law be expected to address?
Matters which the Royal Decree-Law may address: gambling advertising
If we are to speculate about the matters that are strong candidates for inclusion in the imaginary Royal Decree-Law discussed in this article, the most likely, and first on the starting grid, is everything relating to online gambling advertising (which includes all types of online betting and gambling).
There is already something of an outcry on this subject, the regulation of which should have been set out in calmly drafted and detailed Regulations. Indeed, it was, on a couple of occasions, in the form of a Draft Decree (it does not require the status of a Law). At some point, someone will have to state the (real) reasons why that Royal Decree was never published in the Official State Gazette (BOE), despite being one of the foundations underpinning the entire system introduced by the Gambling Law approved more than eight years ago, and which, pursuant to Article 7 thereof, needed implementing provisions, for the sake of consumer protection, responsible gambling, legal certainty, etc.
Now, the need to approve a provision immediately and urgently to define and clarify the issue is evident in view of the numerous requests from all perspectives and sectors of society, including gambling businesses.
In short, all the ingredients are there for this matter to be the principal subject of a Royal Decree-Law. But it remains to be seen…. how would it be calibrated? … Would there be a total ban, as in the recent Italian example? Would there be an amendment to the Audiovisual Law? An indiscriminate restriction to certain time slots? In addition, a restriction or abolition of welcome bonuses? Would advertising sponsorships be eliminated? All of these have featured in the numerous and disparate proposals and initiatives, and even in several Autonomous Community provisions already approved on this subject.
It also remains to be seen how the principal direct “addressees” of such a restrictive measure, besides online licence operators, would react: the media, television and radio broadcasters, which would cease to receive, or see a reduction in, the consideration under multimillion advertising contracts; or sports clubs “sponsored” by online operators, if the measures extend to these forms of advertising; and, finally, “Autocontrol” itself, the only organisation which has so far undertaken ( “ad hoc”, and in the absence of public bodies) the assessment of all online gambling advertising campaigns.
Hypothetically, this action could also affect the regime under the national General Advertising Law, but the content of that legislation actually concerns aspects of unfair competition, misleading advertising and other matters of general application, rather than a specific advertising or economic sector.
As regards the Gambling Sector, the only matters over which the national Government has competence, through the Law on the Regulation of Gambling (LRJ), are confined to gambling and betting at national level, including national lotteries, that is, gambling offered by online licensees and that conducted by SELAE and ONCE. Not land-based gambling or gambling at Autonomous Community level.
Other matters
Speculating further still, the regulation of another two or three matters related to the foregoing remains pending and frustrated, and some urgent decision could be taken on them.
First, everything relating to “responsible gambling”, although, since this is an “indeterminate” concept (we cannot even speak of an “indeterminate legal concept”), the top hat of surprises could be somewhat broader and more generous here: measures concerning Spaniards’ (mental) health, the protection of minors and that of consumers in general can offer plenty of scope in such cases: from prohibiting betting on certain events to converting the current territorially fragmented system of “self-excluded persons” into a system of single, “interoperable” inter-Autonomous Community or national registers of excluded persons; also encompassing the urgent approval of an extra-budgetary allocation for those affected by gambling addiction. The text of the aborted Decrees on advertising and responsible gambling contains more than enough material to include under this heading.
Anything fits here; imagination has no limits, although the public authorities’ desire to intervene in people’s lives ought to have them.
Secondly, several different matters had already been included in the Preliminary Draft Law on Anti-Fraud Measures, a very recurrent concept, the passage of which was halted by the calling of the election, and which sought, among other things, to amend certain points of the Law on the Regulation of Gambling:
In particular, the first group of measures (aimed at operators) consisted of amending Article 10.5 of the LRJ by adding a new paragraph f), imposing an obligation to draw up a fraud prevention manual which was to include the procedures and measures implemented to identify fraud scenarios, with an obligation to inform the competent authority of transactions detected as fraudulent.
