Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the Alicante Provincial Court (Section 9, in Elche), of 16 April 2018

·


The Judgment of the Alicante Provincial Court (Section 9, in Elche), of 16 April 2018 implicitly recognises that prizes won in the lottery organised by O.I.D may be claimed through legal proceedings, without taking into account that, since its publication, the Civil Code has provided (Article 1798) that the loser has no civil right of action in the case of prohibited gambling, and cannot even claim back the amount staked. The OID lottery is not an authorised lottery and is therefore prohibited. Of course, this is a matter that the defendant, OID itself, would not be willing to plead in its favour.

The judgment also refers to precedents concerning lost ONCE or SELAE tickets as applicable to the case, reaching the conclusion that, if the evidence adduced is conclusive, it may be inferred beyond doubt that the claimant is the person who placed the bet represented by the winning ticket and is entitled to demand payment in respect of it.

Furthermore, as the holder of the winning ticket in this case was a seller affiliated with OID itself, the Court concludes that the gambling contract is entered into even in cases where the organisation’s own seller-distributor retains the tickets received for distribution and does not return them by the agreed date and time; consequently, it is inferred that, in such a case, the seller undertakes to pay for them, that is, to pay the price of the bet.

We do not know whether, once this judgment delivered in these particular terms becomes final (legal proceedings to claim the prize from prohibited gambling, recognition of “tacit” bets), the party in whose favour it was given will be able to enforce it in any way, given the repeated debts running into millions that the aforementioned OID owes to a preferential creditor, namely the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT).

More publications