Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Andalusia (Administrative Litigation Division in Seville, Section 3), of 24 November 2016

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Andalusia
(Administrative Litigation Division in Seville, Section 3), of 24 November 2016, dismisses the appeal against the €90,000 fine imposed on Organización Impulsora de Discapacitados (O.I.D.), and jointly and severally on several members of its governing body, as well as the confiscation of gambling tickets, for a very serious infringement of the Andalusian Gambling Law, consisting of holding a lottery draw within the territory of the Autonomous Community without authorisation. The Court dismisses the submissions concerning a possible preliminary criminal issue raised by OID in respect of proceedings before the National High Court for a smuggling offence, since there is no identity of parties, subject matter or grounds; it also dismisses a possible “non bis in ídem” defence based on the initiation of other proceedings, at national level, by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling of the Ministry of Finance, since it has not been established that the alleged facts are the same; nor does it uphold that defence in relation to other penalty proceedings initiated directly against persons selling these tickets. Lastly, the existence of a possibility of authorisation for that lottery is not accepted either, because the decision concerns the infringing conduct arising from the authorisation, and not the refusal of authorisation itself; nor is the amount of the fine disproportionate, since OID has been penalised on very many occasions.
With regard to a possible reference for a preliminary ruling to the CJEU concerning a possible infringement of the Community rules relating to monopolies in games of chance and lotteries, the High Court of Justice of Andalusia has already ruled on previous occasions that such a reference is not appropriate in light of the precedent set by the Judgment of the CJEU of 23 April 2009, which justified a Member State’s decision to impose such monopolies, subject to certain conditions of proportionality and consistency with the objectives pursued by those restrictions, as this is a matter which has not been harmonised under European law.

More publications