Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Aragon (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 3), of 1 February 2018

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Aragon (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 3), of 1 February 2018. upholds on appeal two administrative penalties imposed in relation to facts arising from the operation of bingo, and annuls another which the lower court had upheld.

The first of the penalties upheld, for a very serious infringement, concerns exceeding the limits on bonus prizes which, under the Bingo Regulations, amount to a maximum of 8% of the previous month's takings, a percentage which, in the case under consideration, was exceeded by the offending entity in April 2016. These acts constitute an infringement under Article 39(a) of the Aragon Gambling Law and Article 50(k) of the Bingo Regulations (awarding prizes other than those prescribed).

The second concerns obstruction of inspection and control activities, constituting an infringement under Article 39(ñ) of the Aragon Gambling Law and Article 50(r) of the aforementioned Regulations. In this case, this consisted of failing to provide the requesting officials with the audiovisual recording of the day of the inspection, or providing only part of the recordings. Although this obstructive conduct did not prevent the infringement under investigation from being charged (namely, the infringement mentioned above, which resulted in a penalty, as we have seen), the Chamber considers that it constitutes a separate infringement which may be penalised cumulatively with the preceding infringement, and therefore upholds the penalty imposed.

However, it allows the appeal in relation to the third penalty (a fine of €15,000), precisely because it is connected with the preceding one, since the allegation concerned the absence of a sound recording system (Article 13 of the Order of 1 August 20108), and thus also an infringement of Article 40(d) of the Aragon Gambling Law. The Court considers that this conduct is subsumed within the second infringement above, and therefore annuls the penalty.

More publications