The second group of new provisions (extending the regulator’s powers) included amending Article 21. 8 and adding a paragraph 15 to that Article, extending the list of those required to provide information to the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ): suppliers of games or gambling services, and sponsored entities, concerning those operators or organisers with which they have dealings that lack the requisite authorisation; they too could be required to cease the services they were providing. In addition, the power to combat fraud in sports betting was expressly included. Article 24 added a paragraph 6 which would enable the gambling regulatory authority to access the data of Spanish sports federations to prevent the prohibition on players’ participation in betting.
The third group, concerning Penalty Law, created or amended several categories of infringement:
A new serious infringement was created, by means of a new paragraph ñ) in Article 40 (serious infringements), consisting of promoting or facilitating participation from Spain in gambling activities through websites other than those legally authorised for operators holding the requisite authorisations.
Paragraphs e) and n) of that same Article 40 (serious infringements) were amended, concerning failure to comply with the duty to provide information or to cease providing services laid down in the Law; and failure to comply with the requirements and obligations concerning responsible gambling and player protection laid down in the rules and provisions in force.
A new case was added as a minor infringement, aimed at players: participating on websites not authorised in Spain through the use of IP address masking techniques, that is, pretending to do so from a location outside Spain.
Finally, provision was made for the inclusion of a new Article 47 bis, with the aim of publishing, through the DGOJ website, penalty decisions that had become final in administrative proceedings, imposed for serious or very serious infringements. That Article also provided for the publication of a list of unauthorised web domains on which gambling had been offered illegally without a licence (known in the jargon as “blacklists”).
As can be seen, the list to choose from is extensive. And it is better not to discuss other proposals which truly defy all logic.
Matters which the Royal Decree-Law cannot (or should not) address
One final reflection on those matters which, conversely, cannot feasibly be included, for one reason or another, in a Government Royal Decree-Law.
Advertising or promotional restrictions on land-based gambling, which clearly and indisputably fall within Autonomous Community competence, are already sufficiently adopted and implemented that the Central Government should not seek to interfere with them. The competence over such gambling assumed by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) was fully established when it was included in their respective Statutes of Autonomy, and the Constitutional Court has given the system its blessing.
For better or worse, even the Supreme Court (TS) has already ruled on the advertising of land-based gambling falling within the competence of the CCAA: advertising is not a “cross-cutting” matter over which the State may have competence; rather, Autonomous Community powers over authorisations for land-based gambling extend to “its advertising” (Supreme Court Judgment of 27 July 2017)
Accordingly, we cannot include in this exercise in speculation any measure affecting land-based games of chance (casinos, bingo halls, gaming halls, machines in hospitality establishments).
It is therefore difficult to understand, other than as “fireworks”, why the Prime Minister devoted a few words to this matter in his investiture speech (unsuccessful, but a forewarning):
“Society demands that we boldly regulate the gambling which has spread uncontrollably through the streets of our country, and in particular in lower-income districts.”
For the reasons stated, the Central Government cannot take any measure concerning the supposed lack of control over gambling in the streets, nor act in municipal districts, as some ill-informed people have understood these words to mean.
Of course, the outdated measure of “prohibiting gambling” by Spaniards could always be adopted, and the offence of games of chance reintroduced into the Criminal Code. Highly unlikely. A veritable catastrophe worthy of revolutionary or dictatorial Governments, which does not, a priori, form part of this particular conjuring trick. Moreover, and for formal reasons, this inclusion could not be effected by means of a Royal Decree-Law either; although, beware, worse things were seen against pagans in decadent Christianised Rome.
Finally, there are other matters on which there appears to be no consensus whatsoever for intervention: for example, measures affecting SELAE and ONCE lotteries and betting. There is no need to set out further reasoning: eliminating ONCE’s or the Christmas Jackpot’s advertising campaigns, or removing ONCE vendors from the streets, could amount to a pipe dream, and be highly “unpopular”, the opposite of what such a measure would seek to achieve.
Nor does the removal of the children of San Ildefonso from the Christmas Draw, or of the traditional name “Sorteo del Niño” (for the sake of the uncompromising protection of minors in relation to games of chance), appear likely. Although this too has been advocated by some purists, it has never been taken seriously, but rather as a joke, by any Government of the day.
Madrid, 1 August 2019.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández
Loyra Abogados
carlos.lalanda@loyra.com