Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (Sixth Chamber) of 28 February 2018
·
The Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (Sixth Chamber) of 28 February 2018 (Case “Sporting Odds”) declares that the Hungarian legislation on the award of concessions to operate traditional casinos and that relating to the organisation of online casino games are incompatible with European Union law.
These Hungarian rules prevent gambling operators established in another Member State from accessing the Hungarian market for such games in a discriminatory manner.
Sporting Odds is a British company holding an authorisation to organise online gambling, including casino games, in the United Kingdom.
In 2016, the Hungarian tax authority determined that Sporting Odds was providing online gambling services in Hungary without, however, holding either the concession or the authorisation required for those purposes under Hungarian legislation. For this infringement, the tax authority imposed a fine of 3,500,000 Hungarian forints (approximately EUR 11,260) on Sporting Odds.
Taking the view that the Hungarian legislation on the organisation of online gambling and, in particular, the rules relating to online casino games were contrary to European Union law, Sporting Odds brought an action before the Fővárosi Közigazgatási és Munkaügyi Bíróság (Administrative and Labour Court of the Capital) seeking annulment of the tax authority’s decision.
That court asks the Court of Justice, inter alia, whether the national rules on the organisation of traditional and online casino games are compatible with the principle of freedom to provide services.
In its judgment, the Court of Justice declares, first of all, that the fact that, in Hungary, certain forms of gambling (specifically, sports betting and horse-race betting) are subject to a public monopoly, while others (in particular, traditional and online casino games) may be organised by private operators holding the appropriate authorisation, does not call into question the compatibility of that monopoly with the principle of freedom to provide services. Indeed, a dual system of this kind does not, in itself, undermine the ability of that monopoly to achieve its objective, which consists primarily in preventing gambling addiction among citizens.
Likewise, the fact that this dual system appears to be intended not only to achieve the legitimate objectives pursued, but also to generate additional budget revenue and promote a controlled expansion of gambling does not, in itself, call into question the lawfulness of the Hungarian legal regime, provided that it genuinely pursues the attainment of those objectives.
Consequently, subject to verification by the Hungarian court as to whether those objectives are achieved, the Court of Justice states that the dual system for organising the gambling market in Hungary is compatible with European Union law.
The Court of Justice then notes that the Hungarian legislation reserves the possibility of obtaining an authorisation to organise online casino games solely to operators which operate, under a concession, a casino situated within national territory, which constitutes a discriminatory restriction. In this regard, the Court of Justice considers that this radical restriction of the principle of freedom to provide services cannot be justified by the public policy and public health objectives invoked by the Hungarian Government, since those objectives could be achieved through less restrictive measures.
As regards the question of whether Hungary guarantees, in a non-discriminatory manner, that operators can satisfy the prerequisite for obtaining an authorisation to organise online casino games (namely, holding a concession to operate a traditional casino), the Court of Justice refers to the Unibet judgment, in which it had already found, in another context, that the Hungarian legislation on access to concession contracts permitting the organisation of online gambling was unlawful.
Thus, the Court of Justice recalls, on the one hand, that, although Hungarian law provides for the possibility of issuing calls for tenders for the conclusion of concession contracts, no such calls for tenders have yet been issued in Hungary. On the other hand, the requirement that a gambling operator of «proven reliability» ―with which, under Hungarian law, the State may conclude concession contracts even without a call for tenders— must have carried on the activity of organising gambling in Hungary for ten years constitutes a difference in treatment. This requirement places gambling operators established in other Member States at a disadvantage compared with national operators, which can satisfy that requirement more easily.
In these circumstances, the Court of Justice declares that neither the Hungarian legislation on the award of concessions to operate traditional casinos nor that relating to the organisation of online casino games is compatible with the principle of freedom to provide services.