Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Aragon. (Administrative Division, First Section), of 24 January 2018

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Aragon. (Administrative Division, First Section), of 24 January 2018 examines the concept of a “random prize draw” as an activity advertising bingo gambling services, and its distinction from other activities encouraging gambling. In the case examined, the “random prize draw” was offered in a bingo hall in Zaragoza, free of charge, merely for participating in a game of bingo, and consisted of awarding a prize of between 200 and 2000 Euros, in addition to the prize for the bingo game itself, without any additional draw, and solely because the participant was one number away from calling bingo.

The Aragon Gambling Administrative Service considered that this was not, strictly speaking, a “random prize draw”, but rather an additional bingo prize, not provided for in the Autonomous Community's Regulations governing this game, and that it also interfered with the game itself, ordering its cessation and, where appropriate, amendment of the terms and conditions of the draw in question.

The judgment upholds this position, since, although these random prize draws are subject only to “prior notification”, the competent authorities, in this instance the Autonomous Community authority, retain the power to exercise subsequent control over these activities, and may therefore, as in this case, require amendment of the terms and conditions of the draw where it also interferes with the game of bingo.

The definition of a random prize draw is set out in Article 3.1 of Law 13/2011 on the State regulation of gambling, and also, in Aragon, in Article 7.4 of Decree 159/2002. Furthermore, it is noteworthy that this form of gambling has in fact not been subject to State intervention since the transposition of the Bolkenstein Directive on the liberalisation of services, and that intervention by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) in these activities may continue within these limits.

The judgment explains that random prize draws are permitted to encourage bingo gambling in other Autonomous Communities, such as Madrid, but without interfering with the game itself.

More publications