Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the CJEU (First Chamber), of 22 June 2017

·

The judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 22 June 2017 concludes Case C-49/16, in which a question was referred for a preliminary ruling concerning the Hungarian legislation applicable to concessions for the provision of online gambling, referred by the Hungarian court hearing a case concerning a fine imposed on Unibet International Ltd. in 2014 for offering gambling to Hungarians from its servers in Malta, and in which the cessation of operations of the websites hu.unibet.com and hul.unibet .com. was ordered.

The judgment reiterates the settled case-law of that Court to the effect that the principle of freedom to provide services within the European Union (Article 56 TFEU) is applicable, including in relation to games of chance, and that such freedom may be prohibited or restricted where the restriction is justified by circumstances relating to the protection of consumers and recipients of these services and the protection of the social order, which may constitute overriding reasons in the public interest. Furthermore, these restrictions must be based on the necessity and proportionality of the measures adopted and on the level of protection that each State or national authority decides to ensure.  (e.g. CJEU judgment of 8-10-2010, Carmen Media Group case”).

The examination of the Hungarian legislation reveals two successive phases analysed in the judgment: that in force in June 2014, when the decision imposing the penalty was issued; and the subsequent legislation in force from August 2014, which amended certain aspects. The Court declares both incompatible with the aforementioned European principle, on different grounds. In both cases, the licensing system for private operators operated under a concession regime, although the requirements for granting such a concession changed successively.

Regime in force until August 2014. The granting of a concession required 10 years of operation in Hungary. The Court of Justice notes that, under the national legislation on which the adoption of the decision of 25 June 2014 was based, gambling operators «of proven reliability» were required to have carried on the activity of organising games of chance in Hungary for at least ten years. The Court of Justice considers that this requirement constitutes a difference in treatment, since it places gambling operators established in other Member States at a disadvantage compared with national operators, which can fulfil this requirement more easily. For this reason, the Court of Justice considers that the legislation at issue is discriminatory and therefore contrary to the principle of freedom to provide services.

Regime after August 2014. The experience required to obtain a concession was reduced to 3 years in the State which granted the authorisation, which the Court in this instance accepts as appropriate and consistent with the validity of this restriction. However, in this instance the legislation does not satisfy the requirement of transparency, in so far as neither the requirements governing the exercise of the national authorities’ powers in the procedure for awarding concessions to gambling operators «of proven reliability» nor the technical conditions with which those operators had to comply in order to submit their tenders were defined with sufficient precision.

Lastly, the consequences of this incompatibility between European law and national law extend to the invalidity of the penalties imposed for breaches of those rules. This case-law has already been referred to in earlier cases (judgment of 30-4-2014, “Pfleger and Others case”), which will very probably lead to the annulment by the national court of the penalty imposed on the appellant.

More publications