Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (Grand Chamber) of 20 February 2018
·
The Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (Grand Chamber) of 20 February 2018 upholds the Order of the General Court of the European Union (Second Chamber) of 27 October 2015 declaring inadmissible the action for annulment brought by the Kingdom of Belgium against European Commission Recommendation 2014/478/EU of 14 July 2014 on principles for the protection of consumers and players of online gambling services and for the prevention of minors from gambling online.
That Recommendation was adopted by the Commission having regard to Article 292 TFEU and was published in full in the L series of the Official Journal of the European Union. It follows, in particular, from recitals 2, 9 and 15 that the contested Recommendation, combining aspects relating, on the one hand, to the protection of consumers, including minors, in the field of online gambling services and, on the other hand, to commercial communications concerning such services, aims to protect the health of consumers and players and to minimise the economic harm that may result from compulsive or excessive gambling. According to its wording, that Recommendation sets out principles to ensure a high level of protection for consumers, players and minors with regard to online gambling services and invites Member States to draw up rules governing the information that consumers must receive about online gambling.
The Court of Justice, examining the appeal against the decision of the lower court, reiterates that the Recommendation has no mandatory effects and, furthermore, that it is in no way intended to produce binding legal effects and that the Commission never intended to confer such effects upon it; and, moreover, that it contains no explicit indication that Member States are obliged to adopt or apply the principles set out therein. Lastly, although the German or Dutch versions might contain some nuance in their wording that could suggest otherwise, such acts must be interpreted in conjunction with other versions, rather than on the basis of a single language version, and the General Court carried out that interpretation, confirming its unquestionably non-coercive nature.
In short, confirming the inadmissibility of the action brought against it by the Kingdom of Belgium.